-
The moderators of this forum are the Pokémon Showdown! Administrators.
-
Welcome to Smogon! Take a moment to read the Introduction to Smogon for a run-down on everything Smogon, and make sure you take some time to read the global rules.
-
Congrats to the winners of the 2024 Smog Awards!
Bug Reports v4 -- POST BUGS HERE https://www.smogon.com/forums/ps-bug-report-form/
- Thread starter DaWoblefet
- Start date
- Status
Here just to say that Octillery doesn't actually learn fire blast (it learns flamethrower):
https://replay.pokemonshowdown.com/gen2randombattle-1457336063
BUG STATUS: FIXED by Tarrembeau
Last edited by a moderator:
Hey, not sure if it's a bug or something else, but an Ice Fang from a Chewtle failed against my Toxicroak due to Dry Skin in this battle this battle.
BUG STATUS: NOT A BUG - That battle has Revelationmons Mod activated, which makes the first moveslot of the type of your Mon, so most likely Ice Fang was the one turned into Water type (Irpachuza)
BUG STATUS: NOT A BUG - That battle has Revelationmons Mod activated, which makes the first moveslot of the type of your Mon, so most likely Ice Fang was the one turned into Water type (Irpachuza)
Last edited by a moderator:
Possibly not a bug but court change has unexpected/hard to predict behaviour in free-for-all random battles: if one player has set entry hazards and another uses court change, I would anticipate the court change user being the only player without hazards, but instead the hazard-free slot just moves one place. May be difficult to make any more predictable behaviour since if two players set hazards it's unclear what should happen.
Example in this game (t16 kwekj sets hazards, t20 honestpanda uses court change, t25 honestpanda sends in luxray which is caught in a sticky web; presumably azarathegreat's regice sent in t23 is not affected but it has clear body so not having a stat drop isn't evidence): https://replay.pokemonshowdown.com/...-1457848280-cgasjubowuw7uc5uu81007b4v9zowhnpw
BUG STATUS: NOT A BUG, Court Change never existed at the same time as the closest FFA-like battle mechanics (Battle Royal in Gen 7) so the behavior is arbitrarily made up. You'd need to talk with those in charge of the FFA format. (DaWoblefet)
Example in this game (t16 kwekj sets hazards, t20 honestpanda uses court change, t25 honestpanda sends in luxray which is caught in a sticky web; presumably azarathegreat's regice sent in t23 is not affected but it has clear body so not having a stat drop isn't evidence): https://replay.pokemonshowdown.com/...-1457848280-cgasjubowuw7uc5uu81007b4v9zowhnpw
BUG STATUS: NOT A BUG, Court Change never existed at the same time as the closest FFA-like battle mechanics (Battle Royal in Gen 7) so the behavior is arbitrarily made up. You'd need to talk with those in charge of the FFA format. (DaWoblefet)
Last edited by a moderator:
I believe Beat Up may be coded incorrectly. The article on Bulbapedia (https://bulbapedia.bulbagarden.net/wiki/Beat_Up_(move)) states that " the user's Attack alone is used to calculate the damage of each strike" yet this replay showcases Beat Up using the attack of other pokemon:
https://replay.pokemonshowdown.com/gen8ou-1458377143-akr4gdzuc6b2p6jj8ksoydt32sak577pw
The first Beat Up (used by Bisharp) is significantly stronger than the others, which were lv.1 pokemon with minimum attack stats.
BUG STATUS: NOT A BUG, Beat Up changes its base power relative to the base attack of the Pokemon (e.g. 10 for Blissey), not its actual attack stat at level 1 (DaWoblefet)
https://replay.pokemonshowdown.com/gen8ou-1458377143-akr4gdzuc6b2p6jj8ksoydt32sak577pw
The first Beat Up (used by Bisharp) is significantly stronger than the others, which were lv.1 pokemon with minimum attack stats.
BUG STATUS: NOT A BUG, Beat Up changes its base power relative to the base attack of the Pokemon (e.g. 10 for Blissey), not its actual attack stat at level 1 (DaWoblefet)
Last edited by a moderator:
Hidden Power shows up as an illegal move on Pokémon that can get it in Natdex but validates properly
Edit: It looks like this applies to all cut moves
BUG STATUS: FIXED by Karthik
Edit: It looks like this applies to all cut moves
BUG STATUS: FIXED by Karthik
Last edited by a moderator:
https://replay.pokemonshowdown.com/gen8challengecup1v1-1458836731-bm25yqoc1i3jbvmtx3te9lcm9grbrz1pw
Hi. My zapdos galar used the first turn of fly then got hit by smack down, which I guess should cancel fly. But then I was only able to select fly so I selected it and zapdos did the first turn of fly. The animation showed it doing the second part of fly but it did the first part, before being hit by smack down again. So even though fly should have been cancelled by the smack down, I could only select fly.
(I used bounce on the first turn, that's not what I'm talking about. I used fly afterwards.)
BUG STATUS: FIXED by urkerab
Hi. My zapdos galar used the first turn of fly then got hit by smack down, which I guess should cancel fly. But then I was only able to select fly so I selected it and zapdos did the first turn of fly. The animation showed it doing the second part of fly but it did the first part, before being hit by smack down again. So even though fly should have been cancelled by the smack down, I could only select fly.
(I used bounce on the first turn, that's not what I'm talking about. I used fly afterwards.)
BUG STATUS: FIXED by urkerab
Last edited by a moderator:
hello, would you guys be able to fix the sprites so they don't overlap the boost?
BUG STATUS: WRONG PLACE, this would belong in Suggestions (DaWoblefet)
BUG STATUS: WRONG PLACE, this would belong in Suggestions (DaWoblefet)
Last edited by a moderator:
Kris is having me post this here, but this is regarding the question giveaway form in the Wi-Fi room.
So we get two pings, one is when the giveaway is announced:
and one when the giveaway question is posted:
We'd like just one ping at the start, this line will ping all users who have added this to their highlight lists via a button in an rfaq.
Second thing is that a user said they only got one guess at the question, when they should have three.
BUG STATUS: FIXED by Mia
So we get two pings, one is when the giveaway is announced:
Second thing is that a user said they only got one guess at the question, when they should have three.
BUG STATUS: FIXED by Mia
Last edited by a moderator:
I found (at my expenses) a weird interaction between encore and sleep talk on the simulator: encore fails if last move used is sleep talk. Since there's nothing in the not bugs section (or anywhere else online) suggesting that's the proper behaviour, I report it as a bug.
Further info: SWSH ZU match, encore was used by uxie, sleep talk was used by a malamar
BUG STATUS: NOT A BUG, Encore doesn't work on any moves that can call other moves (DaWoblefet)
Further info: SWSH ZU match, encore was used by uxie, sleep talk was used by a malamar
BUG STATUS: NOT A BUG, Encore doesn't work on any moves that can call other moves (DaWoblefet)
Last edited by a moderator:
Playing in BDSP Battle Festival Doubles. Final Turn I use Self-Destruct and KO opponent, I lose. This was a bug fixed in battle mechanics in Sun and Moon, correct behaviour allows the mon using Self-Destruct to win as it dealt the final blow.
BUG STATUS: NOT A BUG, you're in fact mistaken; thanks to misi for the video: (DaWoblefet)
BUG STATUS: NOT A BUG, you're in fact mistaken; thanks to misi for the video: (DaWoblefet)
Last edited by a moderator:
/clearignore doesn't seem to be working as intended.
For me, it's just bringing up /h ignore, while my ignore list stays the same.
BUG STATUS: FIXED by Karthik
For me, it's just bringing up /h ignore, while my ignore list stays the same.
BUG STATUS: FIXED by Karthik
Last edited by a moderator:
I'm back, since I've encountered another bug. I'm not sure if this is a thing with my browser (I just use Chrome), but my status seems to be visible to myself and others after already typing /clearstatus (the message "You don't have a status message set" shows up).
BUG STATUS: FIXED by Karthik
BUG STATUS: FIXED by Karthik
Last edited by a moderator:
https://replay.pokemonshowdown.com/gen8randombattle-1461242791-ucwrg1bjla7uj8bk1zb320volzocgwbpw why doesnt trace shadow tag prevent fett from switching
BUG STATUS: NOT A BUG, Shadow tag users can switch out if their opponent is also Shadow Tag. (Dawn of Ares)
BUG STATUS: NOT A BUG, Shadow tag users can switch out if their opponent is also Shadow Tag. (Dawn of Ares)
In this Gen 4 Random Battle, the Arceus was displayed as Arceus-Water upon being sent out, before immediately reverting to regular Arceus due to holding Leftovers. It should either have started as normal-type Arceus or Splash Plate should have been forced onto it.
If it's relevant, I used 1v1 random battle rulesets to make the room tournament, but that shouldn't affect team generation to my knowledge.
BUG STATUS: FIXED by Annika
If it's relevant, I used 1v1 random battle rulesets to make the room tournament, but that shouldn't affect team generation to my knowledge.
Code:
/tour new gen4randombattle, elimination
/tour rules teampreview, maxteamsize=3, pickedteamsize=1
/tour name [Gen 4] 1v1 Random BattleBUG STATUS: FIXED by Annika
Last edited by a moderator:
FFA random battle bug
If you invite user, and then they Dc and you press uninvite (doesn't matter whether or not they got back online then it will dispaly submitted! and wont let you do anything.Maybe would nice to have a command to invite people specifically to battle in an ffa, but im not a dev.
https://imgur.com/a/Gd77wJa - video of the bug
BUG STATUS: CONFIRMED - CHAT (SERVER) thanks for the video! (DaWoblefet)
If you invite user, and then they Dc and you press uninvite (doesn't matter whether or not they got back online then it will dispaly submitted! and wont let you do anything.Maybe would nice to have a command to invite people specifically to battle in an ffa, but im not a dev.
https://imgur.com/a/Gd77wJa - video of the bug
BUG STATUS: CONFIRMED - CHAT (SERVER) thanks for the video! (DaWoblefet)
Last edited by a moderator:
I've already posted this somewhere else, but I think it's worth further consideration from the community 
After running several experimental games with BluesEnergy00 on Showdown, I may have found a bug that concerns Ditto in GSC (Gen 2). On Smogon the item Metal Powder's description reads as follows:
If held by a Ditto, its Defense and Sp.Def are x1.5, even while Transformed.
When the move transform is used in battle it changes all of the stats (except the HP stat) and typing into those of what it is transforming into. Thus in order to test this fairly we pitted a pokemon against Ditto that naturally has the same base HP stat as it, in this case, Unown. Given that they both have a base HP stat of 48 it was ideal for this test. Logic would tell you that a Ditto carrying Metal Powder would simply transform into Unown (keep the same HP stat) and copy all of its stats but also have a 50% boost to both of these defenses even while transformed like the description says, but no. We found that instead of doing that in practice it seems that Ditto is simply not getting that promised defensive boost in its transformed state as can be seen here:
https://replay.pokemonshowdown.com/gen2ou-1440425517-lvq6yygup6g6u8mpk8wfjcwxrxav839pw
Assuming that is indeed an oversight, it is one that significantly effects Ditto viability in the competitive scene given that it doesn't enter the battle with the best stats to begin with (that is if anyone was tempted to use it at all).
BUG STATUS: NEEDS MORE RESEARCH I'd like a Gen II researcher to confirm (DaWoblefet)
After running several experimental games with BluesEnergy00 on Showdown, I may have found a bug that concerns Ditto in GSC (Gen 2). On Smogon the item Metal Powder's description reads as follows:
If held by a Ditto, its Defense and Sp.Def are x1.5, even while Transformed.
When the move transform is used in battle it changes all of the stats (except the HP stat) and typing into those of what it is transforming into. Thus in order to test this fairly we pitted a pokemon against Ditto that naturally has the same base HP stat as it, in this case, Unown. Given that they both have a base HP stat of 48 it was ideal for this test. Logic would tell you that a Ditto carrying Metal Powder would simply transform into Unown (keep the same HP stat) and copy all of its stats but also have a 50% boost to both of these defenses even while transformed like the description says, but no. We found that instead of doing that in practice it seems that Ditto is simply not getting that promised defensive boost in its transformed state as can be seen here:
https://replay.pokemonshowdown.com/gen2ou-1440425517-lvq6yygup6g6u8mpk8wfjcwxrxav839pw
Assuming that is indeed an oversight, it is one that significantly effects Ditto viability in the competitive scene given that it doesn't enter the battle with the best stats to begin with (that is if anyone was tempted to use it at all).
BUG STATUS: NEEDS MORE RESEARCH I'd like a Gen II researcher to confirm (DaWoblefet)
Last edited by a moderator:
This is some weird bug so
In this ss i reached 1855
But when i do /rank my rank shows it as 1820
Not only that even on the page when you click your username the rank is 1820
This is also not a ladder updating problem considering i got 23 points not 35 points Also this is not ladder decay considering I did play some games before
BUG STATUS: CONFIRMED - OTHER, this is just due to lag in the ladder database; there is nothing we can do about this (DaWoblefet)
In this ss i reached 1855
But when i do /rank my rank shows it as 1820
Not only that even on the page when you click your username the rank is 1820
This is also not a ladder updating problem considering i got 23 points not 35 points Also this is not ladder decay considering I did play some games before
BUG STATUS: CONFIRMED - OTHER, this is just due to lag in the ladder database; there is nothing we can do about this (DaWoblefet)
Last edited by a moderator:
I believe there may be a bug in the interaction between future sight and pokemon with the ability unaware. I tested a battle against my friend to see how future sight and unaware should interact when the future sight user boosts it's stats, and it appears that future sight's power increased after a calm mind boost, which does not match what the calc says is possible.
https://replay.pokemonshowdown.com/gen8ou-1462984459-oky1jntkbxa0oc4k1mxlm7ezvuivtubpw
On turn 3, clefable took 52% damage from future sight under psychic terrain. According to the calc, using storm zone's spread that he showed in the battle, this makes sense and appears to be working properly.
252 SpA Tapu Lele Future Sight vs. 248 HP / 204+ SpD Clefable in Psychic Terrain: 205-243 (52.1 - 61.8%) -- 97.7% chance to 2HKO after Leftovers recovery
However, after I used calm mind, and after psychic terrain ended, future sight did 60% of damage. According to the damage calc, this should not be possible.
+1 252 SpA Tapu Lele Future Sight vs. 248 HP / 204+ SpD Unaware Clefable: 159-187 (40.4 - 47.5%) -- guaranteed 3HKO after Leftovers recovery
and yet, 60% is a damage roll that would have been possible vs a magic guard clef with his given EV spread ((+1 252 SpA Tapu Lele Future Sight vs. 248 HP / 204+ SpD Clefable: 237-280 (60.3 - 71.2%) -- guaranteed 2HKO after Leftovers recovery)). However, this is an unaware clef, as revealed in the replay, and for some reason it took the boosted damage anyway. I tried looking into this online to see if there was a unique mechanic with this interaction, but i wasnt able to find anything
BUG STATUS: FIXED by pyuk
https://replay.pokemonshowdown.com/gen8ou-1462984459-oky1jntkbxa0oc4k1mxlm7ezvuivtubpw
On turn 3, clefable took 52% damage from future sight under psychic terrain. According to the calc, using storm zone's spread that he showed in the battle, this makes sense and appears to be working properly.
252 SpA Tapu Lele Future Sight vs. 248 HP / 204+ SpD Clefable in Psychic Terrain: 205-243 (52.1 - 61.8%) -- 97.7% chance to 2HKO after Leftovers recovery
However, after I used calm mind, and after psychic terrain ended, future sight did 60% of damage. According to the damage calc, this should not be possible.
+1 252 SpA Tapu Lele Future Sight vs. 248 HP / 204+ SpD Unaware Clefable: 159-187 (40.4 - 47.5%) -- guaranteed 3HKO after Leftovers recovery
and yet, 60% is a damage roll that would have been possible vs a magic guard clef with his given EV spread ((+1 252 SpA Tapu Lele Future Sight vs. 248 HP / 204+ SpD Clefable: 237-280 (60.3 - 71.2%) -- guaranteed 2HKO after Leftovers recovery)). However, this is an unaware clef, as revealed in the replay, and for some reason it took the boosted damage anyway. I tried looking into this online to see if there was a unique mechanic with this interaction, but i wasnt able to find anything
BUG STATUS: FIXED by pyuk
Last edited by a moderator:
Download no longer activates when a Pokemon with Neutralizing Gas faints. It has always activated in this scenario since the beginning of Gen 8.
Replays (thx LilyAC for tests):
https://replay.pokemonshowdown.com/gen8lc-1463180507-pu14j341el4k460goa4xe2utn80rhtcpw
https://replay.pokemonshowdown.com/gen8lc-1463177849-dfzmi4uwyelbinhzxicdlurq3svqhpcpw
How it used to work:
https://replay.pokemonshowdown.com/gen8lc-1354981805-xtgl0g92tkotw9djgxooq0eplt0llyjpw
This interaction has competitive consequences in Little Cup.
BUG STATUS: NOT A BUG, in fact Download does not activate in this situation on cart. Unless you have cart footage demonstrating otherwise, this is a long-time bug that was in fact recently fixed (DaWoblefet)
Replays (thx LilyAC for tests):
https://replay.pokemonshowdown.com/gen8lc-1463180507-pu14j341el4k460goa4xe2utn80rhtcpw
https://replay.pokemonshowdown.com/gen8lc-1463177849-dfzmi4uwyelbinhzxicdlurq3svqhpcpw
How it used to work:
https://replay.pokemonshowdown.com/gen8lc-1354981805-xtgl0g92tkotw9djgxooq0eplt0llyjpw
This interaction has competitive consequences in Little Cup.
Might this be what broke it?
BUG STATUS: NOT A BUG, in fact Download does not activate in this situation on cart. Unless you have cart footage demonstrating otherwise, this is a long-time bug that was in fact recently fixed (DaWoblefet)
Last edited by a moderator:
On the simulator, a Future Sight from a Pokémon whose stats are boosted will ignore an enemy Pokémon's Unaware ability.
https://replay.pokemonshowdown.com/gen8bdspou-1463328657-63oeearqlrl18v4n4bdearcf18arb9mpw
https://replay.pokemonshowdown.com/gen8ou-1463321041-1bnsso97h6cf6q4xzrl9q5fjpv203xmpw
This is a bug as it does not work like that in the main games.
BUG STATUS: FIXED by pyuk
https://replay.pokemonshowdown.com/gen8bdspou-1463328657-63oeearqlrl18v4n4bdearcf18arb9mpw
https://replay.pokemonshowdown.com/gen8ou-1463321041-1bnsso97h6cf6q4xzrl9q5fjpv203xmpw
This is a bug as it does not work like that in the main games.
BUG STATUS: FIXED by pyuk
Last edited by a moderator:
The CAP LC validator seems to reject certain combinations of Gen 7 tutor moves and Gen 8 moves for Brattler for an unknown reason, even though those moves should in theory be compatible. The regular CAP format validator also rejects these, so it seems to be unrelated to any LC rules.
This issue first showed up when a user tried to bring a set of Glare / Knock Off / Parting Shot / Power Whip. For reference, Parting Shot and Glare are level up moves in Gen 8, Power Whip is a Gen 8 TR, and Knock Off is a Gen 7 tutor. Parting Shot was added to its level up in Gen 8; otherwise, it received all of its other moves in Gen 7. The validator gave this message:
This is what was in the teambuilder:
I also tried a few other combinations to see if I could spot a pattern. Nothing stood out, but I figured I should include it anyways.
I am not completely if this issue extends to other Pokemon in CAP LC, but we have not had any issues reported yet, and Pokemon like Justyke can pair Gen 7 tutor moves with Gen 8 moves without issue, so my guess is this is primarily isolated to Brattler.
BUG STATUS: NOT A BUG; quoting from a user in the CAP room wulfanator: "Brattler does not learn parting shot until level 48 according to the learnset data in the repository. The other two moves are attainable at level 1 from a "previous generation." Since brattler is level 5 in the picture you linked, that appears to be the problem." (DaWoblefet)
This issue first showed up when a user tried to bring a set of Glare / Knock Off / Parting Shot / Power Whip. For reference, Parting Shot and Glare are level up moves in Gen 8, Power Whip is a Gen 8 TR, and Knock Off is a Gen 7 tutor. Parting Shot was added to its level up in Gen 8; otherwise, it received all of its other moves in Gen 7. The validator gave this message:
This is what was in the teambuilder:
I also tried a few other combinations to see if I could spot a pattern. Nothing stood out, but I figured I should include it anyways.
For reference, Crunch is a level up move, and was one in Gen 7 as well.
If I replace Glare with Crunch then it says Knock/Parting is incompatible.
If I replace Knock with Crunch then it says the whole set is fine.
If I replace Parting with Crunch then it says the whole set is fine.
For reference, Synthesis is another Gen 7 tutor move.
If I replace Glare with Synthesis then it says Synthesis/Knock Off/Parting Shot is incompatible.
If I replace Knock with Synthesis then it says Synthesis/Glare/Parting is incompatible.
If I replace Parting with Synthesis then it says the whole set is fine.
If I replace Glare with Crunch then it says Knock/Parting is incompatible.
If I replace Knock with Crunch then it says the whole set is fine.
If I replace Parting with Crunch then it says the whole set is fine.
For reference, Synthesis is another Gen 7 tutor move.
If I replace Glare with Synthesis then it says Synthesis/Knock Off/Parting Shot is incompatible.
If I replace Knock with Synthesis then it says Synthesis/Glare/Parting is incompatible.
If I replace Parting with Synthesis then it says the whole set is fine.
I am not completely if this issue extends to other Pokemon in CAP LC, but we have not had any issues reported yet, and Pokemon like Justyke can pair Gen 7 tutor moves with Gen 8 moves without issue, so my guess is this is primarily isolated to Brattler.
BUG STATUS: NOT A BUG; quoting from a user in the CAP room wulfanator: "Brattler does not learn parting shot until level 48 according to the learnset data in the repository. The other two moves are attainable at level 1 from a "previous generation." Since brattler is level 5 in the picture you linked, that appears to be the problem." (DaWoblefet)
Last edited by a moderator:
Ok so in showdown snorlax cant learn splash. It was an event move for snorlax and I have a strat that needs snorlax to have splash. https://projectpokemon.org/home/files/file/1841-classic-pcny-splash-snorlax/
https://bulbapedia.bulbagarden.net/wiki/Splash_(move)
Which format are you trying to validate this Snorlax in? Since it was an event released on the original GSC, it wouldn't be obtainable outside of that and Gen 1 tradebacks. (DaWoblefet)
Edit: TECHNICALLY pokemon are tradeable out of gen 2 but its difficult for 1. For 2 Im trying to do a national dex battle so wouldnt that still have splash because its nat dex? (EchoTheMythical)
BUG STATUS: NOT A BUG, No, a Gen II event Snorlax could not be traded out of Gen II. You could not trade from the original Gen II games to a further Pokemon game. This is not legal in the National Dex format. (DaWoblefet)
https://bulbapedia.bulbagarden.net/wiki/Splash_(move)
Which format are you trying to validate this Snorlax in? Since it was an event released on the original GSC, it wouldn't be obtainable outside of that and Gen 1 tradebacks. (DaWoblefet)
Edit: TECHNICALLY pokemon are tradeable out of gen 2 but its difficult for 1. For 2 Im trying to do a national dex battle so wouldnt that still have splash because its nat dex? (EchoTheMythical)
BUG STATUS: NOT A BUG, No, a Gen II event Snorlax could not be traded out of Gen II. You could not trade from the original Gen II games to a further Pokemon game. This is not legal in the National Dex format. (DaWoblefet)
Last edited by a moderator:
- Status