Mad Ram said:Is there any way we can figure out what the change to HP is or at least some sort of ballpark? If we have enough HP stats from enough varying Pokémon, we should be able to give at least some range for how it's changed. I know the whole extra number and "stat xp" bar or whatever it is throw a wrench into it, but a rough guess is better than nothing.
wdcjernigan said:I am wondering if they rescaled the stats to a smaller set of levels? Like is level 50 the new 100? In past games they have hardly used levels 75 - 100 on NPCs except Red and maybe a couple others so maybe they are changing it up.
Whoever knows how to do the stat calculations: can you check against if the Pokémon's level is doubled? Or perhaps 1.5 or 1.33?
I'm not a professional, but I tried playing around with the
HP formula for a little bit, mainly going off my intuition about base HP mattering more and adding it as a flat value. I did not set any IVs/EVs (treated as all 0) for consistency since I didn't want to go into any estimates for those or any mystery factors, so all of these end up being underestimates, though it ends up being farther off for higher level mons.
For reference the base formula ends up as
((2*baseHP+iv+ev//4)*level//100) + level + 10 in python, and one attempt I made was
(2*baseHP+iv+ev//4)*level//150) + level + baseHP after seeing the post about different scaling, though I tried having less level scaling as it seemed like it was generally giving too high numbers for the higher level mons. I don't think this is the exact formula by any means, but I believe a term involving base HP would explain the relatively much higher HP on lower level pokemon that probably don't get much/have much of IVs/EVs. Of course this is all assuming the base stats are the same to begin with, and in the end the datamine will be able to answer this with certainty, but for now I just wanted to share this idea since it was interesting to think about.
results
This is basically a bunch of formatted function prints in Python that correspond to the mons in order of the other post.
Expected is the actual HP from a screenshot and formula is what the proposed formula would output.
Rowlet
Expected: 112, formula: 96
Expected: 103, formula: 90
Cyndaquil
Expected: 62, formula: 58
Expected: 56, formula: 54
Expected: 61, formula: 54
Oshawott
Expected: 97, formula: 82
Expected: 87, formula: 75
Expected: 106, formula: 82
Lucario
Expected: 194, formula: 184
Expected: 203, formula: 186
Expected: 196, formula: 186
Vulpix
Expected: 87, formula: 80
Rhydon
Expected: 223, formula: 213
Crobat
Expected: 231, formula: 213
Lopunny
Expected: 110, formula: 94
Mamoswine
Expected: 269, formula: 250
Drifblim
Expected: 252, formula: 246
Similarly dividing by 150 and adding the base stat in the non-HP stat formula results in this:
Attack: Expected: 100, formula: 114
Defense: Expected: 69, formula: 62
SpA: Expected: 111, formula: 128
SpD: Expected: 72, formula: 77
Spe: Expected: 107, formula: 114
My first attempt was just adding base HP on top of the original formula to get
(2*baseHP+iv+ev//4)*level//100) + level + 10 + baseHP. It came pretty close for some, but gave overestimates for the higher HP/level mons so that's why I tried scaling it down.
results
Oshawott
Expected: 97, formula: 98
Expected: 87, formula: 90
Expected: 106, formula: 98
Lucario
Expected: 194, formula: 221
Expected: 203, formula: 224
Expected: 196, formula: 224
Vulpix
Expected: 87, formula: 97
Rhydon
Expected: 223, formula: 254
Crobat
Expected: 231, formula: 257
Lopunny
Expected: 110, formula: 111
Mamoswine
Expected: 269, formula: 302
Drifblim
Expected: 252, formula: 288