Alright, time for sub review + vetos!
Fragmented said:sub
Arcopod I don't know if your intention was to also have it as a fast Protean-based pivot but I should mention that I imagine that will be its primary role, since Webs is in a pretty horrible state with Boots existing now. Otherwise I think this looks fine. Protean Energy Ball on something with STAB Volt Switch would be scary if not for Batacomb gearing up to be the meta's primary Ground-type and Dragons, of which there are plenty right now, also serving as solid answers. Not really much to say here but maybe that's because this is my first mon here and I haven't gotten into the groove yet.
Conecurrent is a bit hard to comment on because our meta is still new and we don't really have any solid answers for it. Puffrost might do okay but would get worn down over time from Analytic-boosted STAB moves. At the same time it's not veto-worthy because it'd be fairly easy to make subs that answer it while not boosting the meta's power level too much. So to that I guess I can say that this looks like a legitimately interesting Pokemon to use or play against but it's hard to say much beyond that.
Blissier I'm gonna have to veto. Might be a meme sub and you might know this but the uptick in defense is enough to make it comparable to Mew while you still have obscene Sp. Def, strong utility options like Stealth Rock and Teleport, and Toxic returning means you're not as passive now.
Totally_Odette said:Might be broken, who knows? Not me.
I DO!!! BOW TO THE GLORY OF MY SUPERIOR OPINIONS!
Transistor gave me flashbacks at first but then I realized it was on a purely Physical Pokemon and realized it's probably fine, having an effective 135 BP Wild Charge instead of 90 is okay with me. If anything something gives me the feeling that Brontosect might be a touch underpowered since a hazard weakness is going to undercut both its bulk and breaking presence, especially with Wild Charge cutting into its bulk even further which I don't think Leech Life will make up for at all. Maybe boosting its Attack a bit would help, I know it has Waterfall but slower breakers like this aren't supposed to be easy to switch into as it stands.
Snowdentia I think looks cool, I recently messed with the idea of an Ice-type pivot with another type resistant to Rock when subbing to another mod and it could be fun here. Fair warning that I doubt this uses special movesets though since Close Combat and Triple Axel are leagues better than your special STAB options and you also have access to Fire Punch and a stronger U-Turn. The one big thing you lose is Thunder Punch being worse than Thunderbolt. This does have Switcheroo, Swords Dance, and Healing Wish which I think are fun here and should provide a fair bit of versatility.
It's not technically against the rules but I'm not a fan of Delphic Construct's name not fitting the usual Pokemon limit. That aside, the Jirachi comparison keeps sitting in my mind. This has marginally less bulk, no healing, and a fair bit more Sp. Atk with new Fire moves. Some part of me is concerned this won't be able to make progress super well since both of our Grounds and Skoloboros might make it difficult but it's still capable of checking some stuff we have here fine so it should be fine as is.
Spiderpig2398 said:subs
Burleon I feel is pretty distinctly underpowered. All of your physical moves have a very low base power, since I doubt this spends a moveslot on Facade since it'd be very inconsistent, and the base Attack stat itself is too unremarkable as it is. I'd just boost the Attack stat a bit to compensate and use our meta's current defensive Pokemon as a frame of reference for calcs.
Skeledune is probably also undertuned but I'm not as sure about it. Its bulk is fairly unremarkable for the offensive defensive mix this is trying to be and while the Sp. Atk is workable given the strong offensive typing, it might not hold up enough defensively to give this opportunities to do its thing and it might not be strong enough for a Sand Rush role. Similar thing here, I'd consider boosting Sp. Atk a bit; you can go a fair bit higher than similar Sun or Rain abusers since you're using lower base power moves and your main STAB move does not get boosted under weather. This also pushes it away from running Earth Eater which is somewhat concerning for me since this would not follow two Restrictions otherwise.
DenebStargazer said:sub
Fair warning - I don't see any reason Coulomari would run Taunt, but it does follow both Protean and Electric so it still follows two. Otherwise this thing seems like a massive headache to switch into. If you're centering this around a STAB Volt Switch, this has Surf to hit both of our big Grounds and can just chunk everything else with said STAB Volt Switch...or it can just Sludge Bomb the Grasses that would answer it, or in this particular case Psychic is better for Manchini. Don't know if this is a hard veto but it is a bit concerning to me.
Craygun should probably get Dark Pulse, because as far as I'm concerned, it would be barely any different had you subbed a Steel/Fighting with no ability. Dragon Pulse is not a very useful move, this would likely run Flash Cannon / Aura Sphere / TBolt / either Flip Turn or Shift Gear. Would make its ability look a lot more interesting and would make the sub as a whole much more fun.
How come Yamatoad doesn't get CC? By that I mean, uh, Close Combat. Not Cross Chop. I do think Cross Chop looks fine on it though and for that matter the mon itself looks fine as a whole, not really much to say here but I think it's cool that this is immune to Scald. If you want to avoid Close Combat because you don't want this to drop its own defenses then I think Cross Chop is a fine enough alternative.
flareth13 said:subs
Fraudurat looks underpowered as well. The utility is there for sure - Spikes is always great, and while pivoting and paraspreading are both cool, they're not enough reason to pick this over another hazard setter. It's not very threatening offensively because of its lack of coverage and doesn't really have enough defensive use off of its unimpressive typing and bulk. You could go about fixing this in a number of ways but the simplest and, in my opinion, coolest would be to make this part Dark-type and give it Knock Off. It would still have all of the enticing utility it normally does but would be much better at annoying the things that switch into its Electric moves.
Platysus I think looks fine and don't really have much to say about it. Ice Beam is pretty notable but everyone knows this gets that already, and this 100% is running Fur Coat over Sap Sipper if you want my opinion on that.
Spectorc is a bit much though, enough for me to veto it in its current state. Poltergeist off of that attack stat is very strong, Vessel of Ruin boosts its Sp. Def to an effective ~70ish which is very serviceable given how insane the physical bulk is and then you're backed by Shadow Sneak for faster stuff and then Play Rough and either Body Press or like Hammer Arm for things that resist Poltergeist. I'm also really not a fan of Spirit Break on this even if I can't say that's a reason to call this broken. Lowering Attack by 10 points would be enough to make it fine but even then I can't say I'm huge on this sub, I really don't like Pokemon whos whole shtick are that they have giant stats because they just never play interesting and enable power creep more than anything. If you want to center this around Body Press still I'd lower HP a substantial amount and put it into Sp. Def, maybe then swapping Vessel of Ruin out for something else. Hope this didn't come across as too ranty but I don't really want to hide any part of my opinion in a sub review.
Deviation395 said:sub
Our meta doesn't have a defensive Water-type yet and I'd normally check that for how Cetenor here should be adjusted but here we are. I know Manchini answers this but there's still a bit of an issue here. Part of me wonders if this Pokemon will ultimately end up pushing people into making a Water immune sub because of how this can just Flip Turn around its answers, chipping them down while being a strong enough move to scare things out, then freely healing a third of its health and grabbing momentum for its teammates. It's not big enough of an issue for me to want to veto but it's potentially concerning and I'd drop Flip Turn to be safe, U-Turn and Knock Off both do fine enough at annoying this thing's answers and making progress.
Loginator said:subs
Caerial hits a very strong similarity with Zapdos in OU for me but with Nasty Plot, Spikes, Prankster Taunt, and Energy Ball for options. Energy Ball is the only one of these that would be outright concerning but our Grounds don't care about it. We have several things that switch into this, some of which threatening it back very aggressively, but its defensive profile is still strong enough that I would just leave this as is.
Crocodire you might want to mark for Set 2 but I think is a bit much and will be vetoing. Urshifu comparison is a bit obvious but this has Hydro Pump and Focus Blast for substantially more initial power alongside Vacuum Wave. Lacks boosting but you're going to need to build very particular subs to switch into this properly since it also has Ice, Ground, and Psychic coverage to cover all of its bases. Removing Adaptability would be fine but you could bump up its Attacking stats a little bit as well if you want to compensate.
Set 3 mon needs a name or it will be vetoed, and after a second look I'm not sure if this wants to run two Dark moves after all since this has the utility sets being possible to disincentivize Swords Dance sets as well as coverage moves like Triple Axel, the Fire moves, and Poison Jab that compete with the Electric STAB + SD + Knock + Sucker Punch sets I thought this would have at a glance. I'd also remove Pursuit since I know dexited stuff is marked illegal by the teambuilder but it helps for clarity. Once that all is changed the sub will look fine.
LOrd Fernado said:subs
So first we have a part Fighting-type Protean Zeraora. Alright. Except this one doesn't have Volt Switch. Why not? I've also got to wonder if this even wants to run Protean in the first place since an Electric immunity can be a big deal and the only move Zeraora runs in standard that would be altered by this is Knock Off, which robs you of your other two STAB types until you manually switch out. Maybe Quick Attack could be worth something?? I'm unsure enough to the point where I won't veto it off of that but this sub probably could see some changes as it stands regardless, it plays super similarly enough to Zeraora in standard that it may just not be interesting enough for people to vote on it.
Magicism I think should be fine since straight up offensive sets have adequately been gutted if we compare it directly to Magearna. The biggest issue with Magearna was always that you don't know what it's going to do when you see it and the nerfs here squarely lock it into bulkier boosting sets like Draining Kiss + Stored Power + Calm Mind + Iron Defense. Very threatening, no doubt, but its bulk has taken a big hit and it still has the usual issue where anything blocking it from boosting gives it immediate problems.
Making another Ground/Flying-type is a bit of an unusual choice to me when our current splashable Regen user is Ground/Flying, but even that aside I'm not sure if I'm a fan of this. Bulk Up sets sound pretty annoying with that massive special bulk, and we really don't need another Ground-immune mon in general. I don't think it strikes me as big enough of a problem to veto since it might not be strong enough before it gets too many boosts but there's a lot that I'd change here.
DuoM2 said:sus
These are my subs. Since I reviewed yours, can you review mine on Discord? Thanks.
anaconja said:subs
This is still super similar to Cinderace, kinda boring. Its moves are a lot weaker, but Fire Lash and Knock Off's utility make up for it. Might run into some power issues seeing as Libero is nerfed and it's relying on 80bp moves.
When whoever it was earlier said that we had Regen Zarude here they weren't kidding. Only difference is you sacrifice Close Combat and U-Turn for Earthquake. I think all of those plus Regenerator would be enough to make it stand apart from the Pokemon it's based on although I'd consider lowering the Defense a bit just to be sure it doesn't end up too overtuned since the stats here are very big.
Set 3 sub seems alright, maybe a little weak for what you're trying to do here. This is an Ice-type that's likely locked out of an item and the base power of its moves aren't too high, plus you'll be hitting people neutrally a vast majority of the time. Slight Sp. Atk increase couldn't hurt here. I don't see any way a weather abuser that needs to get to +2 would be problematic here without a bunch of extreme qualities that this thing doesn't have.
...okay yeah I just copied that first bit from Mossy's sub review a few slates ago, but this is a resub, I agree with it and also had a lot to go through and wanted to go to sleep soon. Also your Set 2 and 3 subs will need names again.
Mossy Sandwich said:sub
I already made the Teraqua comparison on Discord, it was fine there and will be fine here. Meta needs a bulky Water so I'm not opposed to something like this and honestly don't see much reason to complain about it in general since boosting sets seem pretty honest as well. Not really much to say here.
24 hours to make changes before voting starts! If you want to do anything more drastic or are nerfing a vetoed sub, it never hurts to ask for feedback on Discord to be sure everything's alright!