capefeather said:Like I implied in my other posts, there is more than one kind of "life in prison". In Canada, first-degree murder automatically gives you 25 years without parole. I've heard that in one or more Scandanavian countries, criminals in government custody are treated pretty humanely, no need for suicide watch, really, but again, I'm not terribly familiar with the details. My original point was that the people in this thread were only talking about one kind of "life in prison" involving isolation on a regular basis and just general neglect.This is a terrible idea as it is essentially vigilantism (plus who is "a victim's family"??). Keep in mind, I'm not the one who made assumptions about the victim's family or other loved ones.
You do realize that this also describes you?
The entertainment industry, for all its faults, has provided us with plenty of scenarios under which we are made to sympathize with a character's quest to murder someone else. Sure, it's fiction; I don't have much of a habit of delving into why real people plan to kill someone. All the same, humans don't suddenly cease to be complicated individuals once they commit such a heinous crime. Ultimately, my problem with "murders are evil" is that it's meaningless. It explains nothing, it accomplishes nothing, and thus has no more useful application than, say, the Abrahamic concept of sin. All it is is a restatement of your lack of empathy for the situation. And as I've pointed out in my other posts, meaningless descriptors intended to dehumanize can have devastating consequences.
How can you say that anyone is "winning" or "losing" when you really haven't even made an argument at all? All you've done is restate your opinion and go on some weird tangent about solving Mexico's problems. There is no winning or losing here. If you like repeating your own lack of empathy to yourself in forum post form, that's great, but I don't care.
So your original point is just that you can have a life in prison that's more humane than ours? or that you don't necessarily need a life in prison?
1: The main problems with vigilantism are
A:against the law (in this case it wouldn't be)
B: involve ordinary citizens getting involved in things they shouldn't (i argue they should be)
2: Not really. I'm just fine with a person dying for comitting horrible crimes. I wouldn't do it myself and I get no real personal gain from it-i just have no problem with it either. Sure, by my allowance of this i'm contributing a tiny share, but nowhere near what a murderer does. And unlike a murderer, I have much more legitimate reasons to do so-subjective, but 99.9% of the population agrees. (not even places like nazi germany had such widespread acceptance, and also involved disagreers being killed, so don't throw that shit at me)
3: the weird tangent was in response to your mention of trump.
4: good thing I pointed out that i'm non-partisan and simply reading arguments I see overall, and then stated that, by what i'm seeing, death penalty is winning. sure, I could be lying about it, but it's a reasonable statement to make and, even if i'm lying, what do you care?
Kinneas said:Unfortunately things are never this black and white. I refer you to the case of Charles Whitman, a former US Marine who murdered sixteen people, including his own wife and mother. His actions were premeditated. As stark an evil as you can get, right? Certainly not someone you should shed a tear for.
He wrote in his journal before committing the murders asking for a post mortem to be performed on his brain because he couldn't understand why he was suddenly overcome with inexplicable rages and an urge to kill.
Charles Whitman's autopsy revealed a giant tumour in his brain that was almost certainly the cause of his rages and lack of impulse control that led him to commit the mass murders.
He was killed by the police, but had he not been, he would almost certainly have been put to death for his crimes. Knowing now what we know about the tumour, and seeing the journal entries stating how he was sorry for what he was about to do but could not control himself, do you still consider him an evil person? Would a death sentence here serve any real purpose other than to satiate some primitive lust for revenge felt by relatives of the victims?
I don't understand this at all, could you explain it? Are you saying that the family of the victim should get to decide if a person should be put to death and how? Like the criminal justice system is some kind of game show where the guilty loser has to do a wacky forfeit? You can't seriously be suggesting putting the power of life and death in the hands of traumatized family members of the victim?
i think things often are that black and white, and that this case is perhaps the exception.
you're trying to establish an equivalency between other external factors and tumors, I believe? (not insulting you, it's a great point to bring up). to me the difference is that tumors clearly entered the body and changed him from what he was previously, whereas the other kinds of external factors are there from the beginning and far more difficult to distinguish, as well as easier to mitigate. Additionally, i don't think you can cure a murderer.
as to the second, well, my point was more that the policies are supposedly to give the families what they want, but they could just be asked. Still, now that i think, i can't think of a way to get their opinions on the matter without some serious negative factors, so I guess it's a bad idea after all