Shadow Claw Vs Shadow Force, 1 on 1.
Seems a bit long-winded for this thread but I've been asked to put it here so here goes...
Shadow Claw Vs Shadow Force, 1 on 1?
A lot of you are probably already saying Shadow Claw with regards to an Extreme Killer Arceus but I personally like to keep a set for pure 1 on 1 ownage. Yes, I know it's not the most practical thing but I find it fun. Anyways, when switching out isn't possible, the gap between the two moves is a lot smaller.
So, let's assume it's 1 on 1 and you're using an Extreme Killer, which move would you choose?
It seems to me that in this 1 on 1 situation Shadow Force would guarantee you the win against a Physical Ghost Arceus (which is otherwise pretty much luck of the draw correct?). It would 2 hit KO it, making its speed advantage pointless. However Shadow Claw still guarantees a 3 hit KO and the Ghost Arceus isn't guaranteed to take you out with 3 Brick Breaks. When you factor in Shadow Claw's higher critical chance it seems like it'd be almost as good a choice as Shadow Force would overall.
If you're unlucky enough to come up against a Lugia you could Swords Dance and then smash it with a Shadow Force, pretty much guaranteeing a 1 hit KO (98.something%?) but, alternatively, Swords Dance Shadow Claws would force it into repeated Roosts until it ran out of PP or take it in 2. That's not even taking into account the chance of Crit-ing it before Roost runs out. Both moves equal here for a 1 on 1?
Finally, Giratina. Here you're pretty much ****ed without criticals right? Even a Swords Danced Shadow Force would be walled by Rest and that's not even taking into account Will-O-Wisp. However I'm thinking that Shadow Claw is probably the best bet as you'd get more attempts at that crit.
I'm mainly looking for some confirmation on these calculations and I know there's loads of people out there who know tons more than I do about this stuff so you can probably correct me on some things. Oh and it doesn't need to be limited to these 3 Pokemon, I was just using them as examples of some of the biggest problems you'd encounter.
So yeah, like I said before, you're not gonna get into 1 on 1 matches very often but I'd still appreciate some help in working this one out :P