I don't think I dramatized the power of tera by alluding to 18 types anywhere in my post...in fact if you read my post, I openly state "As the metagame develops, I think we will see certain pokemon settle into certain tera types." Many people on the no-ban side treat this like some revelation that the ban crowd has missed and make it the crux of their argument. But not only is this already acknowledged, it misses the heart of the issue. Perhaps I should have bolded this in my prior post, but let's repeat myself loud and clear because every no-ban post I've read has failed to address this:
THE PROBLEM IS THE TIMING OF WHEN TERA COMES OUT
The fact that every pokemon can use tera to flip the outcome of every important interaction at any time in the battle introduces too many options to consider. Even if you know that kingambit can tera ghost or flying, you still need to GUESS when it comes out when you're trying to revenge kill. That might not be enough to sell the issue, so let me break it down.
Let's assume I have a full health breloom trying to revenge kill a kingambit in the end game, with the following sets:
Breloom
Breloom @ Loaded Dice
Ability: Technician
Tera Type: Fire
EVs: 252 Atk / 4 SpD / 252 Spe
Jolly Nature
- Bullet Seed
- Mach Punch
- Close Combat
- Tera Blast
Kingambit
Kingambit @ Black Glasses
Ability: Supreme Overlord
Tera Type: Ghost
EVs: 100 HP / 252 Atk / 4 SpD / 152 Spe
Adamant Nature
- Sucker Punch
- Kowtow Cleave
- Iron Head
- Swords Dance
For the sake of simplicity, Let's assume that the kingambit is at +2 but is at half health, the breloom is at full health, and nobody is switching. So when I'm trying to revenge kill, with tera legal, the following can occur:
1. Breloom uses Mach Punch and Kingambit dies.
2. Breloom uses Mach Punch as Kingambit predicts that and Tera Ghost, then kills Breloom with +2 Iron Head.
3. Breloom uses Bullet Seed as Kingambit predicts Mach Punch and Tera Ghost, but Bullet Seed kills.
4. Breloom uses Bullet Seed as Kingambit remains Dark/Steel, tanks it, and kills Breloom with +2 Iron head.
The same situation with Tera banned is much simpler:
1. Breloom uses Mach Punch and Kingambit dies.
I want to draw out the possible outcomes in just ONE scenario to try and show people how much guesswork is involved
PURELY IN THE TIMING. The reason why the first scenario has 4 outcomes instead of 1 is solely due to the TIMING of when tera can come out. And this kind of scenario plays out CONSTANTLY in your average gen9 battle. CONSTANTLY having to second guess basic actions like revenge killing, tanking, sweeping etc fucks with your ability to make a long term plan and reduces the game to a string of guesswork until tera is used, because there are simply too many options for you to consider, by virtue of the timing of when tera comes out, alone. I didn't even factor in the ability of both pokemon to tera in my example. We can go one step further:
Let's work with these two sets at full health:
Hatterene
Hatterene @ Leftovers
Ability: Magic Bounce
Tera Type: Fire
EVs: 248 HP / 8 Def / 252 SpA
Modest Nature
IVs: 0 Atk
- Charm
- Mystical Fire
- Draining Kiss
- Psyshock
(Charm is heat trust me)
Roaring Moon
Roaring Moon @ Choice Scarf
Ability: Protosynthesis
Tera Type: Steel
EVs: 252 Atk / 4 SpD / 252 Spe
Jolly Nature
- Crunch
- Iron Head
- Dragon Claw
- U-turn
If these two are both in vs each other and they've taken rocks, assuming nobody switches out and ignoring iron head flinch, this interaction can play out in the following ways:
1. Hatterene stays Psychic/Fairy and tanks the Iron Head, uses Draining Kiss, and kills Roaring Moon
2. Hatterene stays Psychic/Fairy and uses draining kiss as Roaring Moon Tera's steel and kills with iron head.
3. Hatterene Tera's Fire as Roaring Moon Tera's steel, tanks the iron head, and kills back with 2 Mystical Fires.
4. Hatterene Tera's Fire as Roaring Moon stays Dragon/Dark, uses mystical fire predicting Tera Steel, and Roaring Moon kills with 2 Crunches.
5. Hatterene stays Psychic/Fairy and tanks a Crunch as Roaring Moon predicts Tera Fire, uses draining kiss and kills.
6. Hatterene Tera's Fire and uses Draining Kiss as Roaring Moon Tera's steel and kills with 2 Crunches.
7. Do you understand my pain
You can say "it takes skill to recognize when the tera is coming out," but you could also play around dynamax with enough skill, by bringing a ditto or corsola-g or sweeping first or whatever. Plenty of people found the dmax meta fun, and they wanted gen8 to have an "identity." But the dmax mechanic was clearly broken and it was rightfully banned. Because the goal is a competitive and diverse meta, not a "fun" or "unique" one. If we have to ban every new gimmick that gamefreak comes up with because it's too broken in singles, then so be it. People will complain every time we have to do it, and let them.