Superimp's Response
Sorry about the length of the post. I did not want to double post.
------
Here are my replies to
Furai,
shrang and
trickroom.
Replying to
Furai:
Hide
As of the moment, Substitute and Refresh are implemented into the AC of Offensive Pivot. Both the advantages and disadvantages of running such moves for Offensive Pivot will be mentioned (EX: Refresh against Gliscor, Offensive Pivot not reaching notable bulk benchmarks, loss of offensive coverage, etc.)
Genesect has been implemented into the Checks / Counters section. Thanks for the reminder Furai!
Concerning your points on the Support set, please check my comments in the next section.
For main EV spread concerns, please check my comments in the next, next section.
Your points on the Specially Defensive set are valid; they will be implemented into the SC.
Thanks for the input and feedback Furai!
Replying to
shrang:
Hide
I am quite aware of your opinion on the validity of the Stallbreaker / Defensive Calm Mind set as seen from your previous post(s). However, unless you manage to convince the rest of QC that Stallbreaker / Defensive Calm Mind belongs in AC, it will remain a set. Currently, you are the
only QC member who
really has a problem with the set. Please check the previous posts /
trickroom’s post / bulk benchmarks for some possible reasons on why you would run such a set if you are interested.
The aforementioned also applies to the Dual Screens set to some extent. Please take a look at some previously stated opinions:
barry4ever said:I'd much rather say merge the Dual Screens Set and Wish set into a single Support set, I'm not seeing what the dual screen set is achieving over other screeners like Latios.
Poppy said:i think dual screens is pretty shit too, latias has better things to do (soul dew stuff)
trickroom said:Sure Latias can do dual screens but she is better off doing something nothing else can do. Latios is usually better with Dual Screens because Memento eases Baton Pass chains.
Furai said:I agree with everything trickroom has said, you would not want to sacrifice Latias and keep switching around when you can actually do some damage.
trickroom said:Dual Screens is optional to me. It isn't really good but it does have some useful advantages over Cresselia.
Mr.lol said:It sadly can't do that unless its running Dual Screens, and it actually is a bit inferior to Latios at that role due to memento
Right now, it seems that
everyone besides you either does not like the set, they are on the fence, or they tell me that it is optional. Unless you manage to convince the rest of QC that the Dual Screens set should be mentioned as a set, it is likely that it will remain in OO.
--------
Concerning your other points
shrang, the Stallbreaker / Defensive Calm Mind set might benefit from a name change. As I previously told
firecape, the name is currently a placeholder until something more appropriate is found. In light of the points made by both you and
trickroom, perhaps "Defensive Calm Mind" was the better name after all. There is even some precedent for it as seen with Arceus-Water’s analysis.
As a note on CM Arceus-Dragon, while it is true that Arceus-Dragon has much better Physical Defense, Speed, and less weaknesses, Latias has some noticeable advantages such as Levitate, Soul Dew, ability to deal with Kyogre, other CM Arceus, etc., and much more. These advantages are just something to keep in mind.
Concerning the Support and Specially Defensive sets, please check my comments in the next section.
Thanks for your feedback and input
shrang.
Replying to
trickroom:
Hide
Your All-Out Attacker set suggestion has been accepted. The set seemed to work quite nicely in testing, and it appeals to those who want their Latias to be a hit-and-run attacker along with some fantastic special bulk. It is now the third set.
I see you noticed my Lucario mention trickroom. It was actually meant to be an interesting fact, as I found it a bit amusing on how 168 SpA EVs allows Draco Meteor to 2HKO Lucario. This is why I mentioned “coincidentally”. But rest assured that in the actual analysis, Lucario will not be mentioned.
You points on why it is not recommended for All-Out Attacker to run maximum SpA EVs are definitely valid. I agree with you - this is why the set does not actually run maximum SpA EVs.
Concerning main EV spread suggestions, please check my comments in the next, next section.
Regarding your points on the Support and Specially Defensive sets, please check my comments in the next section.
Concerning names, the Stallbreaker / Defensive Calm Mind set might benefit from a name change. As I previously told firecape and shrang, the name is just a placeholder until something more appropriate is found. In light of the points made by both you and shrang, perhaps “Defensive Calm Mind” was the better name after all. There is even some precedent for it as seen with Arceus-Water's analysis.
Thanks for all the feedback and input trickroom. I really appreciate the All-Out Attacker set suggestion too. It's a nice set – credits go to both you for the actual set and Colonel M for the inspiration!
------------------------------------------------
For those who wonder why the Support set was even considered, realize that it was an attempt to legitimize a possible blend between the Wish and Dual Screens set, both of which have not received enough positive QC feedback to justify their existence as a standalone set.
barry4ever said:I'd much rather say merge the Dual Screens Set and Wish set into a single Support set, I'm not seeing what the dual screen set is achieving over other screeners like Latios.
With the suggestion of
barry4ever in mind, I have tried to create a possible, viable Support set. Perhaps I have not put enough effort into crafting such a set. Nevertheless, my attempts have ultimately resulted in failure. As
Furai,
shrang,
trickroom, and many others have pointed out, there seem to be too many problems with the Support set as it so stands. Members have noted that her Wishes are too small, that sacrificing her with Healing Wish is generally not worth it, that she is not using her offenses effectively, that she is unable to even
Light Screen on Kyogre’s Modest Choice Specs Ice Beam after SR guaranteed, and much more. I myself through my own testing have found her performance to be overall underwhelming – I imagine she simply tries to be too many things at once, doing everything a bit ineffectively. It should come as no surprise that I'm currently leaning towards placing the Support set in OO where the Wish and Dual Screens set currently reside.
Concerning Specially Defensive Latias, this set is an attempt to broaden her options to appeal to as many Latias users as possible. Perhaps you might say this set challenges the paradigm that Latias should be "constrained" to the roles of offensive pivot, CM sweeping, or all-out attacking. That Latias has little need to run bulk. The truth is, there are so many differing opinions on what makes Latias Latias. Maybe you are someone like
shrang, passionate supporter of the Offensive Pivot (and Dual Screens). Perhaps you are someone who really likes the Stallbreaker / Defensive Calm Mind like
Manaphy. Maybe you are like
trickroom,
Hugendugen, or
Poppy and don't mind using All-Out Attacker. Or maybe you just have completely different opinions on what the EV spreads should be like. Simply put, Latias has a different "flavor" for everybody. But doesn't this apply to Specially Defensive as well? When one can clearly see that some people might actually gravitate towards such a set according to Moveset analysis?
Throughout my testing, Specially Defensive Latias seemed to show more promise than the Support, Wish, or Dual Screens set. I'm probably not the most experienced user of a Specially Defensive Latias; I tend to use the Defensive Calm Mind and
Offensive Pivot All-Out Attacker sets as I personally find them to be overall more useful for Latias. I'm not going to force down these opinions on everyone though, as I imagine many people see this as plain rude. However, based on my experience of actually
using a Specially Defensive Latias, I can honestly tell you that the feats she can do are simply unrivaled. This set takes full advantage of the Soul Dew boost to perform tasks that are impossible for an offensively inclined Latias, or for that matter any Pokemon, to accomplish.
Please check this link to see some notable excerpts of actual testing (Besides the first log… I couldn't find anyone who spammed unboosted Ice Beam / Psystrikes after SR). These logs range from being possibly boring to outright insane. It is important to note that Latias can possibly do all these roles at the same time, even if you stack her field with every single entry hazard imaginable.
Specially Defensive Latias has titanic special bulk. She may not have the special bulk that Blissey, Chansey, or Multiscale Lugia can boast. But it is still respectable – this set has around 6.8% more special bulk than Specially Defensive Giratina while not even running maximum SpD investment (Not counting Leftovers). Combined with her resistances, this "thing" takes special hits very well.
No other Latias set comes even close to how well this set deals with Choiced Kyogre. Moreover, Specially Defensive Latias counters
ANY standard Kyogre variant (Including Thunder Wave; its Ice Beam is far too weak to overcome her defense). Although it is definitely true that CM Kyogre sets can be an issue when they are the last Pokemon, this set easily phazes them if they are not, can set up Light Screen to allow other teammates to deal with them more effectively, or simply get in first and spam Roar to rack up entry hazard damage. This set also remains reasonably fast – she still has enough Speed to outspeed any non-Choice Scarf neutral Base 90 or 95 Speed Pokemon depending on her EV spread.
There is one major problem with Specially Defensive Latias - her overall lack of offensive power. Even though an unboosted Dragon Pulse is not exactly weak, it is not exactly strong either. This means that Specially Defensive Latias can be detrimental to momentum if not used properly, while her offensive pressure is not exactly the best. Still, Latias has Light Screen and Roar. Oh, and anyone who dares to switch in a special response may be in for a rude awakening.
As the writer of this analysis, it is my intention to be as open-minded about all viable aspects of Latias as possible. If people happen to have a demand for a certain, viable aspect of Latias, then I imagine there is little reason for me to not test it. This can be seen when I tested the All-Out Attacker for
trickroom (Accepted), or Reflect Type for
Mr.lol indirectly (Sorry
Mr.lol, I think that's AC for Defensive CM). This is the fundamental reason on why I'm really testing a Specially Defensive Latias - people seem to be using it, so I'm trying to find a possible, viable set for these people. All I'm really doing as the writer of this analysis is giving a bit of a "nudge"; the Smogon community will ultimately decide which sets will show up in the analysis.
Overall, I have found the Specially Defensive set to be
reasonably useful through actual testing. In fact, I imagine this set might just have a place as an official set, giving a nice four set symmetry with the analysis of Latios for aesthetics (Brother/Sister theme). However, if you guys overall find the Specially Defensive set to "suck" after some of your own testing, then it will obviously be removed. In essence, I have the willingness to adapt your ideas to benefit the community as a whole, and will use this in combination with my own Uber metagame knowledge and testing to ensure that when the analysis is finally finished, it will be of the quality that Smogon is known for.
---------------------------------------------------
It is from the continuation of this train of thought that perhaps the time has finally arrived to determine the ideal main EV spread for each set once and for all.
Here is a list of notable Kyogre bulk benchmarks that Latias can strive for:
[box]
- 40 HP EVs Timid = Choice Specs Timid Ice Beam with SR is unable to 2HKO after a Reflect Type
- 80 HP EVs Timid = Choice Scarf Modest Ice Beam is a guaranteed 3HKO [No SR]
- Choice Specs Timid Water Spout (full power & rain) can never 2HKO after a Calm Mind [No SR]
- 88 HP EVs Timid = Choice Scarf Modest (full power & rain) Water Spout is a guaranteed 3HKO after SR
- 132 HP EVs Timid = Choice Scarf Timid Ice Beam is a guaranteed 3HKO after SR
- 168 HP EVs Timid = Choice Specs Modest Ice Beam with SR is unable to 2HKO after a Reflect Type
- 204 HP EVs Timid = Choice Specs Modest (full power & rain) Water Spout can never 2HKO after a Calm Mind [No SR]
- 236 HP EVs Timid = Choice Specs Modest Ice Beam is unable to 2HKO through Light Screen [No SR]
- 252 HP EVs Timid = Choice Scarf Modest Ice Beam is essentially a guaranteed 3HKO after SR.
- Choice Specs Timid Ice Beam can never 2HKO after a Calm Mind [No SR]
- 252 HP EVs & 12 SpD EVs Timid = Choice Specs Timid Water Spout (full power & rain) with SR can never 2HKO after a Calm Mind
- 252 HP EVs & 16 SpD EVs Timid = Choice Scarf Modest Ice Beam is a guaranteed 3HKO after SR.
- 252 HP EVs Calm = Choice Specs Modest Ice Beam can never 2HKO after a Calm Mind [No SR]
- 252 HP EVs & 16 SpD EVs Calm = Choice Specs Modest (full power & rain) Water Spout with SR can never 2HKO after a Calm Mind
- 252 HP EVs & 32 SpD EVs Calm = Choice Specs Modest Ice Beam with SR is unable to 2HKO through Light Screen
- 252 HP EVs & 52 SpD EVs Calm = Choice Specs Timid Ice Beam with SR can never 2HKO after a Calm Mind
[/box]
Here is my current slate for possible main EV spreads:
[SCROLL=20]
CURRENT SLATE FOR MAIN EV SPREAD OF OFFENSIVE PIVOT:
- 48 HP / 208 SpA / 252 Spe Timid
- 252 Spe = Speed tie other Speed boosting Base 110 Speed Pokemon
- 208 SpA = Dragon Pulse without SR OHKOes standard Palkia guaranteed + maximizes Soul Dew boost (Which now guarantees against 4 SpD Palkia)
- 48 HP = Remaining EVs go into bulk - doesn’t reach any notable benchmarks
- 60 HP / 208 SpA / 240 Spe Timid
- 240 Spe = Outspeed non-Choice Scarf Jolly Terrakion
- 208 SpA = Dragon Pulse without SR OHKOes standard Palkia guaranteed + maximizes Soul Dew boost (Which now guarantees against 4 SpD Palkia)
- 60 HP = Remaining EVs go into bulk - doesn’t reach any notable benchmarks
- 100 HP / 216 SpA / 192 Spe Timid
- 192 Spe = Outspeed non-Choice Scarf Jolly Garchomp
- 216 SpA = Dragon Pulse without SR OHKOes standard (and others) Palkia guaranteed + maximizes Soul Dew boost
- 100 HP = Remaining EVs go into bulk - benchmarks up to 88 HP EVs reached - ensures that SR damage is at a minimum like the other EV spreads
CURRENT SLATE FOR MAIN EV SPREAD OF DEFENSIVE CALM MIND:
- 252 HP / 4 Def / 252 Spe Timid
- 252 Spe = Speed tie other Speed boosting Base 110 Speed Pokemon
- 252 HP = Greatest amount of overall bulk with greatest possible Speed - benchmarks up to 252 HP EVs reached
- 4 Def = Remaining EVs go into Defense
- 216 HP / 40 SpA / 252 Spe Timid
- 252 Spe = Speed tie other Speed boosting Base 110 Speed Pokemon
- 40 SpA = Dragon Pulse with SR OHKOes standard Palkia guaranteed + maximizes Soul Dew boost
- 216 HP = Remaining EVs go into bulk - benchmarks up to 204 HP EVs reached
- 252 HP / 40 SpA / 24 SpD / 192 Spe Timid
- 192 Spe = Outspeed non-Choice Scarf Jolly Garchomp
- 40 SpA = Dragon Pulse with SR OHKOes standard Palkia guaranteed + maximizes Soul Dew boost
- 252 HP & 24 SpD = Remaining EVs go into bulk - benchmarks up to 252 HP EVs & 16 SpD EVs reached
CURRENT SLATE FOR MAIN EV SPREAD OF ALL-OUT ATTACKER:
- 88 HP / 168 SpA / 252 Spe Timid
- 252 Spe = Speed tie other Speed boosting Base 110 Speed Pokemon
- 88 HP = Bulk benchmarks up to 88 HP EVs reached
- 168 SpA = Remaining EVs go into SpA to boost overall damage - Draco Meteor easily 2HKOes Specially Defensive Giratina without SR
- 100 HP / 164 SpA / 244 Spe Timid
- 252 Spe = Outspeed positive base 108 Speed Pokemon like Garchomp
- 164 SpA = Draco Meteor without SR 2HKOes Specially Defensive Giratina guaranteed, Grass Knot with 1 layer of Spikes OHKOes 252 HP Groudon guaranteed after -1 SpA IV drop, and maximizes Soul Dew boost
- 164 HP = Remaining EVs go into bulk - bulk benchmarks up to 132 HP EVs reached - minimizes SR damage like the other EV spreads
- 164 HP / 152 SpA / 192 Spe Timid
- 192 Spe = Outspeed non-Choice Scarf Jolly Garchomp
- 152 SpA = Draco Meteor without SR 2HKOes Specially Defensive Giratina guaranteed, will always break Gliscor's Substitute at -6, and maximizes Soul Dew boost
- 164 HP = Remaining EVs go into bulk - bulk benchmarks up to 132 HP EVs reached - minimizes SR damage like the other EV spreads
- 164 HP / 148 SpA / 196 Spe Timid
- 196 Spe = Outspeed non-Choice Scarf Jolly Garchomp after -1 Spe IV drop
- 148 SpA = Draco Meteor without SR 2HKOes Specially Defensive Giratina guaranteed after -1 SpA IV drop, and maximizes Soul Dew boost
- 164 HP = Remaining EVs go into bulk - bulk benchmarks up to 132 HP EVs reached - minimizes SR damage like the other EV spreads
- 148 HP / 164 SpA / 196 Spe Timid
- 196 Spe = Outspeed non-Choice Scarf Jolly Garchomp after -1 Spe IV drop
- 164 SpA = Draco Meteor without SR 2HKOes Specially Defensive Giratina guaranteed, Grass Knot with 1 layer of Spikes OHKOes 252 HP Groudon guaranteed after -1 SpA IV drop, and maximizes Soul Dew boost
- 148 HP = Remaining EVs go into bulk - bulk benchmarks up to 132 HP EVs reached - minimizes SR damage like the other EV spreads
CURRENT SLATE FOR MAIN EV SPREAD OF SPECIALLY DEFENSIVE:
- 252 HP / 12 Def / 148 SpD / 96 Spe Calm - Bulk Focus - Takes hits more effectively than the other EV spreads
- 252 HP / 24 SpA / 136 SpD / 96 Spe Calm - Special Attack Focus - Can now OHKO Rayquaza guaranteed without SR
- 252 HP / 120 SpD / 136 Spe Calm - Speed Focus - Can now outspeed non-Choice Scarf neutral Base 95 Speed Pokemon. Despite the loss in bulk, she can still take on Mewtwo, super effective CM Arceus, etc. without SR; more risky if you take them on with SR on her field.
[/SCROLL]
It would be really appreciated if you guys voiced your opinions on which options from the slate work best for each set. Feel free to justify your choice or possibly provide new viable EV spreads to go on the slate. Hopefully the benchmarks I provided should aid with your decision.
All your posts will be used to eventually decide the main EV spreads for each set. Just mention the set, the slate options you think fit best, possible justification, and then post/PM/VM/whatever! Even if your desired option from the slate is not chosen, it is very likely that it will show up in AC in some form or the other.
Everyone's input is welcomed! Choose the options that
you feel are most optimal for Latias's performance, that
you have found to work most effectively.
EDIT:
Regarding EV Spreads, I have received input from four members currently.
Current Opinions
Furai - NOTE: QC
- Offensive Pivot = 1.
- Defensive Calm Mind = 2.
- All-Out Attacker = 4.
- Specially Defensive = 3.
Poppy - NOTE: QC
- Offensive Pivot = 3.
- Defensive Calm Mind = 1.
- All-Out Attacker = 3. NOTE: Has not commented on 4. or 5.
- Specially Defensive = 3.
trickroom - NOTE: QC
- Offensive Pivot = 1.
- Defensive Calm Mind = No Comment Yet (Assumed 2.)
- All-Out Attacker = 4. (Assumed based on Post #30)
- Specially Defensive = No Comment Yet
Superimp - NOTE: Self-explanatory
- Offensive Pivot = 1.
- Defensive Calm Mind = 1.
- All-Out Attacker = 4.
- Specially Defensive = 1. or 3. -> Interchangeable, but 3. preferred
Regarding Set Order, I have received input from six members currently.
Current Opinions
Poppy - NOTE: QC
- All-Out Attacker
- Specially Defensive
- Defensive Calm Mind
- Offensive Pivot
Mr.lol - NOTE: Has tested all four sets personally.
- Specially Defensive
- Defensive Calm Mind
- All-Out Attacker
- Offensive Pivot
Furai - NOTE: QC
- All-Out Attacker
- Offensive Pivot
- Defensive Calm Mind
- Specially Defensive
shrang - NOTE: QC
- CM Latias
- All-Out Attacker
- Specially Defensive
trickroom - NOTE: QC
- CM Latias -> Interchangeable as 1 or 2
- All-Out Attacker -> Interchangeable as 1 or 2
- Specially Defensive
Superimp - NOTE: Self-explanatory
- All-Out Attacker
- Defensive Calm Mind
- Specially Defensive
- Offensive Pivot
SCORE: All-Out Attacker wins based on IRV method. Defensive Calm Mind is second place. Specially Defensive is third place. Offensive Pivot is last place.