CheesyBrie said:Hey so I just want to start off saying in this post that I appreciate the time and effort that the OU council have put in this generation.
They have been more transparent and responsive to the player base, while also taking swift and corrective action on the problematic pokemon that have cropped up this generation.
Thank you Finchinator, ausma, ironwater, Ruft and TPP for all of your hard work thus far.
Now, I want to talk about the elephant in the room. Great Tusk.
I'm not posting to say "oh no Great Tusk is broken ban ban ban".
But this is the third consecutive month where it has been the top pokemon. With two consecutive months of an over 50% usage stat, I think there is something wrong with the OU tier. No pokemon should ever have that high usage. It's a cry for help. (Per the monthly stat charts displayed at the start of each month, Great Tusk had 37% in December, 53% in January, and 57% in February.)
Last generation, I think there was too much caution on behalf of banning problematic pokemon (too many suspect tests and not enough conversations among the council for quick bans). This led to heavily skewed usage stats of checks and counters that otherwise shouldn't have seen that much play (Looking at you Seismitoad). Clefable was good, but it was the only realistic answer to Urshifu-S.
I digress. My point here isn't the Great Tusk is problematic. But something is wrong with the meta, and the role compression offered by Great Tusk is probably the most efficient method to answer whatever that problem may be.
I'd assume Gholdengo is in a similar boat. It has 35%+ usage for the past three months. (37% in December, 43% in January, and 41% in Febrauary).
Something needs to be done. I would love to see Garganacl banned, as it just is dummy thiccccc (yes with five "C"s) and causes all sorts of problems.
However, I don't know what the actual problem is. I don't know if Great Tusk is a symptom or a cure, but I felt the need to call attention to it.
A parting thought: when the Home/DLC drops, I think we should learn from the mistakes of Gen 8. I don't think everything should be freed again (there were like... three suspects on Cinderace in gen 8 back when Libero was broken).
Please consider keeping all of the currently banned mons locked out of OU, or at least provide a transparent council vote on what should or shouldn't be allowed back. I'd also ask that the council vote on or outright ban any of the pokemon that were banned last gen. So Lando-I, Magearna, etc. Barring balance changes from Gamefreak, broken mons don't stop being broken, and I bet tera will help most of the Ubers more than hurt.
Again, I digress. My overall point is this: Something is wrong and clearly overcentralized in OU, moreso than possibly any other generation. Something is wrong, and I appreciate whatever changes may come to improve the health of the OU metagame.
Frankly I think the reason Great Tusk is so excessively used is quite obvious.
Generation 9 just simply doesn't have OU level viable hazard removers outside of Great Tusk and Corviknight, these two frankly just have so many more tools than the rest of the competition, and this isn't even on a level of them being "broken", they're just the two pokemon that can
reliably get rid of hazards. Couple that with the increased distribution of spikes. a lot of OU level pokemon getting Stealth Rocks, Glimmora and you're essentially required to have one of the two on your team. This is why Hatterene is so much more used than last generation, preventing hazards from going up is essential to a lot of more offensive playstyles, and even stall builds.
Gholdengo's usage is coupled with just how great hazards are this generation, the lack of pokemon that can A. remove hazards
and B. Beat Gholdengo 1v1, makes it such a great and appealing option in the current metagame. The lack of removal options is what causes both of these pokemon to be so great.
Last generation we had a ton of viable defoggers, Lando-T, Zapdos, Tornadus-T, Mandibuzz, Tapu Fini, all mons with either great typings or options for teams or reliable recovery. Once home comes around, this'll hopefully reduce the usage of these two (that is if we get more removal), but in this current metagame, Great Tusk, Corviknight and Gholdengo's usage is excessively bolstered by the great viability of hazards and the huge lack of viable removal.