lol, since this has been bumped...
I followed DBZ as a kid... or at least tried to. My parents had a weird attitude toward "violent" shows and video games like DBZ. Sometimes they'd let us watch, but other times they were all up in our faces about watching violent media. Also the church I attended as a kid was rather unfriendly to anime. (As an aside, I'm still surprised that the very original Ocean dub kept the scene of a Saibaman falling apart after Vegeta blew it up...)
I don't know about in general, but I suspect that the main thing that makes Dragon Ball "so great" to the majority of North Americans is the many flaws that made it so-bad-it's-good. I generally don't consider Dragon Ball very good overall. Don't get me wrong, I like the series and I can talk about it, but I get that a lot of that is because I (and many, MANY people over the last few decades) grew up with some form of it. I wouldn't recommend it to very many people who aren't already into it. I'm also not downplaying its role in popularizing anime outside of Japan or inspiring modern shonen manga/anime. However, it's true that a product isn't good just because it started something big. In the Tales series, for example, most people seem to consider the original versions of the first two entries unplayable...
So I'm not going to enumerate the flaws of Dragon Ball, because there really are so many that one can pick out and different people put different values on those flaws. Considering what I just said, though, it's clear what my opinion is on the second point. The series wasn't successful in spite of its flaws; it was successful partially
because of them. I definitely see the Abridged series as proof of this. People like making fun of the shitty plot, shittier script (don't even bother convincing me it's any good, maybe the Japanese version is blander, idk, but seriously), and even shittier voice acting. There are also YouTube channels like ImmaVegeta whose main purpose is to pick out Dragon Ball clips and titling/captioning them in humorous ways (though sometimes the clips speak for themselves).
Dragon Ball is basically an embodiment of
the peacock.
Buu saga was just a shitty convoluted mess designed to make money by appealing to small boy's love of flashy power-ups with no rhyme, reason, or substance-- the series tremendous inconsistencies are also ridiculous.
I'm sorry, but that kind of applies to the entire series (including the "death is meaningless" part). Buu was just the worst about it (unless you count GT, which does this even worse). There are lots of good endings to the series, with arguably just as much closure to it as the Cell Arc's ending. Tournament 23 (with Goku fighting Piccolo Jr.) was a really good possible ending. But anyway, AT's notorious for not planning very far ahead, and because of this, what any one person thinks Dragon Ball is "about" is probably far from the truth. The series NEVER took itself seriously, which is probably another part of why it was so popular and "good". (Also we all know the series ended at Cell because of low ratings in Japan, and it's actually being continued into Buu anyway.)
As for the Buu Saga power comparison thing: from my recent reading of the Buu Arc, Gohan is definitely the strongest non-fused being.
blarajan said:
Cell is the best arc, Buu is cool but Akira Toriyama didn't even want to write it...he was forced to. You can't really get mad at him for that.
This... is probably false. There is no indication that anyone compelled him to keep writing. Most of the rumors surrounding supposed intended endings are entirely false, or require huge stretches to believe given the evidence (and lack thereof). There was no apparent intention to end the series until it actually ended. (I guess you could argue Androids 19/20 but that's probably just an intention to end the arc, not the series.)
Outlaw said:
Also, Kai sucks for not including the good filler such as the car exams.
YES! The filler episodes get a lot of crap from being associated with the inter-episode padding but the filler episodes contain some of the best shit in the anime. The driving episode was great. Though fuck the Garlic Jr. filler arc <.<