NOC Pokemon Mystery Dungeon Mafia - Explorers - Game Thread (Game Over!)

Voting out a low poster who we really really think is scum is fine but I’m not sure Laurel’s giving that for me anyway and I’m surprised he’s at that point for Tommy

But eh I’m also kinda not. Don’t think anything he’s done is really a townping yet, it’s all WIFOM at best lol
 
I have laurel scumplay as ultimate gimmick attempts in my head, last time I played with him as mafia he did some similar shit and i caught him I just can't remember which game it was so I can go reread
 
Duskfall98 said:
I'm a bit confused with this post, in the first paragraph you seem to be agreeing with celevers oligarchy or debate club w/e narrative

but in the second paragraph you seem to not really like how he's come up with the narrative? like are you on celevers side?

feels like you agree with celever while also saying he should be easy to bury so I don't get it
Click to expand...

i dont agree with celever's idea that mafia is currently manipulating the town, which is where celever's oligarchy differs from standard debate club. my scum thoughts on celever are due to the nature of how he is making his arguments.


HydrogenHydreigon said:
i dont quite understand this
Click to expand...
i got asked why i voted pulsar (a wagon i didnt like) rather than celever (one of my "if a good wagon forms" names) - to which my response was, i thought the wagon was forming due to oligarchy which i thought was a particularly bad wagon reason. turns out it was for other stuff maybe.
 
Duskfall98 said:
who else do you think is mafia again?
Click to expand...
i had genisu and af scumleaned but I'm torn on genisu, my latest scumlean on him was under false pretenses

I'm willing to listen to a good case on someone i'm null or maybe even town leaned on, not married to my reads at this point in the game

ur push on Laurel just seems heavily based on meta and that analysis has been made on not much content so I don't understand how I'm supposed to follow or consider it a good idea (especially because he's given out a vest), it seems more like a white whale of yours I guess

also if Laurel can give out more vests we should be telling him who to give them to and putting him on a leash because giving townreads items is generally good, if we vote him off we lost that opportunity
 
Shane the Shroomish said:
i had genisu and af scumleaned but I'm torn on genisu, my latest scumlean on him was under false pretenses

I'm willing to listen to a good case on someone i'm null or maybe even town leaned on, not married to my reads at this point in the game

ur push on Laurel just seems heavily based on meta and that analysis has been made on not much content so I don't understand how I'm supposed to follow or consider it a good idea (especially because he's given out a vest), it seems more like a white whale of yours I guess

also if Laurel can give out more vests we should be telling him who to give them to and putting him on a leash because giving townreads items is generally good, if we vote him off we lost that opportunity
Click to expand...

hmm ok thanks, my push on laurel is almost entirely meta though yeah

I was pretty happy genisu was town yesterday tbh wouldn't like to see him voted

a fairy seems to be generally getting consensused meh'ed atm as a possible vote
 
Shane the Shroomish said:
i had genisu and af scumleaned but I'm torn on genisu, my latest scumlean on him was under false pretenses

I'm willing to listen to a good case on someone i'm null or maybe even town leaned on, not married to my reads at this point in the game

ur push on Laurel just seems heavily based on meta and that analysis has been made on not much content so I don't understand how I'm supposed to follow or consider it a good idea (especially because he's given out a vest), it seems more like a white whale of yours I guess

also if Laurel can give out more vests we should be telling him who to give them to and putting him on a leash because giving townreads items is generally good, if we vote him off we lost that opportunity
Click to expand...
It sure seemed like you were married to your reads yesterday brother lmao
 
Duskfall98 said:
neon you spend so much time in thread, it would be helpful if you could just catch up and give some thoughts, you have a habit of just refreshing pages on smogon, I know this since you're nearly always the first person to reply to role pms etc in like 2 minutes every time

if you're going to be in thread here, you might as well read and try your best to give something right? you've played enough now to know how the game works, I know youre capable of it now youve seen how these things work

I promise you, if you engaged and tried give some content/real thoughts on the game, you will get so much more interactions and engagement with your posts, which I do believe(?) is what you're seeking

please don't reply to this, with a "I've no thoughts joke" we all want you to take the game seriously and try, so we can take you seriously

but that has to start with you taking yourself seriously, which you can do, so please give it a chance
Click to expand...
That will have to wait until I'm done with this appointment I'm in rn though because then I'll be able to take my meds
 
Duskfall98 said:
hmm ok thanks, my push on laurel is almost entirely meta though yeah

I was pretty happy genisu was town yesterday tbh wouldn't like to see him voted

a fairy seems to be generally getting consensused meh'ed atm as a possible vote
Click to expand...
I don’t think a fairy’s getting meh’d really, everyone seems somewhat game to vote her out but no action is happening (this game hasn’t had a lot of votes backing up words in general tbh)
 
Shane the Shroomish said:
I'm quite confident you're a wolf but I've been in this situation before where I'm feuding with someome many times, I don't know if my accuracy rate is greater than like 50% in these cases this early
Click to expand...

as someone who used to always thunderdome, if you know you're inclined to thunderdome you should take a step back and not thunderdome (I know it's very hard)
 
You must log in or register to reply here.
Back
Top