Lemingue said:I went to check the comments and I saw some comments that said "Megas are only unbalanced/bad because they stopped early. If gamefreak kept going, it'd be a good mechanic", which is a common counter argument to people who think megas are bad, but I don't think I can see it.
Because you can only have one mega in a team, decided in the builder so to speak, megas not only compete with other mons, but with themselves. Why use mega pidgeot when you can use m ray (extreme example because m ray is an extremity but hey, it was in the game)? As megas kept being added, I find likely they'd just powercreep other megas or be too weak to be considered for a slot, which leads into a very constricted metagame. Sure, maybe in 2022 worlds would have been mega dragapult, turtonator, lycanroc and cinderace instead of the cores we had in gen 6 and 7, but all you're changing is which pokemon you're limiting teams to.
Megas fare better in a tier format (also why they're looked at more fondly by smogon players I assume), but I think there'd come a point where newer megas just kept pushing others out of the spotlight, which just means you created two ways of being powercrept.
I think in a way, that's one of the reasons why gamefreak dumped the concept. There has been an increased pressure on making vgc an e sports, and having the top 20 teams be the exact same 2 teams repeated over and over wasn't a good look. Not only that, but the amount of effort put in trying to come up w them and balance them out only to it fail to be useful 70% of the time is a lot of wasted design time. Sure, they're good merch and people think they're cool, but you can get good merch and people thinking theyre cool with normal pokemon already.
On the topic of creativity in “ team building “, VGC suffers a huge problem. Unlike Smogon tournaments where you can switch your teams and have no specters due to the nature of PS!, you can switch your teams around and apply more surprising strategies because you are not devoted to a single team. In VGC, you are team locked foe an entire tourney that not only you have to play a BO3, but people will get to see your team ahead of time. So that’s why VGC teams tend to use the more consistent Pokémon like Landorus-T and Zacian-C over more niche counterparts. That also means bulky offense tends to be more common than any other archetypes, because it’s the most consistent, sure it might be boring for spectators, but players are here to win, not entertain.
Worldie said:I would kinda disagree, but I can see why you'd think that as singles player.
Dynamax did definitely warp the metagame in VGC as well, but it did create its own dedicated strategies. Weakness Policy abuse was one of them ofc, as well as multiple creative ways to actually rid of opposer dynamax.
Eerie Sound, Eject Button Switcheroo, Yawn abuse, were some of the many shenenigans people would pull out to subvert the position where you Dynamaxed and suddently had a useless pokemon with half the HP that will get ignored.
At same time, many dynamaxers would employ abilities like Clear Body to make sure to preserve the buffs they acquired. Other Dynamaxers are picked specifically to work with certain weathers or terrains.
Some creative Dynamax usage also made otherwise-completely-unviable mons like Regigigas or Coalassal actually see the spotlight and reach "you need a counter for this or you get rolled over" status, not much unlike certain singles sweepers like Volcarona.
I can definitely see where Wolfey was coming from, and while I won't disagree with the mechanic being horrible for singles (i've played a bit of BSS and honestly it wasn't fun in the slightest), people need to accept these mechanics are designed for doubles and "breaking singles" isn't something GameFreaks really cares for.
(On a more positive note, I'm on the train of thought that Teralyze won't remotely be as gamebreaking for singles as Dynamax was, so maybe they did indeed learn their lesson on that front)
They should at the very least try to heed some attention to BSS, since not only is it the official Singles format, but it’s also dominated by Japanese primarily, their local audience. I also think BSS would be more appealing for newcomers to join because it is closer to the main campaign than Doubles is. And before anyone goes down my throat saying stall is going to dominate BSS, I disagree. Stall is less reliable compared to 6v6 to two factors, one being that it’s harder to wall things with 3 Pokémon as opposed to 6, and things are squishier than at Lv.50 as opposed to 100.
My rankings are this: Megas #1, Z-Moves #2, and Dynamax #3. I really like Z-Moves because there’s not only limited offensive effects, Z-Powers can be used defensively as well, like Z-Trick Room and Z-Haze. And coming from a 1v1 Player, Z-Crystals were amazing to put on stall mons because they deny Trick and Switcheroo, huge achille heals for stall Pokémon.
On topic of Wolfe, I really can’t say I enjoy his videos, simply because he looks from things only a VGC perspective, without taking consideration of other formats ( like his Mega Ranking and Super Mechanic ). And the fact he called people who used Mega Altaria “ dumb “, and I’m someone who took Mega Altaria to 1800s + on BSD for ORAS.