Welcome to Smogon! Take a moment to read the Introduction to Smogon for a run-down on everything Smogon, and make sure you take some time to read the global rules.
Even if you think sam is scum you fucking leave him for last because if we lynch three scum and scum choose to nightkill and we get fruit from sam then sam is cleared
Last to claim: DS., Josh, XnadrojX, Sanjana, Tonithetourguide
dodged claiming : XnadrojX, DS, JALMONT
Mafia start with 85 points. Counting DS (-5), XnadrojX (-4), BVP (+10), and assuming 4 mafia (-80), mafia have 6 points left to spend. This assumes last night got rid of a BVP, and was not a 'No-Kill' action (No-Kill is a +3). It also assumes mafia use all of their points. Therefore possible teams are:
Josh (-5) and Drookez (0) + 1 daytalk
Josh (-5) and Samoyed (+1) + 2 daytalks, 1 roleblock, or 1 rolecop
Josh (-5) and apricity (0) + 1 daytalk
Josh (-5) and CsYager (0) + 1 daytalk
or
any 2 zero-point roles (0) + 6 points worth of daytalks (-1), roleblocks (-2), and rolecops (-2)
Samoyed (-1) and any zero-point role (0) + 7 points worth of daytalks (-1), roleblocks (-2), and rolecops (-2)
Any teams that don't contain Josh have a lot of extra points to use on special actions, and I don't think mafia need that many points. We also have no evidence of that many actions being used. Therefore,
The most optimal team seems to be Josh and Samoyed, resulting in a good selection of special actions they are able to use.
Using fruit to test samo won't work without a tracker.
I'm voting him because I think he's the most likely scum slot out of drookez/josh/me/cs/hal/samo since we are assuming scum haven't taken high price roles.
I mean role-wise I don't see why the mafia wouldn't want a commuter but m2h has played very towny so I can't see myself lynching him. The no-kill is very weird at this point though. Especially if no one got hooked. I don't really get it. Maybe there's "deep scum" (ew I can't believe I said it)
this is getting annoying, either case him in light of the flips or don't but this is too late into the game for naked votes on someone with so many associations with scum