MrHands said:My original post is about the weirdness where out of all the billionaires who invest in the military industrial complex, oil, coal, etc we have a handful such as Musk who instead invest in things like renewable energy, space travel, and so on that are incredibly useful to humanity as a whole. Like it or not Musk's money going into Tesla is a huge part of the reason why every auto manufacturer is producing their own EVs right now. Musk is not a great guy, though he's not exactly a Disney supervillain either. He's a billionaire who happens to invest in useful technologies. He's a total douchebag, but why he is so uniquely hated by the left and obsessed over by the media is bizarre. He's useful. Why isn't the left outraged over Bernard Arnault, Larry Page, Steve Ballmer, the Waltons, the Mars, Low Tuck Kwong or Carlos Slim? Even Mark Zuckerberg seems to attract less hate, and he hasn't done much besides sell your data and make Tom lonely.
Musk is a douchebag (as I've said many, many times but you seem happy to ignore) but he is very useful compared to most other billionaires. He might not be a hero to the people, but the obscene hate directed at him seems more a product of social media. He's a celebrity. If he'd just shut the fuck up he'd probably be seen in a similar way to Bill Gates or Steve Jobs.
I mean, you're not entirely wrong that the more the guy talks the more leftists are reminded of what a ghoul he is and he'd probably fare better if he shut his fucking mouth, but you keep calling him a douchebag and, evidently, thinking that you're making reasonable criticisms of him in the eyes of the left. Well, uh, you aren't. I don't speak for the entirety of the left but I don't know a single person who hates Musk because he's just a rude person or whatever. Mostly they hate him because, as I've said a few times now already, he's an openly conservative crypto-pushing tech bro billionaire who busts unions, treats his workers like garbage, and built his "success" on daddy's apartheid emerald mine money.
If you want to reduce all that to "he's a douchebag", that's 100% an attempt to whitewash him, and a particularly weaselly one that would theoretically give you the cover you need to say "well I don't
support him, I think he's a douchebag lol", at least if it wasn't so obvious what you're doing that you could tell from space. Centrists do this shit all the time when they talk about someone they know they can't come out and openly support but they want to try and rehabilitate the image of. I've heard them make similar arguments about actual Nazis like Nick Fuentes and Richard Spencer. If instead of "they're open neo-Nazis" or "he's a billionaire neo-con scammer who hates worker's rights and benefits from apartheid" you say "they're douchebags" or whatever, it makes them a lot more palatable to the average person. After all
I'm a douchebag. Why should it bother me if they are too? Well, it turns out the criticisms of them go a bit deeper than "they're meanie poo-poo-heads" and to try and gloss over those more pointed criticisms with a completely meaningless one is, by definition, whitewashing. It's just a form of whitewashing that has a little bit of plausible deniability.
I don't really know if you're doing this intentionally or not but given pretty much everything else you've posted it would hardly be a stretch.
MrHands said:The solution to almost every bad part of capitalism is heavy government intervention in the same way as we've found to work in Europe. Higher taxes with a strong social safety net and a powerful government willing to step in when corporations practice anti consumerism by doing things such as supporting unions, breaking up monopolies, making fucking Apple use a regular phone charger etc. In addition certain services such as healthcare, roads, fire dept etc that are not beneficial to consumers as a for profit service should be nationalized (if private competition should be allowed is debatable).
You seem to bounce between a, like, borderline Objectivist AnCap and a lukewarm SocDem depending on what's convenient to you. To be fair this describes most liberals, I just find it funny. Just to be clear, when you say...
MrHands said:found to work in Europe.
... well, Europe is a big place with heavily varying degrees of government intervention. Are we talking about the Nordic model implemented in Sweden, Denmark, Finland, etc.? Or some more generalized overview of the EU or something?
At the end of the day, capitalism is profit-driven, even under a social democracy. If profit can't be extracted at home, it will be extracted abroad; we see this in the Nordic countries and how many of their companies force workers abroad in poorer, third-world countries to work under ruthless, inhumane conditions to make sure the line keeps going up back home despite the higher taxes. That's not even considering the fact that the bourgeoisie (substitute rich CEOs and business owners if you don't like that word)
will resist any attempt to reform the American economic system into a more socially democratic one.
To be fair, that's an argument against me and other socialists as well, but SocDems seek to work within the current system rather than remove it and build a more equitable one, which means you're playing by their rules right from the start. How do you expect to implement European-style social reforms when the U.S. can't form a cohesive response to climate change, or agree on a living minimum wage?
This is where I believe the bourgeoisie have already shown their belly by cracking down so hard on unions over the past 150 years and why I believe revolutionary unionism is the only non-violent path to social reform available to citizens of the U.S.
Any kind of social reform, whether we end up in a glorious anarcho-syndicalist utopia or some kind of soft capitalist SocDem state. After all, why are they content with electoralism but terrified of direct action? You mentioned strong unions so maybe you're on board at least to this point?