XenonHero126 said:The way some UBs have the identical Pokedex entry “Although it’s alien to this world and a danger here, it’s apparently a common organism in the world where it normally lives” is boring
- Buzzwole: A reckless alien in this world, its home world is a jungle with muscle tone trees it wrestles against and active volcanoes it trains in.
- Pheromosa: A hasty alien in this world, its home world is a desert where it uses its super speed to turn sand to crystal which it uses to build.
- Xurkitree: A power-draining alien in this world, its home world is a tangle of cable-like vines it plugs itself into to connect with others.
- Celesteele: A combusting alien in this world, its home world is a valley filled with craters which contain a liquid it uses as fuel to launch off.
- Kartana: A severing alien in this world, its home world is a forest where human-like beings train to use them as a samurai does with a sword.
- Guzzlord: A devouring alien in this world, its home world is a desolate planet because of it, but no one knows where it came from.
There GF, was that so hard to do?
KalosianPorygon said:What is a Legendary Pokémon?
According to Bulbapedia... It's any Pokémon Game Freak/TPCi/whoever is in charge of the franchise slaps the "Legendary" label on.
Is anyone else confused by the lack of consistency among this group of Pokémon? Because nothing fully unifies Legendary Pokémon and makes them fully distinct from non-Legendary Pokémon
Hm, you know, I feel "Legendary" is more of an arbitrary title. Comparing it to something in the real world, what we count as a "God" vastly differs from culture/religion to culture/religion.
Some only have the one god, some have a set of gods, some have a god for every day of the week. Some have powerful spirits BUT they are not considered deities.
Some gods are human, some gods have heads of animals, some gods are just the element they control, some gods don't have a set form if any.
Some gods are forces of a nature and have no connection with people, some gods exist to help the people, some have evil gods who harm the people.
Like with classifying real world "Gods", what classifies a "Legendary" Pokemon is going to depend on the culture(s) of that Region and what position that Legendary is in. While "power, rarity, and lore" are three usual good parameters to work with, a Legendary neither needs all three and some can just get by with one. The only "unifying" thing I can really think that relates them is that you're not gonna see a trainer without considerable ranking using them as if they're like any other Pokemon not considered Legendary. You gotta go through them one-by-one (or in groups of two/three/four which many are in) to discuss why it's been called a Legendary (and for some the reason may be flimsy, Phione).
Going back to Ultra Beasts for a second, they would usually have the checkmarks for a Legendary, but they're not. They're considered their own thing simply because they're exclusively from another dimension (and travelling from that other dimension seem to have given them certain related quicks like prime stat numbers and the Beast Boost Ability). And the dex further goes on to explain even in their home world they may not be considered Legendary because they're a common species. The Cosmog family seem to escape this as they seemingly are rare and, because they have visited the Pokemon World in the past, people have seen them and written legends on them thus get the title of Legendary. And Necrozma I don't even know, it's not an Ultra Beast, its apparently questionable if its even considered a "Pokemon" at least as we know it.
FloopThePig said:Also them deciding to separate legendaries and mythicals. The only difference between the two is the method of obtaining them in the games. But in the Pokémon universe that's not really a thing, so the mythical classification literally has no relevance there.
Mythical is even more arbitrary as this one feels like its completely meta. I don't even know how to fit it into an in-world arbitrary title concept without it sounding like the reason someone would call a Pokemon "Legendary". There Japanese name is "Illusionary Pokemon", and I don't recall the term "Mythical/Illusionary" ever really being used in the game as official terms for them. They're just referred to as super rare Pokemon if it ever comes up (though I don't think they're even considered Legendaries unless attached to a Legendary group such as Keldeo). So, I would actually say "Mythical" is PURELY a meta term, it does not exist in-world, similar to "Pseudo Legendary" or "Pikaclone" except Mythical is a official term for marketing purposes. Looking through the batch of them, if I were to give them a more descriptive umbrella term it would be "Aloof Pokemon", get rid of the vagueness of "Mythical" and while explaining these Pokemon are just very rare to see or reach or maybe even know about.
AquaticPanic said:Right off the bat they introduce him as "The strongest trainer in the entire world!" whichin itself isn't really an issue but imo the problem is that they don't explore this.
Most have said what I would have about Leon (essentially being a mirror of the protag), though this one point actually does bother me (and why the recent Diantha battle really bugs me).
In the games, Leon is the strongest trainer in
GALAR. That's it. Maybe he battled other notable trainers outside Galar, we aren't really told, but one thing Leon wants to do as Champion is show the world how strong Galar trainers are. If Leon was already the world champion, why would he even need to do that? Wouldn't the world's strongest trainer being from Galar naturally lead to many thinking Galar trainers are strong? This could also go hand-to-hand with Rose's focus so being on Galar that he could have advertised and marketed the Galar League to the world years ago, but he kept the Galar League pretty much secluded to the region. Thus, despite Leon being a mirror of the player, we don't really know how he would measure up against other Champions. I have never gotten the sense in the games that Leon has faced Lance, Steven, Wallace, Cynthia, Alder, Iris, or Diantha, let alone others like Elite Four members and Frontier Brains.
Infact, with the strongest trainers he battled being in Galar, is it that he's unstoppable because he's a really good strategist, or is it because he has battled against essentially the same opponents so many times he just knows how to counter them (not to mention most of them are the Gym Leaders who are all Type Specialists).
Yes, I'm oversimplifying things, though what I'm saying is, no anime, against an actual other Champion like Diantha, Leon should be sharing knock outs. Leon should have lost at least four of his Pokemon against Diantha if he kept from using his Charizard until Diantha sent out her Gardevoir. Like, they skipped more than half the match anyway so it's not like they had to animate the other battles they weren't already planning to show. Leon was already feeling like a Gary Stu with his battle against Alain, which I just let go as them wanting to build up tension of Leon for Ash personally, but this was not the case with Diantha and all they did was make Leon look like a writer's pet and did Diantha dirty (and being she's a Champion that didn't really receive much attention in the games, this felt like it would have been an opportunity to really show what she got and why she's a Champion; but NOPE, we gotta make Leon look invincible until he verses Ash when he would conveniently forget his plot armor so will have an even match with him).
It's also why I really like the first episode of Pokemon Evolutions which focuses in on Leon just before his Champion Battle with the protag. He doesn't say a word, but you can just tell from his expression and slight motions that the battle with Eternatus REALLY shook him. Leon is always acting in charge and unfazed by any setbacks, but here we finally get to see Leon in a vulnerable moment which shows he truly is good guy, he's afraid of not being strong enough to protect those he care about, & possibly feels guilty he needed to be the one that was saved. It shows there is a human character underneath all that bravado and those sponsor logos.
Pikachu315111 said:(TBC)
TBC two weeks later, I r gud at managing time.
Coronis said:I mean, since the initial trailer and starter reveal, thats basically what I’ve done.
Man, major kudos to you!

Part of me would like to do that, but the other part of me also wants to know what to be expecting. I guess it's my personal form of FOMO, I don't get it from stuff like missing out playing a game event or not watching a certain new show, but when it comes to new Pokemon info I want to learn about it asap (hey, at least its free FOMO). I do try to keep away from spoilers though, that's a bit too much, but trailers and stuff revealed via website is free game (to me, and of course kept on the thread dedicated to discussing the new game).
DrCoeloCephalo said:Drake demands more respect than Leon.
For the short time we had with Drake, and the Orange Island crew in general, I liked them; they definitely had a lot of personality put into them, sometimes even moreso than characters in the game (they probably are leagues ahead of several Kalos League trainers). I can see why fan hacks to try and remake the Orange Islands is a popular project.
churine said:if a given area is the first area an evolutionary line appears in the game, imo that line should need to spawn the unevolved form first, thats how they did it in the early gens.
Or at the very least have the unevolved form as an encounter, heck make it a common encounter with the evo a slightly more uncommon encounter. I think we've been shown that just because a Pokemon is at evo level that doesn't mean it needs to have evolved. For Wild Pokemon it could be the Pokemon just naturally aged to that Level or there's something about that species social structure where they would only want a few of the evolution while the others remain unevolved. Also, whose to say evo Levels aren't boosted by having a bond with a trainer and in the Wild a Pokemon evolves in different ways which either means evolving later or, some rare cases, able to evolve early.
KalosianPorygon said:Let's change the subject to stat-enhancing items. (...) Some are more useful than others, and sometimes it depends on the generation (RIP Soul Dew's viability), but there are three of these that are just plain useless: the Lucky Punch and Ditto's Powders.
I agree all these items, if they want to keep them, should receive an upgrade.
Lucky Punch: Now from the effect alone it feels completely random. Why bother with an item to increase its Critical Hit Ratio when it's a Special wall? Checking it, I see it was introduced all the way back in Gen II and with that I could MAYBE see what GF was thinking. Back in Gen I, Chansey wasn't just a Special wall Pokemon but a Special powerhouse; it soaked up Special moves and could deliver them back because Special was a singular stat. When Gen II was introduced, Special was split into Sp. Atk & Sp. Def, redefining many Pokemon which were Special-focused. With Chansey being made into a Special wall, GF maybe were felt it would alienate players who liked Chansey. Sure, they also were making Blissey which is better in every way, but to get Blissey you needed high friendship which takes a while to grind and best way to increase is leveling up which Chansey now has a harder time doing. So, they decided to give it a Held Item, but instead of doing something simple like doubling Special Attack, they decided to be cute. You see, Chansey's name in Japanese is "Lucky", with the idea of seeing one, let alone catching one, was lucky. So, Lucky Punch (the name itself a pun) focuses on Critical Hit Ratio cause Chansey would naturally be more "lucky" to score one (this is also probably why it gets the Ability Serene Grace).
So, how to improve it? While normally I like to keep with the "spirit" of the item, I'm going to do a twist with this: On a turn Chansey uses a punching move, it'll use its Special Defense stat instead of Attack for damage calculation, the Move's Power is increased by 20%, and there's a 50/50 chance Chansey will move first. Now that's what I call a "Lucky Punch".
Ditto Powders: Yeah, you already went over what the basic thought of these items were (and why they didn't work), so skipping to my upgrade suggestion: Both Powders make Ditto move last BUT protects it from everything except damage from moves (so its unaffected by Status Moves, secondary effects, status ailments, & indirect damage). When Ditto uses Transform, at the end of the turn after having Transformed, if its holding Metal Powder it increases both Defense & Special Defense by +1 stage; if it's holding Quick Powder it increases Speed by +1 stage each turn. Both items are consumed afterwards. Now only does this give a reason for the Powders to exist, but also a reason to even use a non-Imposter Ditto. Heck, I'd even maybe suggest making a "Power Powder" to increase Atk & Sp. Atk and change its normal Ability from Limber to Sticky Hold.
MoonlightRose said:When I'm watching a Nuzlocke and the person is very overlevelled.
Naturalharmoniax said:That is why nuzlockes need a leveling rule.
Eh, I more think it should be generally agreed just to play the game and not grind unless absolutely necessary. Part of the fun of the Nuzlocke is working with that you get; sometimes you're lucky and you have the right Pokemon for the right job, sometimes you aren't and got to think your way to a victory. And while you of course don't want a Pokemon to faint, that's as much part of a Nuzlocke as the "only catch first mon on route" rule. It can be tragic and sometimes unfair, but that what makes Nuzlockes interesting from a narrative prospective. If you're just gonna grind levels so your Pokemon has little chance of fainting, why are you even playing a Nuzlocke?
Imperial Magala said:Wtf was even that Squirtle biting scene? You never see anything that again in Origins and feels like it was added as a hook to keep people invested. Like I remember in Generations Bryce kicking Plasma grunts and Essentia kicking Mimi, but you don't see stuff like Charamander screaming bloody murder in its first battle anywhere else.
I guess they wanted to show how inexperienced & unprepared Red was? During the whole time Charmander was being bit, Red was just standing there in shock until he noticed Charmander's tail flame weakening and he recalls it. An experience trainer would have commanded their Pokemon to counterattack and toss Squirtle off them after the initial bite. But Red just stood there, so Charmander could do nothing but withstand Bite and the increasing damage. It's more violent than anything else we've seen because Red is failing as a trainer to respond to their Pokemon in a distressing situation.
How Would It Usually Go
*Squirtle Bite Charmander*
Charmander: GAH!
Red: Charmander, it's head it out, use a Scratch!
*Charmander scratches Squirtle causing it to let go and back off*
What Red Did
*Squirtle Bite Charmander*
Charmander: GAH!
Red: What...
Charmander: AAAH! MASTER GIVE ME AN ORDER! IT'S BITING DOWN HARDER!
Red: Ugh...
Charmander: AAAAAH! MASTER HELP! I CAN'T TAKE THE PRESSURE!
Red: Oh, Charmander's tail is weakening!
Charmander: AAAAAAAH! NO S*** SHERLOCK! DO SOMETHING! ANYTHING! WHILE I STILL HAVE A CHEEK!
*Red returns Charmander*
Charmander: ... If we don't have my favorite meal tonight I'm setting your sleeping bag on fire.
Volt-Ikazuchi said:Now,
ceal might find this roster appealing, but Glalie has a flat 80 in every base stat and Sealeo is a NFE mon. This is the 3rd E4 member in Hoenn.
Would have been so easy to throw in Shellder on Route 109, Sneasel in Mt. Pyre, and Jynx also in Shoal Cave.
Volt-Ikazuchi said:A bunch of Megas should've been straight up evos. Any mon that wasn't a 3rd stage one shouldn't even have gotten one in the first place.
(...)
Now Mawile is probably stuck as a terrible mon until Megas return. What a boneheaded idea.
If they weren't afraid to change things, maybe they could give Houndoom, Mawile, Medicham, Manectric, Banette, Absol, Sableye, Glalie, Lopunny, & Audino a new evo which resembles their Mega Evo but isn't so "fancy". Then retcon the Mega for being the new Evo, you would only need to change the names of the Mega, Stones, and also readjust the stats (heck, maybe also slightly redesign the Mega).
Then again, I guess this is what Regional Variants are for now?
Nokocchi said:In Japanese, the move is Called "Ball Throw". As a result, it is blocked by Bulletproof.
Additionally, in the Gold and Silver 1997 Space World Demo, there was a Fire/Water Seal that balanced a flaming ball on its nose that could also learn Barrage.
I know, doesn't change my observation, though interesting the Fire/Water Seal was going to get it. Does that mean I'm off with my thinking or by Gen II they were thinking differently/more openly about what the concept of the Move was.
(Finally caught up to the recent page, though gonna stop here as next post is gonna take some time)