gregdawiz said:The claim that its outdated hasn't even been proven. You guys just keep saying 'its old' like that's a reason??? Its like psychotic almost how against sleep clause y'all are when there is very little substatial arguments for thowing it away??? I mean you Mr Buzzwole in this post literally are saying the reason it is outdated is that its old and from a spinoff (as well as an out of nowhere comparison to 4chan) when that has no correlation. Old =/= outdated in every case. You're not even providing a legitimate reason why its bad.
The only substantial claim I've heard against it is regarding "cart-accuracy" which is not something the community even agrees on.
I feel like if we are talking about removing a whole mechanic (sleep moves clause) and not reforming sleep clause, then the burden of proof does have to be incredibly high. This goes back to every other ban in OU, where we have to prove moves even as blatantly broken as last respects are broken on even their worst abusers. If it really is just 3 mons causing the issue, it's they who should be banned.
It's a gameplay mod that exists solely to nerf a specific element, which means it runs contrary to tiering policy and only exists due to the grandfather clause. Freeze Clause in past gens is also a gameplay mod, but in that case the alternative is functionally banning Ice moves, with Aurora Beam and its 65 BP the strongest without a freeze chance, and so it endures.
In this way, it is different than the battle timer, or showing percentage health, or showing available PP, or the damage log. Those are all gameplay mods as well (though the last two can be functionally replicated on a cart match with pen and paper) but the intent is convenience, rather than applying a nerf to something.
Unlike most, I'm not reflexively opposed to complex bans; I think that when properly targeted, they can have a place, such as DPP Baton Pass, where it's allowed purely as a pivoting move but not as a 'passing' move. I'm not even opposed to nerfing things to balance them, as long as it doesn't set problematic precedent, so I don't mind changing Sleep Clause into "You cannot use a move that causes sleep if you have already put an opposing mon to sleep," and just grey out the button, because that's not literally modifying game mechanics. It's replicating a gentlemen's agreement, and it does differ slightly in actual gameplay: losing the ability to sleep a mon coming out of sleep, or using sleep moves to PP stall.
I'm also not opposed to just nuking sleep moves in general, whether or not that ends up including Yawn. I just want the current iteration of Sleep Cause banned, because once again: it's a gameplay mod that meaningfully changes how we play the game.