The Faz said:Cringe. Just make it so under tera your first 2 types are replaced by the tera type (as normal) but you keep the extra type you had pre-tera; I see no reason for the tera ban here. The format already is built upon mons quickly changing their type, being able to do it for free once-per-game won't break much. Also, "would take longer making it work with the game" if you're talking coding-wise then something taking longer to code is in no way a basis to ban something.
I see no reason why not to base it around OU.
Additional questions:
- What about moves that fail, like Last Resort?
- How would this mechanic interact with Protean/Libero?
- How would this mechanic interact with Soak?
- Ghost type attacks are super against ghost-type mons, and only Dark and Normal types can properly fend off against these attacks. What stops something like Ceruledge with Brick Break/Bitter Blade/Shadow Claw/4rth Move (Shadow Sneak, Coverage or some other move)? Fire move to attack Goldengo, spammable ghost moves that get even better on the second hit (due to typing change) and fighting coverage for dark and normal types.
- In fact, what stops stall and defensive teams to being completely destroyed by Fighting mons? Recover is a normal move, making fighting much more potent at stallbreaking. Many defensive moves are either normal or poison, two types Great Tusk appreciates greatly. What's stopping Tusk from destroying the format?
In general, my thoughts are
- It needs a more thorough FAQ
- How will defensive teams survive on a meta that seems skewed towards offensive team structures?
Thank you for your comments. I'll try to address everything as I feel that it needs to be:
In regards to tera, the whole point of the meta is that the regular type combination is manipulated by the now "wild" third type. I suppose it'd be fine..? But I'd prefer if it wasn't allowed; it could always be tried out, however.
TL;DR, yeah maybe Tera could work. Dunno yet.
1. If it fails, it never activated, so just as if it was nullified by abilities that absorb the type, I imagine it'd be based on only if the move gave results.
2. Libero/Protean would act like Tera does I imagine. They only change the original two types to match the move they're about to use, and this meta only adds a type *after* they've been hit by a move. In other words, they have no correlation, and hence I don't think this is anything to worry about.
3. Soak will change the enemy's type to Water, and the user's third type to Water.
4. I see the issue, and I see two ways to approach that, sort of. For one, types being superior over another in OMs is not unheard of; there's been many times where the metagame has shaped around the strengths of one type and practically nonexistent for some others (see TCG's Dragon type or Steel type in Metronome battle; even though it's not an OM) The other way to see this is that not *every* Ghost type is going to be insanely good, and there's almost always a secondary type that you can target towards. See my Gholdengo argument: in this metagame you *can* find ways to break through Ghost types by forcing a type onto the Pokemon in question.
That, and if Ceruledge does become an issue, then there's always the case of "I don't know exactly what would be a threat or a ban. Thanks for pointing this out."
Great Tusk can definitely be looked at as a ban/threat. Thanks for pointing that out
5. Adds to the strategy. Of course, types are only changed at the END of the turn, meaning if a faster poke uses Recover it's not immediately going to be ruined by a Fighting type move. Plus, correct me if I'm wrong, but there's always Detect to change your type to Fighting.
Yes, absolutely; I need a better FAQ. I don't know exactly what to ask because the metagame is unpredictable IMO. And yet, I feel as if there's still a strategy to be made from this unpredictability factor. If you can't break a Pokemon with few weaknesses, give it a type that you *can* break through.
Defensive Pokemon does have it a bit rougher in an offensively chaotic metagame. However. I don't think it's impossible. In what way? I can't say for certain.
Thanks for the critique! If I missed something that I should try to answer LMK. I went ahead and did some revisions to the original post.