sumwun said:Some people want to simply ban baton pass Smeargle, while others wanted to ban belly drum Smeargle and preserve other baton pass sets, right? Why did the council have to choose one of those options to let others vote for? Maybe there could have been 2 stages, with the first one being "ban a move on Smeargle" versus "change nothing". If over 60% vote to nerf Smeargle, then do a second vote between "ban baton pass on Smeargle" and "ban belly drum on Smeargle". I know I posted this a little bit late, but I'm still kind of curious.
Speaking as tiering admin rather than as anyone on the council, in general Smogon’s tiering philosophy is to avoid complex bans whenever possible, and to always look at non-complex solutions first. Banning a specific move + Pokemon combination is the very definition of a complex ban, and something we try to avoid.
Now, there is a lot to be said for preserving old gens as much as possible, and to do so I think that sometimes it’s impossible to completely avoid complex bans. However, in this case there was already a complex ban created to curtail BP: Smeargle + Ingrain. The argument was that Smeargle still provided enough value to the metagame to be worth preserving, and banning Smeargle or Baton Pass outright would be an unreasonable restriction on the metagame.
Fast forward to the current situation, and it is clear that even with Ingrain Smeargle banned, Baton Pass chains are still causing problems. Part of that might be resolved with the reduction to three Baton Pass users per team, but the council was clearly still concerned with some aspects of Smeargle-passing, since DrumPass Smeargle in particular doesn’t require a full team’s support. However, adding on Belly Drum + Smeargle in addition to the already existing Ingrain + Smeargle ban would be adding on yet
another complex ban for the exact same ‘mon. Adding on yet another restricted move for Smeargle is simply a bridge too far, at least from the perspective of overall tiering philosophy. To me, if a Pokemon requires multiple moves to be banned on it to remain competitive, that tells me that either the Pokemon itself is irreparably broken or there’s something else that is actually the problem.
Assuming that Smeargle is worth keeping around, changing the ban to Smeargle + Baton Pass eliminates that issue. Rather than being a new complex ban, this would be an update to the existing Smeargle clause, since removing Baton Pass from Smeargle would allow the council to free Ingrain and keep the total number of complex bans involving Smeargle the same. From a tiering perspective, this is definitely a much cleaner solution.