G-Luke said:The chief stand out is by far Bone Rush. Bone Rush is a rather controversial attack, with people claiming to call it uncompetitive. Bone Rush hits 3 times an average of 66% of the time, a 10% chance to miss, a 1/6 chance of hitting at a weak base power and a combined 30% chance of pushing to a higher BP. Just like Blizzard, roughly 70% of the time it does what is intended.
Lemme get the correct probabilities before we continue. For the sake of this post, we'll assume no crits as that would make the math much more complex.
2/20(10%) - Miss - 0BP
6/20(30%) - 2 Hits - 75BP
6/20(30%) - 3 Hits - 112.5BP
3/20(15%) - 4 Hits - 150 BP
3/20(15%) - 5 Hits - 187.5BP
Average: 106.875BP
math
The miss chance is easy since it has nothing to do with number of hits, so it is
1/10
Without factoring in accuracy, the odds for 2, 3, 4, or 5 hits are
1/3 - 2 Hits
1/3 - 3 Hits
1/6 - 4 Hits
1/6 - 5 Hits
Each of these probabilities only occur after the 9/10 chance of hitting, so we need to multiply each of those probabilities by 9/10
9/30 - 2 Hits
9/30 - 3 Hits
9/60 - 4 Hits
9/60 - 5 Hits
In order for these figures to be easily comparable, the denominators need to be converted to the same number
1/10 * 2/2 = 2/20
9/30 * 2/2 = 18/60 | (18/60) / (3/3) = 6/20
(9/60) / (3/3) = 3/20
And just to double check the math was right, the numerators should add up to the shared denominator of 20
2+6+6+3+3 = 20
The average BP came from multiplying the probability by the BP of each event and then adding them together
This average may not look too impressive compared to Earthquake's 100BP, but compare Fire Blast and Flamethrower(93.5 vs 90) or Focus Blast vs Aura Sphere(84 vs 80) and you can see that it would not be at all unreasonable to use Bone Rush over Earthquake. It outperforms EQ 60% of the time and does some, albeit less damage 30% of the time.
Bone Rush has a considerable chance of screwing over the user, either not being strong enough to do considerable damage or straight up missing. It also has a considerable chance to gain BP and break through things it may not be able to with other Ground attacks. I believe uncompetitive strats allow the user to rely on RNG to win rather than skil, forcing unviable strategies to counter. Bone Rush to me, while it does have an RNG factor, is not to the point in which it makes users rely on luck to win.... In addition, the chance to fail and not be at an effective BP isn't a meaningless value, and can be severely punished for doing so thanks to Smokomodo's fraility. I think people that are against Bone Rush just do not want to lose to cheese, and use the uncompetitive argument as a shield.
Here is where we get to the difference between Bone Rush and attacks like Focus Blast or Fire Blast. Those attacks are easy to prepare against. They either hit and do 110/120BP worth of damage, or they do nothing. When calcing for them, you assume they hit, but with Bone Rush how many hits do you calc for? 3? 4? All 5? You could base your calcs on it doing 3 hits, but then you'll be beaten 30% of the time. Once we get to 4 or 5 hits we reach or exceed the power of Bonemerang, so if you want to be sure your mon will be a consistent answer to Bone Rush Smokomodo, you need to assume it will do 5 hits. That puts a large restriction on teambuilding if you need a check for Smokomodo.
As an example, Earthquake is a guaranteed 3HKO on Sub DD Zygarde, so Zygarde could switch in and then either OHKO it with Thousand Arrows or Dragon Dance, then hit it with Thousand Arrows
252 Atk Earth Plate Numel Earthquake vs. 188 HP / 0 Def Zygarde: 154-183 (38.1 - 45.2%) -- guaranteed 3HKO after Leftovers recovery
140+ Atk Zygarde Thousand Arrows vs. 0 HP / 4 Def Numel: 338-398 (106.6 - 125.5%) -- guaranteed OHKO
So with just EQ, this Zygarde set can switch in and KO/force out Smokomodo every time, barring crits(even then it would need two crits to 2HKO). But if Smokomodo is carrying Bone Rush, it will take 7 or 8 hits total to KO depending on rolls. The probability of this happening is somewhere between 18% and 36%(the damage calc doesn't make this easy, idk what the exact percentage is but it is within that range) So this set, which would've been a guaranteed switch in now has between about a one in five and a one in three chance of losing just because of RNG.
This is both uncompetitive and unfun
This is just one example, but you will get similar results with almost any other grounded defensive check.
It doesn't take unviable strats to counter Bone Rush either (most common ways to deal with Ground type attacks still apply for Bone Rush)... The fact that this phenomenon actually exists in standard play (Bullet Seed Breloom) and has not been banned nor deemed uncompetitive in nature further proves my point.
Bone Rush
does force people to run one of a small set of defensive Pokemon if they want a consistent answer for Smokomodo. I'd like to point out that Breloom is slow with 70 base speed, frail with 60/80/60 Defenses, has a 4x weakness to the common Flying type, and has to use the mediocre offensive type of Grass to deal out significant damage. Despite all of this, it got banned in UU. To be fair, Tech Bullet Seed was not the only reason it got banned, Spore was another big part in that and its ability to also run a Sub Poison Heal set, but it was still a big factor in its banning.
Hax is something that is common place in Pokemon and is something we will always have to deal with, as annoying as being fully paralyzed three turns in a row is.
Terrible point. Just because stuff like this already happens means that we should actively add more RNG? Is this a competitive project or not?
That rant out of the way, we gotta justify Bone Rush, which actually is not hard. Komodo Dragons, while voracious predators, are also notorious scavengers. And what is more associated with carrion than anything else? Bones. Bone Rush being granted to a Pokemon due to having some connections to scavenging is not even new, as Mandibuzz also gets the move.
Mandibuzz has a bone in its design, it doesn't just get it because it is a scavenger. Rattata, Raticate, Teddiursa, Ursaring, Poochyena, Mightyena, Wingull, and many othjers I'm sure are all based on animals that are primarily or occasionally scavengers, but they don't get Bone Rush.
The only Pokemon that gets Bone Rush but doesn't have a bone in its design is Lucario, which is based on the Egyptian god Anubis. Its primary roles in Egyptian mythology were the guider of souls to the afterlife, an embalmer, the weighing of a person's heart to determine if they went to the afterlife, and as the protector of graves, cemeteries, and tombs. That last one I think being the most important part of why it gets Bone Rush. As far as I am aware no other Pokemon is as directly connected to the dead in a supernatural way as Lucario is. Before you bring up Yveltal, it doesn't deal at all with the dead, it causes death. It is more akin to a Dementor or an atomic bomb than to something like Anubis.