Aberforth said:Ubers Tiering Leader here: Doing anything other than banning or allowing Terapagos as a whole would be a mistake.
Fundamentally all you are arguing for is to restrict the ability of Terapagos to use Tera. This is something every tier leader wants to avoid; every tier has at least one banned mon that would be fine if its ability to tera would be restricted. While Terapagos tera'ing does give it more benefit than any other Pokemon, implementing a Tera List is something nobody with any say in tiering wants to see in any way shape or form.
Talking about Mega Ray and Megas in general
Ubers banned Mega-Ray because we were banning a Mega, we just had to implement a clause because there was no handy item that could be banned. Its also much more of an exception because it was literally the first ever pokemon ban Ubers had, and came at a time when trust in the Ubers Leaders to run suspects was at an all-time low, while something simply needed to be done. There was also precedent from OU to ban Megas instead of the outright Pokemon itself that we were following, as opposed to Tera-Banning Terapagos, and Ubers also explicitly looks to ban as few things as possible, especially at that stage when Mega Ray was what changed the philosophy of Ubers to let Pokemon be banned from it at all. The
OP of this thread has even acknowledged this before, Ubers should not be used for OU precedent.
The teambuilder does not show things like the Mawilite being banned in the ORAS OU tier, but that is for simplicity of use, because when people build or look at analyses, they dont look for items, they look for Pokemon. Initially in gen6, the mega and the base form were actually tiered together but the item was suspected (
see places like this where the suspect was for the Sablenite), it was separated into just tiering the Megas like a separate pokemon itself midway through the gen to avoid situations (that were happening) where fringe OU Megas (Pinsir) would drop into UU, get banned, and then regular pinsir would drop down the tiers one shift at a time until Mega-Pinsir went back to OU. It was causing disruption and annoyance in the lower tiers, and depriving them of good options in the meta. I dont think Megas are a good analogy to Terapagos, because there is not a uniquely different aspect to Terapagos that we could isolate without having it simply be "Terapagos cannot use Tera".
I am not convinced by this post or any of those which talk about how banning Mega-Rayquaza was a necessary evil because it isn't linked to an item. Mega-Rayquaza is linked to a move, that's a non Pokémon element just like items. We even got lucky with only Rayquaza being able to viably use this move in any tier.
Ubers had 2 other options, ban Rayquaza (Pokemon ban) and ban Dragon Ascent (move ban), that would follow tiering policy as you explain it. If I follow you correctly, Ubers ignored these options for something totally unorthodoxal from a tiering perspective and this doesn't deserve a mention anywhere? I only see two possible options; tiering was awful back then and people wanted to preserve Dragon Ascent Rayquaza in Ubers, or Mega-Rayquaza is its separate entity as it follows the current definition of what constitutes an alternative form. I'm fine with current leadership telling us banning Mega-Rayquaza was a mistake, but it definitely wasnt caused by the lack of other options.
Also out of curiosity, I clicked the thread you linked about how Terastal shouldnt be compared to Mega-Rayquaza and the only mention I found about it is
Marty stating it is not a mod to prevent Mega-Rayquaza from Mega Evolving as it is a basic agreement to not use an option that they are never forced to use.
Kris said:I feel like a lot of people are ignoring the precedent of Wishiwashi? It has a really lame base form and a battle-only form that is triggered through an ability. They're tiered together. The only difference is a third form that Terapagos has access to, which is not locked behind something easily bannable (ability with Zyg-c precedent, item with mega precedent, move with ... well nothing? idk), and the argument of "Terapagos-S has different BST so it should be tiered separately" falls through when we had a Pokemon that arguably (?) could've been legal in OU in Darmanitan-Galar-Zen if we had just banned Gorilla Tactics instead of Darmanitan-Galar. The answer then was that it was pretty much a complex ban and that forming a complex ban for a Pokemon that was made broken due to something unique to them (in Gorilla Tactics) was a non-starter, and that's also the answer that's being provided now, but people don't seem to want to listen.
No, we are not ignoring these forms. The thing is that these forms are locked behind the use of the superior form. I cannot start the battle as Darmanitan-Z or Meloetta-P. You are right though that both Wishiwashi forms could be tiered differently with the use of sub level 20 Wishiwashi which cant turn into Wishiwashi-School and would be the only mean to use Wishiwashi-Solo independly from its School form. That said I dont know if you can make a precedent of it, as I suspect that the unviability of sub level 20 Wishiwashi-Solo and the fact that it is the only form change locked behind a level threshold are the reasons why nobody ever cared about tiering them separately.
This is also funny because we have precedents of forms that were held in higher tiers by their base forms. Mega-Slowbro and Mega-Garchomp were OU by technicality in ORAS (and SM in Garchomps case). Terapagos-Stellar is similar to those, it shouldnt be able to drop lower than Terapagos-Terastal, but Terapagos-Stellar should be able to be tiered in tiers above Terapagos-Stellar.
Aberforth said:Terapagos-Stellar is not a pokemon, it is an in-battle forme change accomplished by using Tera. If you could Tera a different pokemon on the team and still use Terapagos-Stellar, I might have a different opinion, but I see Terapagos-Stellar as being Terapagos using Tera, not as a Pokemon itself that should be tiered seperately.
Megas were a different mechanic that I do not think should be used as precedent. One of the fundamental principles behind mega evolution was that you could have one per team, whereas one of the fundamental principles behind Tera is that every pokemon can do it. I do not think that Megas are a good justification to have anything even superficially resembling a Tera-List.
The thing is you are stating your opinion that is based on basically nothing. I am not saying it in a mean way, but I do think it is irrelevant when it goes against established rules and doesn't explain why we should deviate from said rules except for your personal likings. There is a current definition of what counts as separate forms, this definition has been linked already twice in this thread and states that what constitutes a different form for tiering is different BST, typing, or dex number. There is no mention of abilities or items or anything similar. Terapagos-Stellar changes its stats upon Terastallization, it is different from Ogerpon because the latter doesnt change its stats, but it is not different from Mega-Evolution because items have never been the reasons why Mega-Evolution were tiered separately from their base forms.