Voting has ended! Our winners are:
Ema Skye's Tangled Feet
Ema Skye said:Ability: Tangled Feet
New Effect: When switching in, the first move this Pokemon uses will usually go first. (+1 priority)
Competitive Reasoning: Revenge killing is a fundamental aspect of Pokemon, as you can't possibly check every Pokemon in your team since there's like 900 of them. Tangled Feet turns the user into a powerful revenge killer, negating speed bonuses and allowing the use of high priority moves. Gale Wings is the obvious comparison here. Gen 6 Gale Wings is, imo, more powerful than this as it allows consecutive uses, but this is definitely stronger than Gen 7/8 Gale Wings which, and I think most of us would agree, is over-nerfed.
Speaking specifically to Mr. Rime, they have a wide array of moves that would blend well here. Some possible applications: offensive moves to revenge (Ice/Psychic STAB & Ghost, Electric, Fighting and Grass coverage - Choice Specs sets would like this), Rapid Spin to remove hazards and boost speed (possibly useful to get an easy boost), Slack Off (on second switch in), other boosting moves (Nasty Plot, Calm Mind), and some other Prankster-style tricks (Hypnosis, Trick, Taunt, Screens and Block). Ideally, future users of Tangled Feet will have additional quirks aside from just launching strong attacks.
Thematic Reasoning: Tangling implies inconsistency (especially the Japanese name - Tottering). The priority effect is inconsistent as a result. Or picture the Pokemon tripping over itself after it's first attack, giving it normal priority again.
guruu's Shell Armor
guruu said:Ability: Shell Armor
New Effect: If the user is healthy, all incoming attacks are calculated against it's Defense. Shell Smash changes the user's ability to Weak Armor.
Competitive Reasoning: Besides Lapras and Escavalier, all other fully-evolved Shell Armored Pokemon have a much higher Defense than Special Defense stat and would really appreciate this new effect. The "must be status-free" clause was added to keep Rest + Curse/Iron Defense sets from being overpowered.
Thematic Reasoning: The Pokemon uses its hard shell to block attacks.
My Sweet Veil
Adou said:Ability: Sweet Veil
New Effect: Sets a screen on entry which heals any ally Pokemon by 1/16th of their maximum HP at the end of the turn.
Competitive Reasoning: Pokemon with this ability could become more supportive in general, making up for their mostly subpar stats. Ribombee in particular could have an extra layer of utility with Sweet Veil + U-turn, allowing it to pivot into a bulkier teammate after setting its webs.
Thematic Reasoning: Sweet Veil acting as an actual "veil".
G-Luke's Run Away
G-Luke said:Ability: Run Away
New Effect: If the foe has a super effective move or an OHKO move, it will immediately switch out.
Competitive Reasoning: Being able to switch out upon sensing a super effective move allows these Pokemon to get massive momentum for their team, keeping the opponent on their toes and in general making the meta much fast paced. It is held back by being triggered by ANY uper effective move however, so even a mere Water Pulse would force them out.
Thematic Reasoning: Running away from wild battles is what Run away does, and since everything has the same level in competitive, making them switch when a super effective move is the best comparision i could come up with.
Buffed Pokemon: While several Pokemon already have great abilities, Run Away could still be very prime for pivoting, especially on a Pokemon like Rapidash-Galar who has eh abilities to work with already.
We can't move into the second stage yet, however, as we have a tie between Hematite and Dilasc for their Telepathy submissions. For the tiebreaker, simply vote for one submission or the other. This tiebreaker phase will end in ~24 hours.
Hematite's Telepathy
Hematite said:Oh, if it's okay, I think I'm gonna resubmit this:
Ability: Telepathy
New effect: "The Pokémon sets Wonder Room when it enters battle." Wonder Room is an existing move that swaps every Pokémon's Defense with its Special Defense for five turns.
Competitive reasoning: Wonder Room is a truly fascinating move, but the fact that it takes a turn to set it often undermines it, since its power level is so much subtler and harder to abuse than something like Trick Room. Being able to set it on entry turns this around, letting you use the Pokémon as a pivot to prepare the rest of your team for dealing with any sweeper that targets your weaker defenses or any wall that shrugs off moves from your stronger offenses.
Note that using Wonder Room while Wonder Room is already active turns it off, so unlike, say, Drought or a Surge user, this allows you to change it both ways - switching in a Telepathy user is less "setup" and more "toggle." A Pokémon with Telepathy that's capable of pivoting often can ensure that Wonder Room is always giving your team the upper hand.
Flavor reasoning: Telepathy is already a defensively oriented Ability that's largely associated with Psychic-types and Pokémon with a strange connection to the dimensions, so it makes sense that they could twist them this way.
Notable buffs: There are three Pokémon that jump out as having the potential to take advantage of this in wildly different ways, all of which are in Galar!
:noivern: Noivern is the fastest Pokémon with Telepathy that's currently available Tapu Koko isn't in Galar yet, but Telepathy is also unreleased even then, and it also generally runs a pivoting move in U-turn and plays a role of offensive support for most teams. Noivern is on the frail side, but its ability to set Wonder Room and then switch out before taking a hit opens up new opportunities for the rest of its teammates to take advantage of whatever Pokémon the opponent sends in.
:beheeyem: Beheeyem's niche is the opposite of Noivern: rather than being the fastest possible Wonder Room pivot, it manages to be the slowest thanks to its access to Teleport. It might take some stat buffs from the next stage to get it there, but I think Beheeyem could become an excellent defensive pivot that's able to switch in and take a hit.
:gardevoir: Despite being mostly an offensive Pokémon, Gardevoir actually has above average special bulk and could realistically play the role of a special wall. It also has useful support moves like Will-o-Wisp, Trick, Healing Wish and even the excellent Wish + Teleport combination. Unfortunately, it's held back by its abysmal physical defense - but with Wonder Room allowing it to swap its defenses every time it switches in, careful play can enable it to wall opponents on both sides of the spectrum (and especially take advantage of Will-o-Wisp, which is strongly biased towards physical walling) so long as it switches in at the right times, while its base 125 Special Attack and access to Fairy STAB should allow it to keep up offensive pressure while it does.
Dilasc's Telepathy
Dilasc said:Ability: Telepathy
New Effect: Psychic type -ate
Competitive Reasoning: Powered up Psychic moves are never a bad thing especially on strong normal moves.
Thematic Reasoning: I feel this ability speaks for itself. Not the most exciting buff but eh.
Buffed Pokemon: The most interesting buff is Noivern who gets Psychic type Boom Burst which I guess can get around Toxapex.
Tangled Feet Votes
Dilasc - 4
Ema Skye - 11
shnowshner - 9
Revenge of Depressed Gay - 5
Shell Armor Votes
Yoshiblaze - 10
guruu - 12
MegaFlareon - 8
Sweet Veil Votes
Dilasc - 7
Ema Skye - 8
Adou - 14
Telepathy Votes
Hematite - 10
Dilasc - 10
guruu - 9
Run Away Votes
Dilasc - 3
G-Luke - 11
guruu - 10
MegaFlareon - 3