Alright, let's go over some abilities. Our choice of ability needs to fulfill the concept of offensive support while also being able to be a contender in the current, relatively bulky metagame. I've included 3 tl;drs if you're not interested in snake_publications_inc :)
Abilities that I like:
GMars said:Regenerator
I've already gone over Regenerator's long benefits in my previous post. Basically, when Knock Off, poison damage, and relatively weak attacks are being thrown around everywhere, Regenerator is an incredible option to enables CAP27 to tank those, retain momentum, not waste a moveslot with recovery.
GMars said:Serene Grace
Serene Grace is one that has a lot of potential. With this ability, CAP27 can run STAB moves with high chances to status the opponent, meaning that we compress extremely reliable utility into its offensive moves. This is important because it makes a 3 attacks + recovery set a feasible option, unlike with many other abilities, as at least 1 of those 3 attacks can have some utility attached to it. 2 attacks + utility + recovery still works also. Even though it doesn't help with survivability and switch-in opportunities, this ability really leans into the offensive support that this concept is literally being built upon, so Serene Grace is a good option to me.
GMars said:Poison Touch
Poison Touch is very similar to Serene Grace. By compressing a poison chance into CAP27's STAB attacks, we bring in additional utility to CAP27's attacks without consuming moveslots.
As for regular poison, I think it's an underrated status. Sure, it's not Toxic, but a 12.5% flat damage rate every turn isn't anything to sneeze at. It will deal more damage than Toxic would before 3 consecutive turns of Toxic damage. It means Pokemon like Mandibuzz, Hippowdon, Tomohawk, and Arghonaut suddenly have to spam recovery for an attack that does about 40% rather than about 50%, which is significant. Guts users like Colossoil, Conkeldurr, and Obstagoon will be wary to switch in due to Poison Touch activating; while that will activate Guts, it's chipping away a lot faster than it would with burn. Dragapult and Seismitoad, which have no recovery, are that much more annoyed to switch into CAP27's Fire-type STAB.
It also means that CAP27 can spam one STAB attack to see how the opponent will respond to it; if it's a resisted hit, Poison Touch could activate as a consolation and the CAP27 user can gain valuable information about how the opponent will react or simply punish their switch in. Finally, the Steel-types that would want to switch in and absorb Poison Touch simply don't want to because of Fire-type STAB.
Also, just because CAP27 has Poison Touch doesn't mean it can't inflict other status. If the CAP27 user predicts a physical attacker switching in, it could use a burn-inducing attack instead. Many Pokemon in the past have run dual status sets, and this Pokemon would play no differently from them. Bottom-line, this ability may not be the most powerful, but it definitely breaks into the offensive support and is underrated. The offensive side is easing prediction with a sizable chance to deal passive damage and punish counters while the support side is softening up the opposing team for CAP27's teammates. And while it may impact counters a little bit, it's not outright beating them with Poison Touch, just inflicting a status.
tl;dr 1
- Regenerator
- Mitigates Knock Off, passive damage, and damage from weak attacks we want to switch into
- Enables CAP27 to retain momentum
- Allows CAP27 to not run a recovery move, opening up a valuable moveslot and lowering the chance of 3 non-utility attacks + recover set
- Serene Grace
- Increases the reliability of damaging utility moves
- Enables CAP27 to run 3 attacks + recovery sets that have utility compressed into them (doesn't preclude 2 attacks + utility + recovery)
- Allows CAP27 to soften the opposing team with status in a more offensive way
- Poison Touch
- Allows CAP27 to annoy anything that wants to switch into it, without outright beating any of its checks and counters
- Synergizes very well with Fire typing due to Steel-types not wanting to switch in
- Doesn't mean CAP27 can't inflict other status like burns or paralysis
- Team support is wearing down the opposing team quickly
Abilities that I think would sorta work:
GMars said:Magic Bounce
Magic Bounce is a weird one for me. Although it's powerful...I'm not sure how well CAP27 can take advantage of it. Looking at our threatlist, it does bounce Toxic back at Rotom-H, which is very useful. However...I'm worried about how well it can use it past that one matchup. Kommo-O and Ferrothorn's hazards are reflected, but CAP27 still has to worry about Knock Off and Earthquake from them. Other hazard setters like Seismitoad, Hippowdon, and Arghonaut don't particularly fear CAP27 that much and can threaten it with Earth Power, Earthquake, or Knock Off. So, it could bounce back hazards, but it's not going to be the most reliable at keeping them off the field unless it's good enough to force out these hazard setters. For status users, it's really risky. Hippowdon and Seismitoad will hate having their Toxic reflected at them, and Hydreigon and Dragapult will hate having Thunder Wave thrown at them, but they all threaten CAP27 with their STAB attacks. For me, obviously Magic Bounce is useful because it's Magic Bounce - a really strong ability - but I'm not sure if CAP27 is the best user for it, and I think the above 3 abilities are much better for it.
GMars said:Multiscale
I'm pretty iffy on Multiscale. I'm concerned that CAP27 will have to be at full health a lot of the time to really make use of this ability. CAP27 really want to switch into a lot of weaker attacks. Why do we want to soften blows from really weak attacks? Admittedly, it's useful that CAP27 could potentially tank Dragapult and Hydreigon's Draco Meteor, Terrakion's Stone Edge, etc. but that will require CAP27 to keep multiscale up, and that means it can't switch into those weaker attacks without dedicating its free turns to use recovery. We also start falling into the 3 non-utility attacks + recovery moveset territory, and I really want to avoid that. Plus, it's hard for CAP27 to hold Leftovers to refresh Multiscale easily, and we don't have access to any STAB HP-draining attacks. I can see the benefits, but I'm not terribly sold on it. It's offensive support in that it can potentially remove a powerful, faster threat if played well, but I'm still not completely sold right now. In Gen 7 I'd be much more supportive of this ability, as that metagame had many more strong attacks flung around, but I don't think it's as applicable here.
tl;dr 2
- Magic Bounce
- Limited usefulness against hazard setters and status users: Rotom-H is a solid matchup, Ferrothorn and Kommo-O are more reliable, but other Pokemon like Hippodown, Seismitoad, Hydreigon, and Dragapult are really difficult to switch into to reflect their moves
- Obviously strong because it's Magic Bounce, but could be more useful on a CAP with a better typing
- Multiscale
- Good to tank a strong hit from a powerful foe, but I'm not convinced that the metagame is offensive enough / has enough powerful moves thrown around to warrant this type of support
- Most of the time Multiscale will be broken by weak attacks, and we don't have HP-draining attacks and likely won't be holding Leftovers to refresh Multiscale easily. Recovery will be likely required on movesets - increases chance of 3 non-utility attacks + recovery sets
- Will have to spam recover most of the time to refresh Multiscale - could mean we don't use our utility as much?
Abilities that I think are inferior/not useful enough:
GMars said:Sticky Hold
Alrighty, let's dig into this ability some more. I don't think I've ratted out enough how useless this ability is. Let's take a look at the post GMars linked...
theotherguytm said:Permanent immunity to hazards in conjunction with the Boots. This is the obvious upside of Sticky Hold. Just ask Clefable what immunity to hazards can do for you, and in CAP 27's case, immunity to hazards is very, very useful to negate Stealth Rock. An ability which pairs so strongly with our most natural item should not be underestimated.
This is very true, and I see why this ability is appealing. However, if we take the time to look at the Knock Off users in the metagame, it becomes apparent that CAP27 doesn't want to be switching into most Knock Off users anyway. I'm going to repeat what I said in my previous post because I already said this:
"Sticky Hold protects CAP27's Heavy-Duty Boots, which is great. But what uses Knock Off in the metagame? CAP27's switch-ins are Ferrothorn and Zeraora. It's good that we're better switch-ins to them. But...that's about it. Ferrothorn legitimately becomes a perfect switch-in, but Zeraora will more than likely be faster than CAP27 (not a guarantee of course, but 143 Speed is pretty high). CAP27 won't necessarily like switching into other passive Knock Off users like Clefable, Arghonaut, Mandibuzz, and Toxapex given their access to status - unless they're weakened I don't see CAP27 realistically staying in. I also really doubt we'll have the titanic bulk required to tank multiple Knock Off from the Guts wallbreakers that run it: Conkeldurr, Colossoil, and Obstagoon, especially because Knock Off will always be at full power and we take neutral damage. Bisharp doesn't have Guts, but Knock Off + Sucker Punch will still leave a mark. Basically, I think Sticky Hold tries to address a legitimate concern that CAP27 faces, but I don't think we have the typing to act as an effective Knock Off absorber. I think Regenerator covers what Sticky Hold is trying to address but actually accomplishes what it needs to."
Also, Caribolt barely ever runs Knock Off. Basically, we don't really want to be a Knock Off absorber.
theotherguytm said:However, it has seen use in LC on mons such as Shellos and (in the past) Trubbish. The Eviolite VS Knock Off metagame in LC makes Sticky Hold invaluable for these two.
This is true, but LC has many more weaker Knock Off users that they'd want to switch into. Shellos is a slow, bulky, and rather passive wall that can tank Knock Off hits, while Trubbish is able to force out the Fighting-types that use Knock Off. CAP27 doesn't want to be a passive wall, nor does it force out a large list of Knock Off users.
theotherguytm said:
- Rotom forms: CAP 27 would love to switch in on Rotom-H and Rotom-M without worrying about being Tricked a Choice Scarf.
- Clefable: Not losing our item to Clef, and especially being immune to receiving a Sticky Barb, would ensure CAP 27 can switch-in on any defensive Clefable.
- Celebi and Jirachi: Two more switch-ins that might give us a nasty present.
Since the Home metagame, Choice Scarf Rotom-H has declined massively, as well as Rotom-M in general. Clefable's Trick sets have died in favor of Wish + Teleport, Calm Mind, and Thunder Wave / Knock Off / other utility Clefable. Celebi isn't even ranked on the VR. Jirachi is the only relevant Choice Scarf user you pointed out.
Unless we become a super sturdy wall, which is antithetical to "offensive support," Sticky Hold realistically helps 2 matchups: Ferrothorn and Jirachi. It sorts of helps against Bisharp and Zeraora. Overall, I think rather than focusing on keeping our Heavy-Duty Boots throughout the battle, it's much better to embrace the fact that item manipulation is a staple of Gen 8, that Regenerator actually addresses Knock Off concerns much better, and being immune to Jirachi's Trick isn't good enough for the primary ability.
GMars said:Immunity
Basically, I think Regenerator outclasses this ability. Toxic is definitely a good move in this metagame, but the only relevant Toxic user that we threaten ourselves is Rotom-H. Being immune to Mollux's Sludge Bomb poison is good too, but I'm a lot more concerned by the actual damage from Sludge Bomb rather than the chip damage at this point. Mandibuzz, Seismitoad, Toxapex, and Arghonaut all have other ways to damage us - be it Knock Off or Earthquake - so even if we switch into Toxic, we're facing down something that forces us out. For this reason, I don't think Immunity is actually that helpful. It helps in two matchups, and CAP27 can benefit more from Regenerator, which covers these matchups and more.
GMars said:Poison Heal
Poison Heal suffers from the same issues as Immunity, except now it forces us to want Toxic Orb. Which, as we've seen from Snaelstrom, isn't good on a Stealth Rock-weak Pokemon. Also, as we've also seen from Snaelstrom, holding boots and hoping for the opponent to use Toxic against a Poison Heal user isn't a reliable strategy either. I'd rather pass on this ability in favor of Regenerator too.
GMars said:Natural Cure
The same problems as Immunity apply to this one too, except now we get to deal with paralysis users too. Jirachi has better moves to be running than Thunder Wave and Body Slam right now, and Rotom-H has been running less Discharge after the Home meta. Dragapult and Choice Scarf Hydreigon aren't exactly easy to switch into due to Draco Meteor, so absorbing their Thunder Wave isn't the best idea. It'll be harder to force Clefable out, especially if we're paralyzed. I could be missing a few paralysis inducers, but...yeah I'm not particularly enthused by this ability. Yes, we can absorb and cure status, but to what end? We barely force out anything that induces status - in fact most of the time they still force us out, so CAP27 is still on the back foot.
GMars said:Grassy Surge
In such a bulky metagame, I think this ability is more of a detriment to CAP27 and its team rather than a benefit. Yes, I realize the importance of passive recovery; I ran Trick Room in Gen 7 with Tapu Bulu and its Grassy Surge was what held those teams together. However, giving double Leftovers to opposing Toxapex, Clefable, and Seismitoad and Leftovers recovery to opposing Mollux seems really hard to overcome when we've lost a lot of breakers in the generational shift. Rather than preventing CAP27's wallbreaking teammates from being worn down too much, I fear that the opposing team will just bulk out all its teammates' hits. Plus, weakening Earthquake means nothing when almost every Earthquake user a) can switch to High Horsepower (think Hippowdon, Excadrill, and Colossoil, b) uses Earth Power anyway (think Seismitoad and Gastrodon) or c) just use a different move (think Syclant, Tyranitar, or Knock Off Arghonaut). Anyone hoping to have Grass-type coverage on CAP27 itself should take one look at the threatlist and realize that we completely stuff almost every check and counter with near-STAB Grass-type coverage in the mix, which makes the chance of having Grass-type coverage incredibly small. I don't think this is the right metagame or Pokemon for Grassy Surge
tl;dr 3
- Sticky Hold
- Knock Off and Trick immunity is cool on a Pokemon likely to carry Heavy-Duty Boots, but if you actually look at the Knock Off and Trick users, CAP27 really threatens two - Jirachi and Ferrothorn - and sorta takes on two others - Zeraora and Bisharp
- The rest either carry status (Mandibuzz, Toxapex, Arghonaut) or are Guts wallbreakers (Colossoil, Conkeldurr, Obstagoon).
- It's also not likely we'll really force out Mandibuzz, Toxapex, or Arghonaut
- Knock Off damage isn't reduced and we don't resist it, so we'll have to be super bulky to take on these stronger ones.
- Trick has really died since Home was introduced - Jirachi is the only relevant user right now.
- This ability is really good on paper, but underwhelming when you actually look at the context of the current metagame
- If you want to actually address how CAP27 may lose its Heavy-Duty Boots, pick Regenerator.
- Immunity
- Realistically only helps against Rotom-H and Mollux
- Other Toxic users like Mandibuzz, Seismitoad, Toxapex, and Arghonaut can cripple CAP27 in other ways - Knock Off or Earthquake
- Even if CAP27 can successfully switch in, it can't force out those Toxic users based on typing alone
- Choose Regenerator if you want to mitigate Poison damage
- Poison Heal
- Suffers the same problems as Immunity
- Snaelstrom has really demonstrated the problem of a Stealth Rock-weak Poison Heal Pokemon - can't hold Toxic Orb and HDB at the same time
- Choose Regenerator if you want to mitigate Poison damage
- Natural Cure
- Suffers the same problems as Immunity AND two of the most Thunder Wave users are fast Dragon-types
- Jirachi hasn't been running Body Slam or Thunder Wave that much this generation, and Discharge Rotom-H has declined
- Choose Regenerator if you want to mitigate Poison damage, and most Paralysis-inducing users threaten us anyway, so there's not much of a point in trying to absorb paralysis - just avoid it altogether
- Grassy Surge
- In the bulky metagame, passively healing CAP27's wallbreaking teammates isn't worth giving double Leftovers or Leftovers + HDB to the opposing balance teams
- EQ reduction is deceptively easy to work around
- Grass-type coverage is really unlikely given the entirety of CAP27's threatlist
EDIT: GMars didn't mention Neutralizing Gas on his post so I forgot it >:(
Neutralizing Gas is just ok. The relevant abilities that it turns off are Tomohawk's Intimidate (if we're physical), Toxapex's Regenerator, Hippowdon's Sand Stream, and Guts from Conkeldurr, Obstagoon, and Colossoil. However, CAP27 will have to rely on a teammate switching out of Toxapex for Neutralizing Gas to really take effect because Toxapex very likely won't fear CAP27 at all. All those Guts users carry Knock Off, which still removes our Heavy-Duty Boots. Other than that, there aren't any immunities that we'd want to abuse (Flash Fire Chandelure is the closest we'll get). Making Ditto's Imposter fail is funny but not that useful. Syclant could switch in and take 50% from Stealth Rock, but 99% of the time it's not going to want to switch into CAP27 because we're a Fire-type. In fact, Neutralizing Gas potentially makes us worse against Arghonaut if we're special because Draco Meteor's drops are no longer ignored. Basically, it's a really cool and powerful ability, and it has a few cool uses, but it's not doing anything really notable for CAP27. Would put it in the middle category (abilities that sorta work) I think.
EDIT 2: As this thread draws to a close, I think I like Poison Touch, then Regenerator, then Serene Grace the best for primary ability. Poison Touch and Regenerator have been swapping places a lot though.