I'd also like to write down my thoughts on Dynamaxing, note that these are my opinions and not the councils.
First, I want to highlight what makes it unhealthy in my eyes.
1. Choice lock restriction not applying once you Dynamax - this I think is what makes it the most unhealthy to me. Scouting choice items is already a skill that requires playing around to determine how your team can handle the threat. This knowledge becomes irrelevant when you know your opponent can Dynamax and hit you with a swift 1HKO. An example of this is a Choice Scarf Excadrill vs Toxapex. Now, maybe I'm locked into rock slide because I predicted the Gyarados but my opponent went into Toxapex instead. Now they know I'm scarf, but they also know I can Dynamax, but I also know this information. This exchange leads to so many mind games at each turn where all the fundamentals of checks and counters are thrown out the window. Does the Toxapex user Dynamax into Max Guard? Does the Excadrill user predict this and save it? These exchanges happen at every turn, bringing me to my next point.
2. You can Dynamax any Pokemon at any time - this is problematic in itself, every game I've played I have to worry about my opponent using their Dynamax in every situation. Will my Dynamax beat their Dynamax? Should I setup first? If my opponent Dynamax's here I lose my wincon, should I scout? Granted these questions do not necessarily mean that it is overly unhealthy, but if I have to ask myself at every turn it becomes too much.
3. Max Moves and their secondary effects allowing you to easily setup and sweep - Now the main thing that makes this mechanic broken are the Max Moves. It is kind of ridiculous how you can boost your stats while attacking, or setup weather/terrain to hit harder with your next move. The most prominent example is with Swift Swim teams using Max Geyser to set-up rain and even if Dynamax runs out they are still a major threat with +2 speed and a boosted water attack. Being able to setup your pokemon to sweep after Dynamax runs out is ridiculous, and it doesn't have to be used offensively either.
Here is an example, if you skip to turn 18 you can see I used Max Quake to increase my SpDef so even if my Dynamax ran out, I would be able to beat the Gengar. Max Moves also lead to things like weather wars just to stop your team from getting swept. They hit through protect so even if you don't get the damage off you still get the boost. And then if you Dynamax defensively, you still can't use recover or any status move to stall them out, just Max Guard.
Now to touch on some other points that I have seen:
Gigantamaxing: Honestly, I do not see the point of tiering this separately. It may not have been explored much but Gigantamax Pokemon can still do a lot of the same things Dynamax mons do, sometimes better. Drednaw is a pokemon I use a lot. I Gigantamax it and use Max Knuckle to get a +1 attack boost, now I have double HP, double speed most likely from having rain up, and now I have +1 attack and am free to use Max Stonesurge to hit with a boosted water-type attack and set-up a free Stealth Rocks. Lapras does it even better by setting up screens. The problem still persists.
Gigantamax is not too different or underpowered to tier seperately.
Banning certain Pokemon instead of Dynamax: I also do not agree with this. I really see no point in banning Pokemon when the main broken thing is the mechanic. Ok we ban Gyarados and Togekiss, now that just leaves room for innovation to see what else becomes too unhealthy. Pokemon start running random flying coverage to get the +1 speed (I have tried this with Hydreigon). Pokemon that have been underexplored and are already quite good such as Corviknight, will start to see more use and abuse Dynamaxing. Also banning the sweeping abusers does not tackle the main broken mechanics, such as being able to get out of choice lock, or setting up terrain or weather for a later sweep. Sometimes I use dynamax just to setup terrain because my non-Dynamax attack will hit harder. Here is an example:
CB Dracovish vs Toxapex
Regular Choice Band Dracovish:
252 Atk Choice Band Strong Jaw Dracovish Psychic Fangs vs. 252 HP / 252+ Def Toxapex: 172-204 (56.5 - 67.1%) -- guaranteed 2HKO
During Dynamax:
252 Atk Dracovish Max Mindstorm (130 BP) vs. 252 HP / 252+ Def Toxapex: 118-140 (38.8 - 46%) -- guaranteed 3HKO
252 Atk Dracovish Max Mindstorm (130 BP) vs. 252 HP / 252+ Def Toxapex in Psychic Terrain: 178-210 (58.5 - 69%) -- guaranteed 2HKO
After Dynamax and Psychic Terrain set-up after a Max Mindstorm:
252 Atk Choice Band Strong Jaw Dracovish Psychic Fangs vs. 252 HP / 252+ Def Toxapex in Psychic Terrain: 260-306 (85.5 - 100.6%) -- 6.3% chance to OHKO
What I'm trying to get at here is that Dynamaxing allows you to setup for a sweep outside of Dynamax, and allows you to sponge attacks and sometimes hit harder when outside of it. This remains true to all Pokemon and
I don't think banning the main abusers will solve this issue, because the issue is the mechanic itself.
My recommendation right now would be to
Ban Dynamax+Gigantamax completely, as I do not see this being healthy for monotype at all. I know it sucks to have to ban the main appeal and mechanic of a new generation, and I personally sometimes find games to be very fun with it, but that should not sway the conversation from the unhealthy and balanced aspect of the mechanic. A lot of players including myself are in a weird position where there is little motivation to build and play because of a lack of certainty in how Dynamaxing will be handled. However, I think we should wait until after the first monotype tour that was posted, and get some actual results from the games and credible replays. Maybe the metagame trends will prove to be different and players can quickly adapt. I find it highly unlikely, but it is worth it to see. However I think action should be taken soon.
TL;DR
Just read the bolded and underlined parts of this long ass essay lmao can't believe I wrote this shit. Also, bro you get 2x HP and 3 Z-Moves that set-up weather or terrain or boost your stats, do I need to say more?