For those who responded to me, thank you! I'd start by just expanding upon my beliefs, but I hope they'll come out more naturally the more I participate here.
SergioRules said:https://www.washingtonpost.com/graphics/politics/policy-2020/ I've used this site, granted not sure how reliable WaPo is on this stuff, but as you can see from the graphics, the main things that differ between Yang and Sanders are:
- Sanders wants to tax assets on the wealthiest Americans, whereas Yang wants to adjust capital gains.
- Sanders wants to cancel all student loan debt, while Yang wants to alleviate debt burdens in other ways.
- Sanders wants to abolish the electoral college, while Yang wants to reform it.
Personally on these three specific issues, I side much more with Bernie.
I also think that Bernie has just been a more popularly used name with his run for the Democratic nomination in 2016 also already getting his name out there, while Yang hasn't had quite the same exposure to the media.
Thank you! I use Yang's policies list here:
https://www.yang2020.com/policies/ so I'll try to respond the best I can with only the information he provides, as well as any he's expanded upon in interviews
In regards to wealthy Americans being taxed, Yang has a similar plan. The Freedom Dividend (I'll just refer to it at the 1k a month thing) is primarily being paid for by a VAT of 10%, meaning that we're taxing corporations 10% of their production. This makes it harder for corporations to hide profits and income. Super powerful corporations are going to be putting much more into the Dividend than most of their administrators are going to get out of it. I think that a VAT is much stronger than a flat wealth tax because it's not limited to those above a certain income rate and scales alongside the power of a corporation. If a corporation makes 10k yearly income and another 100bil, the latter is going to be hit much harder. Capital gains are a major part of it, but wealthy Americans aren't getting off scot-free.
I like the total relief of student debt idea from Bernie. It's one aspect where I prefer Bernie over Yang. That isn't to say Yang has a plan, but total relief for all current student debt and major reform for how loans are constructed going forward is a big part.
3. Yang's plan for voting is pretty large but I'll try to tackle the points about the electoral college here. The main issue is that abolishing the electoral college isn't feasible. We'd need 38 states to agree to an amendment, which we don't have the support for. Even then, the abolition of the electoral college wouldn't change the demographics of the states. Whether we get rid of it or not, Texas is going to have an overwhelming majority of Republican votes and California is going to have an overwhelming majority of Democratic voters. This is why I think Ranked Choice Voting with Proportional Voting would be the best option. Neither would require an amendment and better represents the feelings of the people. Ranked Choice Voting is a fantastic solution to the issue of swing states. Having a state that's solidly red or blue depresses turnout because those who think "well, shit, i wanna vote blue in texas, but that's an L waiting to happen" now have three shots at a blue vote. Our current system leads many to not vote for their favorite candidate, but rather the one they like that also will probably win. This is an issue a lot of Yang supporters are trying to cover; lots of people say they would vote for Yang, but they think he probably won't win. Ranked Choice allows people to vote for their favorite as their top and then the person they think will actually win second.
Chou Toshio said:Hi JimJim, thanks for the question and hope I can provide an insightful and useful answer. Just for reference, I first discovered Andrew Yang early in 2018 when he appeared on Sam Harris’ podcast— I often listened to “Waking Up” at the time, and also a fan of Eric & Bret Weinstein. That’s before JRE, before watching him kick Ben Shapiro’s ass, long before there was a Yang Gang. I immediately took a liking to Andrew, and believed he had a good analysis of the problems plaguing the country. Compared to Bernie, I really loved how he honed in on the issue of automation, and putting UBI front and center. At the time, I believed (as I guess many Yang fans do) that he had a more “updated” understanding of the problems compared to Sanders. I even donated to Yang twice, hoping to see him make the debate stage and challenge Bernie on those issues, and put Automation in the center of discourse.
Bernie was always my #1, but at the start my reasons were more political—his increasingly impressive efforts to galvanize the left, and most importantly, his promise to transform the Democratic Party and his movements to do so. Yang has never been sufficiently opposed to the party leadership for my taste— I needed to hear the promise of revolution; and it had to come from a voice with the moral authority and established trust to make that promise authentic.
(I’ll also note that at the time, Yang appeared to be staunchly for single payer)
But as campaign season kicked off, the engines of outreach in the Bernie machine geared up; and I watched the campaign & candidate evolve— and I evolved with them. From a policy standpoint, I can’t imagine supporting Yang, and the two candidates have seemed to become increasingly different.
In particular, “Hear the Bern” podcast challenged me to listen to broader ideas in the left, including bringing me to actually engage with real socialist voices like Richard Wolff & Michael Brooks— and I found their arguments more compelling than Yang’s or Weinstein’s. I probably moved from SocDem to DemSoc. They convinced me.
What I came to understand, from a policy perspective, the fundamental difference between Yang and Bernie (and between Warren & Bernie as well really) that spans all their policy choices, is whether or not you center power, structure. Whether you re-structure government and systems in order to put power into the hands of the people and focus on strengthening democracy, or if you try to use market mechanisms to “fix” capitalism. Single Payer Medicare for All does this. Strengthening Unions and giving workers increasing amount of shares and board seats does this. Raising the minimum wage, does this. And a Jobs Guarantee does that on steroids because you’re telling private employers “You need to pay this much ad provide benefits this good in order to get any employees at all.”
What I fundamentally came to believe is that the government, controlled by progressive democracy, by the people themselves-- must LEAD the transformation, and I couldn’t put my faith in a candidate who fundamentally structures his policies on the assumption that Government cannot be competent.
Progressive taxes, Single Payer Healthcare, Green New Deal w/ Federal Jobs Guarantee, Foreign Policy of Global Worker Solidarity, Democracy in the Workplace, Free University, Bernie’s Immigration plan…
Bernie continued to get sharper, his policies got sharper, a product of his team getting stronger, his message became clearer and he did the unique thing of putting the voices of people before his own. I loved Bernie in 2016, but my love for Bernie of 2020 is… really, truly, he is the leader that the American people need to write their own future history.
Yang has more in common with Bernie than you may think. Single Payer Healthcare / Medicare for All is his #2 policy after the Freedom Dividend, even if it is a slightly more moderate take than Bernie's. The VAT is a progressive tax which 169 other countries currently have. Also, he's for the Green New Deal, but he says that because we're only 15% of global emissions that even if we took a total 180, we'd make a dent in the acceleration of climate change, but wouldn't be able to reverse it.
I must say, my biggest fear as a fan of Bernie is the $15 minimum wage. I say this because this is going to lead to corporations wanting to save money by automating more jobs. I work in retail right now, and my job would be trivially easy to automate away. The issue with capitalism is that the capitalist at the top is going to look for ways to save and make money, and automation is going to strip that away. I watched an interview with Richard Wolff where he stated that because of the massive move to production in China, India, Brazil, etc. that people can't buy back what they're selling. I fear that this will happen if minimum wage is raised. MORE production will be moved to automation or countries with lower wages.
Hopefully, I can start a fruitful conversation and be here more often.