All the books in this post can fit somewhere under the heading of lgbtq ocean horror lit. It just happened that way, I don't plan it.
Our Wives Under the Sea by Julia Armfield was released in America as I was getting around to long-time fixtures on my to read list Melissa Broder's
The Pisces and Rivers Solomon's
The Deep.
The Deep by Rivers Solomon-
The premise of
The Deep is that pregnant slaves thrown overboard during the Transatlantic Slave Trade survived as mer-people and establish a civilization under the sea, called the Wajinru. Wajinru society has a
The Giver-type political structure where one person is charged with remembering and containing the whole history of the Wajinru. This person, called the Historian, is the protagonist of the novel. This role comes with a cost, the Historian is isolated with the pain and literal weight of the memories of every single Wajinru both alive and from the past. This often makes her physically ill and renders her weak, as the mind is a powerful organ and exerts profound somatic effects on our physiology.
Every few decades, however, the Historian gathers all of the Wajinru and guides them through remembering their history, allowing themselves to temporarily (a few days maybe) let go of the memories and remind the rest of the Wajinru of their histories and identities, after which they will forget again and the memories are returned to their vessel, the Historian.
It all becomes too much for the Historian, and at the outset of the novel she is sure that the process of guiding the Wajinru through the memories, letting them go, and then taking the memories back will kill her. And so she flees. And that's the set-up, which I found to be quite captivating, it really motivated me to read the novel.
Perhaps some readers w a mainstream politics (this book is published by NPR lol btw) will just blast through this book and pat themselves on the back or w.e, but I have to say the strong exposition lead to a somewhat muddled message and plot arc:
First, a big part of the novel involves the Historian healing and regaining her strength while living as a captive...which is a bit dissonant with the claim this novel makes to be able to speak about or make comments on the experiences of the ancestors of slaves. IMO.
Second, the Historian has a human love interest who turns out to be the last descendent of the society from which the very first pregnant slave to birth Wajinru was from. The revelation of the historical connection is written as cathartic or as being somehow transformative, but I see sort of narrative as somewhat in need of interrogation. To me, an anti-Zionist Jew, this idea that you belong somewhere or with someone because of something that happened 100s of years ago appears slightly too similar to a Zionist saying I should live in Israel or feel some connection and/or entitlement to it because some Jewish people lived there 2000 yrs ago. Now, this book is of course a different context, and it is an interesting question drawn out by the novel, but it for me it comes w some alarm bells. And when I discussed this w a Palestinian friend of mine they also pointed this out, so I don't think this is just me being overly harsh.
The Pisces by Melissa Broder- I love Melissa Broder so much, I just have to say.
The Pisces tells the story of an aspiring literature grad student who just can't fill the void inside her. At the outset, her academic career is falling apart as is her romantic relationship w another academic. She flees from Arizona to Venice Beach (
Barbie movie enjoyers, that Venice Beach) to dog sit for her sister. While living in Venice, she meets and falls in love w a merman who swims near the shore at night.
The novel explores the seemingly insatiable craving some of us experience to be loved and the desperate things such people do to find it. The story is told w Broder's typical incredible sense of humor and trademark Melville-ian descriptions of moods/affects. I also LOVED that one of the main devices is a therapeutic processing group for women that the protagonist attends, it really worked for me, made me relate to the main character, and also was just so hilarious in a super realistic way. If you have some reservations about finding love, connection, and meaning in contemporary life, I think
The Pisces will be a really fun read for you.
Our Wives Under the Sea by Julia Armfield- This novel relates a story about a woman who's wife goes on an expedition to the bottom of the sea. Something goes wrong and the expedition returns much later than expected, and Leah, the protagonist's wife, returns changed and 'wrong'. Interestingly, it came out in America right as that billionaire's submarine implosion was in the news cycle. The novel mainly focuses on the love and loss experienced by the protagonist as she finds she cannot relate to her changed wife. Many passages invoke her memories of courtship and the time before she returned from the bottom of the sea. Fundamentally, this novel is not a story about overcoming something, so much as it is about letting go of something. As one review I read points out, a central question of the novel is what happens when one person in a relationship is fundamentally a different person now than the one they were when the 2 fell in love: the Ship of Theseus of romantic attachment...
Armfield's writing captures the pain and sense of foreboding Leah's wife experiences and successfully evokes feelings of unease, suspense, body horror, anxiety, all that fun horror genre stuff. It's really quite masterfully plodded considering there is almost no actual 'events' in the novel. Very little really happens or gets explained, and not to spoil it, but there is no closure in the ending either. Nonetheless, I was pretty enthralled the whole time, the mystery really build and builds drawing you into it, but then leaves the reader to sit with the protagonist's feelings rather than tie everything off neatly. I will definitely re-read or return at some point, but I wouldn't recommend it if you're not a fan of ambiguous endings.
I will be back soon w at least book one of NK Jemisin's
The Fifth Season trilogy, and possibly all of it. I am hoping to finish book one within the next day and I will probably complete the trilogy before moving down on my list.