Scum Reads:
As already posted - Duskfall seems to be just be lying low and reacting to what other players in the game are posting with half thought out posts or posts that are thought out but completely nonsensical and it doesn't seem town indicative really. Either dudes burnt out on mafia and needs a break, he's scum or both. no inbetweens.
Fen is scum and will be subbed out by day 4.
Heury - Every one of his posts feels like background noise which is bad when he actually seems to be trying to interact and push people. Either he's scum trying to figure out which angle to stick with, super, super low effort town or super new.
NAI reads:
Waterlily3 - more like where is lily 3 haha xd. fsr they seem to still be in early d1 mode and i'm not sure if I like that or not
Ampharos - Their content is good and coming out at a good rate but ngl their tone is giving off weird vibes that I can't get over.
This is one of the posts that struck me odd.
SoS - They're posting readlists but those readlists aren't actually giving me much information to go off of outside of basic thoughts on everyone. Kinda want to see him more insistent on pushing waterlily (or really just interacting with everyone more) here because he seems like background noise ngl
U-Turn Out - On one side I want to say both them and dusk are scum together but on the other that's way too fucking obvious and way too early to tell. Otherwise looks to be trying to contribute and seems tonally consistent. Really stuck on this first point here for them though.
Town Reads:
TBZ is town, and he will be subbed out by day 3.
Texas is making me smile and for this he gets a fancy shmancy day 1 pass (where he passes day 1 without a hitch)
Shubaka seems keen to keep day activity up and the content he does post is certainly interesting so far. Most of the read I have on him is tonally basically, but I'd like to see this aforementioned megapost he has in the works first before I give anything hard. I tentatively do write him down as a townlean.
Panic Station: He doesn't seem like background noise but lizard brain keeps looking at his avatar when I try to break down his posts. Most of the stuff he posts seems in-meta (he's KoC right?)
Yes:
CaffeineBoost was originally one of the townie(r/st) players in the game despite the low content, simply due to tone / meta. Last two pages though he seems to be reacting to readsonings posted by other players and trying to lean into them more (maybe so they think he's townier???) and the faux outrage is driving me up the wall. His original merit is still there so I actually feel super flipping flip floppy on the slot rn
Lynch Duskfall98
Side Note: can we not refer to Lol I'm Scum is Lolis it makes me think u guys are talkin bout some weird shit and threw me for a loop or two whilst backreading a bit