Although I got absolutely smacked in Derby, I truly enjoyed building and trying to learn the intricacies of ADV DOU so I wanted to make this post to share my thoughts on the format, in the hope to contribute a bit to it. Even though ADV DOU has its flaws, I feel like the amount of hate it gets is sometimes a bit undeserved, I think there is a ton of interesting thing going on in games and I’m honestly sometimes a bit sad that all people seem to see are Explosion and old gen crits being stupid, because I believe ADV DOU can be much more than that. I put a lot of effort in trying to learn the tier so I have a lot to say (i also like rambling about pokemon), but I am still new to ADV DOU (and to be honest i don't have that much exp in doubles formats in general) so don't take this post too seriously lol, maybe it's full of evil lies...
I’d say the biggest roadblock I’ve met while trying to learn the tier is that it can be a bit difficult to get games as not a lot of people play this format in the first place, and it felt that way even before Derby. It can be kinda discouraging to spend time trying to assemble a team just to not be able to find a game afterwards, but to be fair that’s an a thing with niche formats in general and if u are really resolved to find games you’ll find them eventually (free adv matchmaking role @doucord???).
Here are my thoughts on some stuff:
:marowak:
I always wondered why you can't put sprites in spoiler titles
I think max spdef is the good spread: imo it should be more thought as a defensive mon, with thick club allowing it to not be a sitting duck. I’ve seen pple mostly use it as a support for Gyarados (and occasionally Suicune), but it can be so much more than that: Zapdos, currently the best Pokemon in the tier (imo) is to be expected in almost any matchup, and redirecting tbolt is very appreciated by a lot of stuff that would not enjoy taking it, such as Metagross, your own Zapdos, Aerodactyl, whatever else - the sky is the limit! It also greatly enjoy the absence of team preview which means it can always jump out of nowhere to make Zapdos its bitch. Marowak also can help a ton against Raikou, which even though it is uncommon it can be incredibly threatening in the right position. Aside from the matchup against the electrics, Marowak is not a great mon but it’s not awful either, mono ground is a decent defensive typing which gives it access to STAB EQ, and even with no offensive investment it can still hit stuff quite hard and make stuff happen, even though its bulk comes a bit short sometimes, and it can get stuffed by intimidate.
It has some interesting moves it could run: imo only earthquake/bonemerang and protect are given but aside from that and the (imo optional) rock coverage, it can run icy wind, counter (which trolls Zapdos even harder, as counter works on every hidden power), hp bug (hitting Celebi can be incredibly valuable imo) or perish song (useful vs slow setup), and I guess brick break maybe has its uses to break bricks screens and be a single-target move that hits lax and ttar for the same damages than eq. I’m honestly not convinced by swords dance at all, but maybe that’s because I’m bad, I just don’t see what that helps against. If you are completely irrational you can run sing to cheese people.
Icy wind in general (so not just on Marowak) looks like incredible support: ADV DOU KO mechanics mean that after your offensive guy killed something, a would-be revenge killer can be still caught by a slower icy wind on the same turn, which sounds just phenomenal to me, as you can p much guarantee that anything that tries to come in will be at -1 speed, whether they come in after a KO or through a switch (On an related note: you can do something similar with T-Wave, and catch something coming in, thus wasting their lum berry if they have one, making them vulnerable to status from the following turn.). At the time of writing this, I still have kind of no idea what are the Gooder Ways take advantage of that, but so far I had the impression that CM Celebi (+IDK, I happened to have one in a team with icy wind Swampert) and Moltres (+Marowak) did fine abusing that
:tyranitar:
Sand
I mostly want to talk about the sandstorm weather here because I think it’s cool. Although ADV DOU is quite fast paced, I found sand chip to have a couple useful applications, especially if you get to pivot ttar in early game (more on that later). As switches happen before sand damages apply, every sand affected Pokemon that are not holding leftovers will start playing the game at 93,75%, which allow you to spare some EVs investment on your mons to get the damages rolls you want so you can invest more in an other stat. Depending on the scenarios you are trying to take account of, you can also aim for lower sand ranges, like 87,5% or 81,25%, which can save a lot of EVs.
Sand cutting into the bulk of stuff is especially helpful against Snorlax, either by neutering leftovers or just chipping it overtime, as its bulk is part of what makes it as threatening as it is imo (especially since aside from self destruct, Snorlax damage output can be a bit disappointing. I mean come on, it needs max atk adamant to have a 94% chance to ko 0 bulk gengar, isn’t that a bit sad?). For example, if non leftovers Snorlax spends 3-4 turns on the field, it will passively lose 18,75%-25% of its HPs. From playing I felt that Snorlax is significantly easier to beat down when sand is up, to the point I believe pivoting Ttar directly into it can sometimes be worth, depending on the situation. Now, I imagine this play might look a bit suspicious considering Ttar often wants to be preserved to set up a dd later, however when you expect that nothing that could really threaten ttar is coming in given the state of the board (especially if ttar was not revealed yet) I believe it is definitively a play to consider, for example if you expect Snorlax to hit Gengar with a shadow ball or something like that. This is also one of the many reasons why I running bulk on dd ttar, which also helps vs for ex Zapdos. I tried to use lead ttar but i found it really underwhelming. I tried other sets in the lead position too (band(<-generally outclassed by Regirock I think, esp since you can about intimidate), mixed and counter) but I could not make it work :[ Maybe the reader has an idea?
Sand can also help pushing your stuff into a pinch berry/blaze/overgrow/whatever range. It also enables stupid ass sand veil. SD Gligar is a decent mon, although its stats kinda let it down it still has a good defensive typing and stab EQ is good, I think it can hold its own enough that you can use it to good effect even if it doesn’t end up dodging anything, and of course when it does dodges something I can be really gamebreaking. I’ve thought about Cacturne too but idk what you’d do with it, its typing is meh/bad vs most of the tier and its stats are horrible. It has encore, which might do something, I faced encore leech in Derby but it didn’t manage to be really threatening, it dodged 0 moves but probably wouldn’t have been much of a problem even if it did. It gets Teeter Dance (confuses the entire field besides the user) which is probably gimmicky but also sounds potentially very funny alongside sand veil, and at least has the merit to potentially waste two opposing lum berries and your opponent’s faith in humanity. Skill swap CM Celebi/Blissey can steal Sand Veil for themselves because they are certainly not unkillable enough as is so they should also have the ability to dodge explosion (+ sand veil also makes them immune to sand which they definitively appreciate).
Last but not least, sand reveals speed tiers on sand affected pokemon, which can be useful
A tierlist:
The truth about tier 2 is that i have no idea on how to order aero/arc/ttar/mie so the current order is kinda random. Maybe Marowak scammed me and is actually t3. HPump sucks so maybe Starmie is t3 too... The last tier probably has a couple of actually legit mons but it's generally just dumb stuff i thought about while messing around in the builder, either by trying to do too much stuff in a slot or enabling dumb concepts that try to take advantage of something, or just mons i'm getting noobbaited by. I built with a bunch of them but didn't get the opportunity to try them out yet, especially since i needed to test out stuff more likely to be good than these abominations. Please pretend there is no Aggron on this tierlist i'm not a believer anymore this mon is so much worse than i thought
Reasoning behind my horrible takes
:zapdos:
The typing is so good, it hits almost everything hard, and it helps a lot vs meta as most sets can only hit it with boom. That being said i'm not completely sure it is the top1 pokemon but i felt like it's at least the easiest pokemon to spam, it helps vs a lot, can be ev'd to live pretty much any non-boom move in the tier out of sand (like band hp rock aero) if you want to and still have enough EVs to spare to outspeed Jolly metagross and have some SpA investment EVs with a modest nature (which it's all it really needs imo) and there isn't that much ground immunes/resists to choose from in the first place so that on its own make it easy to consider in a lot of team i think. I often have no idea what to do with the last move to be honest, from my understanding sub to help with boom is the standard so i just use that. No idea what to think about Twave when so much is running lum, although maybe you can just click twave twice sometimes? When watching games i saw pple using some cool stuff like bp + pinch berry, rain dance, light screen and agility. I was told about drill peck but then i did the calcs vs celebi and i cried. Maybe roar could be funny to deny setup from gyarados + marowak (or suicune), or just annoy setup in general and get to scout the opposing team a bit more as a bonus.
:celebi: :snorlax:
Honestly i'm not sure which one of the two is the best, although in general i'm not sure how easily you can get away without including at least one of these two. I'm a big fan of Celebi as i think ground/elec/water resists are super valuable and it gets the right stab combination to actually threaten the stuff it wants to check. In general i think they help checking/trading with a million stuff and that's why i rank them so high. Additionally, if you look at my tier 2, you can see a lot of Pokemon i think are good are be super threatened by Starmie, thus making Starmie a very threatening Pokemon in my eyes, which make me value Snorlax and Celebi even more. Snorlax might be the better of the two, because Celebi has a harder time threatening Metagross unless it runs CM HP Fire, and that set has issues trying to fit everything it wants to fit, like you certainly won't me able to fit protect and recover.
I really like CM HP Fire Celebi, although i believe it wants a plan vs boom or like a plan in the back that takes advantage of one of the boomers nuking Celebi, and once you do that you can wield cool gameplans i think, because one of gengar/meta/lax being gone (especially meta/lax) is a huge deal. I've been very interested by lead curse lax (normal stab + 2 of tect/sball/eq, lefties or lum) + arcanine, curse lax can be hard to kill and start trading as soon as the game start, and arcanine helps it with intimidate, threatens out metagross that could otherwise try to boom the lax, weaken boom from gengar and can use charm on other laxes to make them much less threatening. Credits to Zee for the charm thing by the way, idk if they were the one who actually invented it but i saw them use it in a replay and i thought it was super cool so i started using it too, i think being able to neuter other laxes is epic, although i don't even know if this was the original purpose of the set, or if there is more to it (dd ttar?).
:metagross:
Meta never felt like a top1 pokemon to me, i thought this was because i'm bad but then i asked some adv dou gamers about it and apparently this is a take that actually exists, and one of them even told me that they believe meta might not even be top 5. Thank you for telling me that because now i can put it in t2 without feeling bad.
My personal grief with Metagross is that, even though i don't deny it is one of the most, if not the most, centralizing/threatening mon in the tier, i don't think it is as good/spammable/consistent than the 4 guys i put above it. It is quite slow, and while it does have a very good bulk and typing, it still takes a lot from EQ and strong/super effective special moves, which are easy to stack on a team, and i believe you should probably almost always do it because Metagross will kick your ass otherwise. My thought here is that the tier being warped around making sure Metagross is not going to do dumb stuff for free plays in its defavor. Also its main way to hit Zapdos and the waters is boom which isn't always the most ideal, especially since Zapdos can run substitute, and a big reason why Arcanine exists in the first place is to cook Metagross.
Even though Meta is considerably more dangerous than the mons i ranked above it, i think there are more reasons to use these mons than Metagross, because in my opinion they are more helpful when trying to prepare for the metagame than Metagross, although i imagine this is more of a tierlist philosophy thing. Ironically one of the main reasons why i put Zapdos in top1 is because it helps a lot against Metagross!
Don't get me wrong though i'm not calling Metagross bad, it's still Metagross
Also i think agility might be cool, although you'll need to work around the lack of a moveslot, i brought it twice in derby and iirc it scored 2+ kills every time and got similar results in test games so i'm starting to be a fan. From my experience i felt like this set usually wants to be hp rock+mash+tect, although idk what the standard is. I've been messing around with choice band a bit too, tried it with one million spdef to try to trade with things better but i doubt it's very good %) I thought return/double-edge on band could be cool for the strong neutral hit as i've seen it running that in adv singles sometimes but didn't get to use it much yet
:tyranitar:
I already talked about sand, but i think i really like ttar as a dd wincon too. It can be so scary and i felt like it can be super rewarding to use if you position it well, if you get to push metagross in range, prepare the board for it, stuff like that. I think there is merit to move some EVs from atk to hp, ofc the power is nice but being able to eat stuff like tbolt from zapdos or EQs more comfortably is nice (you can even eat a mash guaranteed from meta if you are max hp, although you probably don't want to do that usually). Probably should always be max speed for starmie at +1?
:exeggutor: :charizard: :shiftry:
No idea how good sun actually is, i never even used it, but every time i saw it i got smacked by it, i can't tell if that's just me not knowing how to play against it or if it's actually as threatening as i feel like it is, although i think sun also punishes me for using Celebi as my special check over thick fat lax. Exeggutor sometimes felt weirdly unkillable to me because of its good typing, also the chloro mons get boom which is scary as well.
:registeel:
>:[
I hate prepping for amnesia+iron defense Registeel, please tell me if there is something i don't realize but it sometimes felt like i had to go a bit out of my way in the builder to be fine against it. I remember when prepping for Lhions, i saw some Registeels in their scout so i brought a taunt Gengar, thinking it was still a decent move even outside of the registeel matchup as it gives more security vs stuff like dd tar, rain, cm users, so setup in general (i imagine there is probably some merit to deny protect too, or troll a zapdos trying to avoid boom by blocking sub). They did bring demon registeel, so i thought i could just ignore it for the time being and KO the rest of their team first then handle it with Gengar, however Gengar couldn't do enough damages to it and just died to sand. Ngl i am the only one to blame for not thinking about Registeel just outlasting Gengar with sand lol (especially since i even had ttar in the team too), however i'm still left wondering how else you are supposed to deal with the mon besides fishing for a crit? Is it just a skill issue, is there some plays i have to make vs Registeel? Is it possible to just overwhelm it? So far i've been mostly using Recover Celebi (or anything with 16+ pp recovery really) to pp stall it and Curse Gengar, which i think is not so awful outside of the Registeel matchup because it still can help vs fat setup, kinda acts as a coverage move against Lax, can hit stuff behind protect, but i don't think i can slap one of these two in every team i make ever. I was told about lefties Gengar and Perish Song but are those things u'd want to run otherwise?
So what's the solution? Is it just a case of #PlayBetter?
:gligar:
I talked about it in the ttar spoiler, and i definitively think it should be ranked, although i admit tier 4 is probably overhyping it
tldr: a bit stretched out with EVs cuz the stats are kinda shit but still a functional mon because good enough defensive typing (esp w/ the elecs usually running hp grass, although weaknesses to water/ice is really annoying vs Gengar and Starmie), stab eq, sd, of course you mostly use it because it gets sand veil but it still does ok even when sand veil doesn't proc. The idea is that you use it to fish for luck, but even if you don't get the luck you'll still be fine as it's not too horrible of a mon.
:gorebyss:
It's as swift swimmer as strong as Omastar but isn't weak to EQ and resists mash, and is much stronger than ludicolo. Under rain and with mystic water it reaches calcs Ludicolo could not even dream of (maybe those spreads aren't real idk, just there to compare):
252+ SpA 30 IVs Mystic Water Gorebyss Hydro Pump vs. 0 HP / 0 SpD Zapdos in Rain: 351-414 (109.3 - 128.9%) -- guaranteed OHKO
252+ SpA 30 IVs Mystic Water Gorebyss Hydro Pump vs. 252 HP / 0 SpD Zapdos in Rain: 351-414 (91.4 - 107.8%) -- 50% chance to OHKO
252+ SpA 30 IVs Mystic Water Gorebyss Hydro Pump vs. 252 HP / 0 SpD Metagross in Rain: 351-414 (96.4 - 113.7%) -- 81.3% chance to OHKO
vs
252+ SpA Mystic Water Ludicolo Hydro Pump vs. 4 HP / 0 SpD Zapdos in Rain: 300-354 (93.1 - 109.9%) -- 62.5% chance to OHKO
252+ SpA Mystic Water Ludicolo Hydro Pump vs. 252 HP / 0 SpD Zapdos in Rain: 300-354 (78.1 - 92.1%) -- guaranteed 2HKO
252+ SpA Mystic Water Ludicolo Hydro Pump vs. 252 HP / 0 SpD Metagross in Rain: 300-354 (82.4 - 97.2%) -- guaranteed 2HKO
In my opinion, if ludicolo and omastar are considered to be ranked then gorebyss probably should be too. To be clear, much like the other two swimmers, i believe Gorebyss is probably better alongside Kingdra instead of over it.
:steelix:
This mon is actually so sad, i can't tell you how many times i looked at it and went like "oh my god this mon actually solves the tier" but then i saw it being unable to do any sort of damages to anything, i mean come on the mon even is walled by Gengar of all things :( The real way to save adv is to free mega steelix i'm afraid
Now on some of the shitmons:
:nidoking: :nidoqueen:
Maybe there is some use for flatter? They are the only two mons that get it that also have more than 3 bst. I think as Pokemon they lose to the whole tier barring the electrics and arcanine though lol
:hitmontop:
I tried to use this guy a couple times because intim + rock resist + fighting stab for lax + stab mach punch looked appealing but it let me down every time :( The mach punch calcs are really super sad, it does 80% max roll to 0 bulk ttar and everything else just eats, and in general it has some serious power issues. Breloom might be better but probably still bad i imagine, it's stronger but also frailer and dies to more things i think
:poliwrath:
Rock check, fighter so maybe it does ok vs lax, damp, maybe could be paired with marowak...? (so just damp + excuses to convince yourself you aren't practicing self sabotage by running the mon)
I think an interesting application for damp is with your own boom lax/meta + bp zapdos (most probably meta+zap in the lead position): meta can click boom, and as zapdos bps out you see what clicked protect on the opposing side or if gengar came in, and then you can choose to block your own boom with poliwrath or go gengar and let the boom go off. I never actually tried this out though /shrug, and i doubt you want to try to do that every game, and blocking your own boom as a response to gengar can lead to an annoying position anyway since poliwrath just dies to it. In general i had a super hard time finding uses for the damp mons aside from blocking boom since their stats are just so bad. Maybe to enable some cm/sd celebi pass thing idk
So i think boom meta + bp zap + poli + gengar + 2 fillers is probably the best shot you could have with poli, no idea what the two last slots should be though. One of celebi/lax/marowak maybe?
:magneton:
Magnet pull isn't what interests me with it, although it's probably a nice bonus. I thought about it as a lead, 80 hp investment means you always live a fire punch from timid gengar and almost always 2 tbolts from modest zapdos and proc salac, you can hit some stuff hard, and draw a banded eq for something in the back to take advantage of. Probably still awful lol but still a perfect addition to the basically shitpost tier
:kecleon:
ngl I put it on the tierlist by accident and i only noticed after uploading the image, and i'm too lazy to remove it
:wobbuffet:
Is there any consistent ways to use that thing? I always wondered, no idea what u can do with it. I put Wynaut here for reasons i'm not brave enough to explain.
:regice:
I looked at the mon and brain went like "zapdos big usage => clicking stab ice beam from the mon with big spdef good", but i never was appealed enough to actually try it cuz its matchup vs metagross bothers me too much
:lapras:
What if you were an ice type but instead of dying to Metagross you die to the n*1 ice beam target Zapdos? (By extension, most ice weak mons can hit you quite hard)
:articuno:
What if you were an ice type but you die to metagross and zapdos? (it has stats though)
:cloyster: :glalie: :jynx:
Okay well i think you can tell i got a bit desperate at some point. Glalie has boom, cloyster has boom and lapras syndrome, jynx has psychic and lovely kiss to pray for no lum berry 75% of the time, but they are all so slow and die to everything
On the topic of cloy and glalie, i tried spikes a bit out of curiosity and unsurprisingly they don't seem to do anything besides pressuring lax a bit esp w/ sand, maybe they can help secure some rolls vs some things i dunno, but all the spikers seem to be horrible mons so it is probably just self sabotage, although considering the list of mons we went over you can guess i'm probably self sabotaging myself more frequently than i'd like to admit it anyway
:smeargle:
I don't have the slightest idea of what you do with this mon but i saw it in someone's else vr and since everything you see on the internet is correct it means Smeargle is viable
Tiering opinions
To conclude: i don't have enough experience with the tier to have any strong opinion on boom, maybe we just aren't good enough at midgrounding it/pressure the boomers idk, however i disagree with the argument that it should be kept because part of the identity of the tier because this is not really competitively driven and isn't something that should be relevant to tiering, at least in my opinion - in any cases i think boom might even be overshadowing lot of other aspects unique to this tier. I also disagree that we should keep boom for stuff like gyarados and suicune, i think those mons might be overrated, and if something as high risk to click as boom is what prevents them from being broken maybe they are already kind of dumb? I doubt a boom ban would lead to more than 2 bans (if any at all) considering how low the power level is in adv, but who knows, i'm certainly not qualified to say. If it is believed that banning boom would make the tier more competitive, it should def be considered.
I imagine this is not on the table as of now as i don't think it had any success yet but i believe Sand Veil should definitively be banned, you know what it can do and i can bet it will do it as some point (even if it doesn't, that kind of nonsense shouldn't be allowed anyway to be honest).
Focus Band is a worse Quick Claw but should be banned too because it essentially can do the same thing, and even Kings Rock. Maybe Scope Lens is dumb but that idk, free extra chances to do 200% damages on a tier memed on for its variance where there is little opportunity cost on the item slot might have silly uses on anything that could consider dropping lum. I think the dumbest part is that maybe it already has seen some use but there is no way to tell just by watching the replays (maybe in .logs? idk). Usually i have no problems with Scope Lens as i don't think it's really comparable to peak game designs tier items like Quick Claw or Bright Powder, but i think if there is one format where it could be dumb it's probably adv dou. Luck items are always incredibly controversial though and i'm aware probably not much is going to happen to them unless they start ruining a tour.
Thank you
sir jelloton for giving me the opportunity to play, and thank you a lot
SuckyLucky Penter Genesis77 Flying Beagle for the advices/test games, and thank you
Frixel for being the goat