A to A-/B+
A- to A
~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~
yes i will start this out with many nominations
rises:
View attachment 150625-> A- (bottom)
This is one of the changes that I honestly don't understand. Rotom has been arguably the most consistent form of hazard removal (read: best thing other than Xatu at preventing hazards) for quite some time now, and dropping it from A(?) makes pretty little sense to me tbh. Nothing in the metagame has really changed at all for it, and I'd argue that Sneasel's slow decline, which has allowed Rotom to run Iapapa Berry, has benefited it greatly. Sure, the rise in Vileplume has hurt it in the 1v1, but you Volt Switch on that, and Vileplume is not preventing a Defog.
View attachment 150626-> A- (somewhere idrk where lol)
WishTect Delphox has seen quite a surge in usage recently, and I think what it does is being underrated. Having one Pokemon capable of checking as many wallbreakers as it does is fantastic. It's also really great for balanced teams that choose to run with Seismitoad as their fat Water-type of choice, seeing as how you aren't pairing Toad with Vaporeon, and Delphox provides them with sustain via Wish. It also stops the broken Comfey, so bop.
drops:
View attachment 150631-> B or B- (somewhere)
I'm gonna just echo sentiments I had from the previous VR: I think Mega Christmas is really bad and fits on like one team archetype (vapo balance). It faces immense competition from Vani, Alolan Neck, and Sceptile as an Ice- or Grass-type wallbreaker, and it struggles to come in versus much of anything (things like Rotom and Heliolisk that you would think it would come in on just pivot on you with Volt Switch lmao) due to its really terrible defensive typing (which also shits on it due to hazards). Overall underwhelming and faces waaaay too many drawbacks to be considered much of a real pick.
View attachment 150630-> C+ (below Samurott)
This is an entry hazard setter that loses to Xatu, and it's a Steel-type that loses to Comfey. I frankly have never seen the appeal to Ferroseed other than it checking Heliolisk (which is clicking Volt most of the time anyhow) and being decent against some hazard removal, but it's a huge momentum drain and passive as hell.
View attachment 150629-> UR
ngl I think this guy is terrible and fits on very, very select builds. Trapping Steelix for Comfey is really nice, although that's about all it does in the current metagame. Steelvally can just pivot out with Parting Shot or U-turn, and Ferroseed is not exactly a Pokemon lol. I could see it just dropping to lower C, but it's honestly not great, and its niche is even more worthless with the huge drop off Torterra has undergone.[/QUOTE]
Rabia did also a pretty good job redacting this ones, and i think that all this should get moved too so ya.
~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~
Initial thoughts/nominations:
could move up to B.
While it still is underwhelming relative to where the initial hype wave put it in theory, Aerodactyl has a pretty developed place in the metagame now. The Choice Band set is annoying to switch-in to for a lot of teams and the Z set can even pick up a kill in a lot of scenarios. This in conjunction with a nearly unmatched speed tier (fuck you, Accelgor) and access to Pursuit, which has limited distribution in the current metagame, makes Aerodactyl a very viable option for a number of teams currently.
could move down to B.
The snowman is unfortunately very underwhelming in my experience. It is very hard to use on teams, let alone get to function consistently. It will see more usage than it deserves on the merit of it being a flashy pick that often forces people's hands defensively, but the burden it places upon teambuilding causes a certain degree of inherent inconsistency that strikes me as incredibly unappealing.
could move down to A-.
On the fence more about this one than the two above, but honestly Seismitoad just is not as good as it was during its initial NU stint and it really shows. The Toxic Refresh bullshit can be annoying, it has a solid defensive presence, and it can up sorta ok, but a lot of things take advantage of it currently. A big one is Alolan Exeggutor, but even the aforementioned Mega Abomasnow tears it a new one. And don't even get me started on how weak Scald is against things like Xatu when you just want to fucking set up Stealth Rock before the world comes to an end. All things considered, I am just not too high on Seismitoad in general atm, but perhaps there is a bit more for me to individually explore on this front.
Love this VR reboot overall!