NOC Pokemon Mystery Dungeon Mafia - Explorers - Game Thread (Game Over!)

Celever said:
Shane’s playstyle is incredibly attractive to me (interpret that attractive as you will) but before this burst post I’d already come up with the following read:

I think Shane is town, I think his first push is town (genisu?) and I think that the far overblown backlash to that first push is scum being threatened by him and wanting to harm his positioning while feeling free to do so because they weren’t buddying their partner in the process.

A large number of players jumped on the Shane read and some of those people will be town parroting their townreads (probably the first person to jump on him is likelier town than the second person for instance) but all in all I think that the reaction to Shane making a single wallpost is wild
Click to expand...

Celever said:
I think M2H not connecting the dots between “Neon claimed to absorb the first town role that dies automatically” and genisu’s point that Neon could just, actively absorb the first town role that dies as cover for that, even after genisu walked her right up to the point of reasoning before that conclusion, fascinating.

Would M2H bus her partner early D1 only to rescind it upon this roleclaim? Yeah, probably. And the “Neon would never think of this” point is undermined by the fact that M2H would think of it. And we all know the first time Neon’s scum he’s in scumchat like “I gotta claim page 5 what do I do”.

Significant S/S eq between those two, even if I’m not particularly scumreading either rn.
Click to expand...


Celever said:
Two separate lines of thought, yeah. Based on more macro thread dynamics Shane should be town, but the specific convo M2H made me look at is a S/S Shane and Laurel sitch for sure. Both running theories don’t have to be right at the same time though, and Laurel is scummy independently of that.
Click to expand...

All the bolded are points that I think town!you would be incentivized to push because you the think situation is bad where mafia are power wolfing or whatever. The fact that you pursue none of these and vote laurel is just...lol. The very fact that you are now trying to post about it only when I'm voting you is sus.

I suppose I should give you a pass for voting laurel if you think that flipping laurel gives you a better idea of Shane. But eh.
 
M2H said:
Now we bring it back to my sister in Christ. My sister in Christ, a wagon is not a magic tool that applies pressure to somebody. That's a bit of a misnomer. Actually being a likely vote creates pressure. Putting votes on me for instance would do literally nothing to me.
Click to expand...
what the fuck are you talking about? this isn't about pressure i literally got asked where i want to put my vote so i gave some thought on where i would want to put my vote

this isn't abt you this is about the state of the game and the fact i haven't placed a vote yet.
 
a fairy said:
what the fuck are you talking about? this isn't about pressure i literally got asked where i want to put my vote so i gave some thought on where i would want to put my vote

this isn't abt you this is about the state of the game and the fact i haven't placed a vote yet.
Click to expand...

Your category said "needs a wagon" which is a weird way to talk about null reads unless you thing a wagon will generate info through pressure.
 
Also bluedoom you we’re voting me when I wasn’t pushing all the people you wanted me to push IIRC so idk why you’re saying “you’re only doing it now I’m voting you” but ok
 
M2H said:
Your category said "needs a wagon" which is a weird way to talk about null reads unless you thing a wagon will generate info through pressure.
Click to expand...

okay if this is about wording that's fine - the wording i chose was to make a distinct btwn laurel and pulsar, who have wagons on there that i dislike and wouldn't join unless they got new logic, and then the rest of the "would vote if a reasonable wagon formed" folk. nothing about pressure
 
Celever said:
JALMONT is a later addition yeah IIRC, it’s mainly Clouds/bluedoom and JALMONT latched onto that overnight. P sure I said that
Click to expand...
no, i mean, i get that, i just didn't get any idea that jalmont "latched onto" anything, his top two scumreads are people that have been far and away under the radar for the majority of the game and he has seemed unconcerned with galvanizing people this phase, whenever you type about him it makes me think i'm taking crazy pills or something
 
You must log in or register to reply here.
Back
Top