TheGunfireGuy said:While teambuilding for gen 6 formats, Water Shuriken still shows up as a special move, despite it being a physical move in the mentioned gen. Because of this, the suggested EV spread also shows 4 Special Attack investment when the rest of the moves are physical. Testing from battles however suggests that it acts like a physical move still, which is correct.
The replay used for testing can be found here.
Relevant Damage Calcs
252+ SpA Greninja Water Shuriken (15 BP) (2 hits) vs. 252 HP / 252 SpD Blissey: 32-38 (4.4 - 5.3%) -- possibly the worst move ever
0- Atk Greninja Water Shuriken (15 BP) (2 hits) vs. 252 HP / 4+ Def Blissey: 108-128 (15.1 - 17.9%) -- approx. possible 6HKO
I can unfortunately not record my screen at the time of posting, otherwise I would attach a video of the teambuilder as well, but that can be fact-checked easily.
In a similar vein to this previous post of mine, while using Zippy Zap in LGPE OU, it shows the incorrect move entry in the teambuilder. The gen 8 entry, which is, "Goes first. Raises user's evasion by 1." is shown instead of the correct entry which is "Nearly always goes first. Always crits." (entries taken directly from /dt and /dt7) However, the base power shown is 50, which is correct for LGPE (as the gen 8 entry on showdown increases the BP to 80). It does work as intended, which can be checked with the calcs below and the replay linked
here.
Relevant Calcs
50 BP + Crit : 0 Atk Pikachu-Starter Zippy Zap vs. 0 HP / 0 Def Arcanine on a critical hit: 45-54 (27.2 - 32.7%) -- guaranteed 4HKO
80 BP + Crit : 0 Atk Pikachu-Starter Zippy Zap vs. 0 HP / 0 Def Arcanine on a critical hit: 69-82 (41.8 - 49.6%) -- guaranteed 3HKO
Instead of continuing to post about this for singular instances, I would like to also make this a general post regarding the issue of changes being made to moves over the gens. From more investigation, it seems that base power (mostly), accuracy changes, PP changes (mostly) and typing changes are reflected correctly. However, move category changes
specifically after the physical/special split and move descriptions/secondary effects show the latest versions instead of the ones for whatever gen is being used to teambuild (while they remain correct in practice).
Evidence for above claims
BP changes : Zippy Zap in gen 7 shows correct BP, Tackle reflects correct BP changes throughout the gens, Moves changed in Let's Go Pikachu/Eevee such as Solar Beam, Sky Attack, etc still show USUM-accurate BPs while building for LGPE OU
Accuracy changes : Gen 1 : Blizzard, Rock Throw, Whirlwind,etc; Gen 2: Low Kick,Razor Wind,etc among others show correct accuracy values and changes in the respective gens in which they were changed
PP changes : Gen 1-3 Absorb shows correct PP value (32) for these gens and the correct value after change (40), Absorb shows USUM-accurate PP value of 40 (base PP: 25) whereas the correct value is 24 (base PP: 15) while building for LGPE OU
Description/Secondary Effect changes : Gen 1 Acid, Aurora Beam, Bubble, etc show a 10% secondary effect chance while it is actually 33% for Gen 1. Gen 1 Bite shows a 30% Flinch chance but it is actually 10% for Gen 1. These are just visual while they work correctly in practice (See: Gen 7 Zippy Zap always lands crits and doesn't raise evasion despite wrong description in Teambuilder)
Physical/Special Category changes : (see: quoted post; this is also just a visual error similar to Secondary Effect changes as is shown by calcs in quoted post)
Edit :Forgot to add this in the original but PP changes are correctly reflected in battle as well, it's also just visual (Golbat with absorb in LGPE OU shows 24 PP in battle)
BUG STATUS: FIXED by Karthik99999