prem said:also setting up screens isnt very difficult in this meta, its just not used because no one tries to really.
I actually felt I should explain this more thoroughly. Halving damage when it comes to Berry Juice is completely different than Eviolite because Eviolite basically has that effect where as Berry Juice essentially boosts your offensive Pokemon's HP by double. The 2x bulk boost compared to the 1.5x bulk boost actually scales further with Berry Juice when you consider that, and not to mention it basically makes you completely unable to avoid Berry Juice threw means of alternating attacks or OHKOes.
Ray Jay said:I think the big thing is that offensive Pokemon with Berry Juice become imbalanced (slightly better, if you will) but not broken. I played a game a while back using Berry Juice on my hazards Dwebble, and it got what, one more layer of hazards up than normal? This was neutered by the fact that everyone *had* to run Staryu in order to get their Sturdy sweeper safely in and blah blah blah.
I guess you weren't directly replying to me but Dwebble's additional ability to Spike is not really a a huge concern....it does this pretty well with Oran Berry and one layer of Spikes doesn't cause you to lose the game like 3-4 Dragon Dance boosts...
Ray Jay said:Heysup's point about 2HKOs becoming 3 or even 4HKOs applies, but it also applies to Eviolite. There are more than a few would-be 2HKOs (especially in the case of mons with super offensive stats, such as Ponyta) that become 3HKOs or 4HKOs when the opposition has Eviolite. Does that mean Eviolite is broken? No, it just means Eviolite lessens the foe's offensive presence. Berry Juice is basically a counterpart to Eviolite; instead of lessening the foe's offensive presence, it helps the user's HP presence. To put it simply, an attack hits for the same damage whether the target has Berry Juice or not. However, provided the attack does not OHKO, the target can take more of these attacks with Berry Juice. Eviolite's useful in that it can prevent certain OHKOs.
When you compare the two like this, how can you not see the inherent threat of Berry Juice? What you're basically saying is: Eviolite is more useful in certain situations on more defensive Pokemon. However, you need to keep in mind that defensive Pokemon were not ever the reason for banning Berry Juice. The fact of the matter is that Eviolite helps set up sweepers a little bit but it only boosts their bulk by a very small number, sometimes not even mattering at all in the scheme of things. However Berry Juice basically doubles almost every set up sweeper's bulk. It makes Eviolite look like absolute trash and outclasses it in so many ways. For example, even with Eviolite Bagon is 2HKOed by Hidden Power Ice from Bronzor, but it's 3HKOed by the berry Juice variant. The difference between +2 and +3 is actually the difference between likely OHKOing and not possibly OHKOing. It adds more bulk to frailer Pokemon than Eviolite and that's why it's too much, why one is clearly broken one isn't.
Ray Jay said:The question here is not if Berry Juice is broken, by itself, arguing Berry Juice is broken is like arguing Eviolite is broken because it makes Scraggy too much of a threat.
It's fairly obvious that your analogy falls flat as soon as you introduce more than one Pokemon into that scenario. It would be like arguing Eviolite is broken only if Eviolite broken a whole slew of Pokemon.....which it doesn't.
Ray Jay said:The question is what does Berry Juice break? In my personal experience, I think Heysup's numbers apparently argue that Berry Juice breaks offensive Pokemon, especially those with a set up move that have enough bulk to take an attack, and even more the Sturdy Smashers. In my experience, most offensive Pokemon apart from the Shell Smashers are not broken after one turn of set up. For example, Scraggy after one turn of set up is honestly not that scary; it would always still use Eviolite. Misdreavus after one turn of set up is only scary if it is running Life Orb, so Berry Juice is a null argument here. The Shell Smashers (really, the only ones I'm considering are Tirtouga, Dwebble, and Omanyte; Clamperl needs either DST or Eviolite based on the team) are really kinda odd. The first two, Tirtouga and Dwebble have special note due to sturdy. Basically, you have to be careful because if you take out an opponent's Pokemon with something Tirtouga or Dwebble sets up on, you now have to do some gymnastics to get around the opponent getting a guaranteed 2 Shell Smashes. Omanyte's worth a mention since it actually beats a lot of Tirtouga's typical counters (Ferroseed and Lileep come to mind, as both can be "handled" with Ice Beam) and is bulky enough to take a hit.
So, it comes down to what's more preferable. Is the more preferable meta one that has no Berry Juice, but nerfed Shell Smashers (the current meta)? Or is the preferable meta the one that has Berry Juice, but banned Shell Smashers? That's right, I think the initial discussion should not emphasize Berry Juice as a whole; Berry Juice is not a "broken" item in and of itself, it depends on what you do with it.
The scary part (and the reason why I'm not even focusing on Shell Smashers, is that you can get
more than one boost very very easily. While I disagree with you immensely about Missy, I'm going to ignore that and look at the bigger picture. You absolutely need to ban the broken item even though it's an item. If the item breaks a large number of Pokemon then obviously the item is the culprit. You can look at it in a more complicated light if you want, for example banning Berry Juice + set up sweepers but I think we can agree that would be messy. It makes much more sense to just straight up ban the thing that's causing so many Pokemon to be broken.
I guess the main difference between what we're saying is that you only think Shell Smashers with Sturdy are broken. If that was the case I'd agree with you, but I can tell you almost certainly that it isn't.