NOC D6 Mafia Game Thread [Day 4; Deadline June 1 at 6 PM EST]

Status
Not open for further replies.
Athena_57 said:
Can maybe see Mewtwo, but talk me through your DS read here? I'm not getting any non-null vibes from it
Click to expand...
There isn't really much of a read on DS here, I just didn't think DS seemed particularly scummy in that interaction. In fact the tone seems to indicate town but the whole rvs vote thing really has me torn on DS.
 
Nobody looks outright suspicious, so I'm tempted to move my vote and pressure other folks

vote Whydon

Hannahh hasn't convinced me she's town so I might move back, depending on how she continues.. however there are a few peeps that need to post asap
 
Athena_57 said:
> I call him out for it
The way you react here is bad imo
Click to expand...

Okay. That is fair. What you were talking about saying that I was responding in a timeline that doesn't make sense isn't fair.

Athena_57 said:
MewtwoHidden
Uh, that post you just quoted was made after you attacked him for dodging that question. Either you're a time traveler or my point stands :psysly:
Click to expand...

The timeline of how I responded to Samo makes sense, I don't think mentioning as an aside that Samo should explain an action. I didn't suggest he was dodging the question in the post you are referencing here

MewtwoHidden said:
your posts are getting progressively worse imo now you want to shift to whydon?

Unvote, vote samo (serious)
Click to expand...
CaffeineBoost said:
I think he's saying that Whydon isn't awkward.
Click to expand...
MewtwoHidden said:
Yeah I just misread him and had a kneejerk reaction.

I think Samo should explain the Hannah vote tho unless it was a joke.
Click to expand...

I misread a particular post and caffeine pointing it out. When I read it I thought samo was being sarcastic. When I found out that he was being serious I backed down a bit. At that point I still wanted an explanation for why he voted Hannah which I think we can all see is a pretty bad vote just based on Hannah's entrance.
 
176354

template: https://tiermaker.com/create/mafia-75025
 
Athena_57 said:
MewtwoHidden What are your thoughts on Clarinet? Give a good answer and I'll let you off the hook for tonight :psysly:
Click to expand...
I guess he left, rip. In a good mood, so dropping it anyways for a bit

Unvote
Vote Clarinet

Reason I asked is bc I'm on the fence about them myself, posts read really pure and pushes seem genuine, but I disagree w/ all his three scumreads (hannah/jordan/me) and am nullreading his townreads so eh.
Clarinet Also weird that you're ignoring Hannah's last post completely if she's (one of) your top scumreads and idt you've tried to interact with me at all. Whydon vote is especially weak, 1 vote isn't going to scare him into activity so it feels like you're avoiding having to pressure people. At least Marth has the whole angleshoot thing going on but this is just... not doing anything.
If your "could be ebil" - list is only minor scumleans the vote is less horrible but your overall stance is weak so same thing really

Looking for input here bc a lot of y'all have him as town and I can see that on tone but I'm not liking his actual gamesolving
 
Athena_57 said:
Mostly out of curiosity, where does this leave you? This seams uh, fairly contradictory
Click to expand...

Townie based on the opening post. Which was you were asking me about.

Then she made a leading post, which I can't say I like. Interestingly, Clarinet made a similarly leading post on page 12. Not enough substance to form a real scumread, but I'm keeping an eye on Clarinet now and Hannah to see how they progress
 
XnadrojX said:
So bluedoom has a "lurk as scum" meta?
Click to expand...
No, he can be lurky regardless of alignment, that's not a tell. I think someone saw him reading and not posting and ppl are using that as a reason to scumread him?
Idt it's really all that bad, I skim all the time without posting regardless of alignment but agree it makes him marginally more scummy than the other two non-posters. 4/10 wouldn't lynch
 
Athena_57 said:
No, he can be lurky regardless of alignment, that's not a tell. I think someone saw him reading and not posting and ppl are using that as a reason to scumread him?
Idt it's really all that bad, I skim all the time without posting regardless of alignment but agree it makes him marginally more scummy than the other two non-posters. 4/10 wouldn't lynch
Click to expand...
would lynch though because he often gets night1 killed because of how towny he is usually on d1
 
Ahahahhaha, I must have triggered a scum? I sure hope so, XnadrojX is my guess

as for engaging you, Athena, I'm not sure what you want.

I've observed your back and forth with DS. and it felt wasteful, that's when you were demoted to a lower position and I could no longer trust you.
 
Interesting wagon on Clarinet building. Certainly getting some strange vibes based on the way they're posting. Specifically it's hard to tell if these random thoughts they seem to be posting are fabricated. Bordering between neutral and scumlean for the time being (neutral on the list).
Samoyed said:
I do agree with mewtwo that bluedoom has schooched so he probably rolled mafia

I like clarinet
Athena: word of advice - stop talking to DS unless you want a multi-day spat
Click to expand...
Samoyed said:
View attachment 176354
template: https://tiermaker.com/create/mafia-75025
Click to expand...
So you scumread bluedoom based on inactivity yet have Zest as neutral? Also if you scum read bluedoom then why haven't you voted for them?
 
Samoy, is there a way to save your cool lists? I wanna compare them...even though I'm aware you will be careful as scum not to slip, but yes I wanna save them for progression purposes...thus revealing my intention and rendering this plan inefficient
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top