• Check out the relaunch of our general collection, with classic designs and new ones by our very own Pissog!

NOC Amnesiac Mafia Game 1 - N2

Status
Not open for further replies.
Omni has to be either rssp or aska iirc, I worked it out earlier but didn't share it because I didn't want the godfather to have that info - except I forgot he already knows anyways lol
 
It's still entirely possible rssp is just opportunistic scum claiming n0 hooked to off Blazade but someone else would have to emerge as having been hooked

Or the hook would have had to be omniblocked a guess
 
Blazade and I can't be omni because rssp was silenced; Sam and ditto can't be omni because yeti was silenced; pluff can't be omni because her action failed whereas don was blocked by omni; yeti/Flyhn are 99% chance of watcher/pt and so aren't omni

The omni wouldn't lie about who he targeted so I think this holds up
 
the only possible holes are rssp or yeti faking silence (brining me/Blazade or Sam/ditto back into the mix) OR Flyhn having lied about who he targeted (which would bring yeti back into omni consideration)
 
How would rssp1 faking silence make Sam or myself the Silencer? jumpluff posted several times during D1, ironically calling saying she thought I was the Silencer. For Sam, Blazade posted as well. I mean, I guess it's possible if rssp1 was instead hooker. In this situation Sam/myself and rssp1 somehow psychically linked to plan our hook and silence claims.

I think most of the rabbit hole logic that Blazade and Walrein are trying to use is too convoluted. The only thing that keeps me from fully thinking Walrein is silencer is the fact that by the time he posted his targets, he would've been pretty sure that he was the Silencer because it was narrowed down to Yeti being silenced today. I guess he could have been banking on Blazade taking the fall, but I don't know.
 
I asked a lot of host questions in my PMs before the game started. Keep pressing for confirmation, you'll get the same answer. I just wanted to save some time.

It's not convoluted when the real silencer is almost certainly lying about targets and when the don is certainly lying about N1 and if I'm not the hooker they're lying too. I'm bringing up possibilites not pushing lynches.

We should do psych claims. Who know their role pm through a result?
 
You are saying that rssp1 knew he was silencer and faked being silenced, meaning he got a failed action and immediately assumed he was silencer or that he was revealed via psychiatrist. In case of the failed action, that would point to you or Walrein being the hooker then. More than likely you because of your N1 target.
 
Walrein said:
Omni has to be either rssp or aska iirc, I worked it out earlier but didn't share it because I didn't want the godfather to have that info - except I forgot he already knows anyways lol
Click to expand...
I think I can only be omniguard if jumpluff is don. Otherwise the kill would have gone through, since I idled.
 
askaninjask said:
I think I can only be omniguard if jumpluff is don. Otherwise the kill would have gone through, since I idled.
Click to expand...
correct

Since I'm not it has to be rssp1 unless what Walrein said

The only potential lie I see there of the ones he listed is rssp1 faking, in which case then it's Blazade since Walrein idled

A day extension would be rad btw
 
It really just comes down to rssp vs. Blazade today though. rssp looking like he's framing Blaxade but I'd have to reread

I'd like to do a mayor test but that could be dangerous.
 
Ditto's misinterpreting my post. I'm saying yeti faking silence would make you potential omni guard. The post had nothing to do with trying to ascertain who the silencer is
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top