What do we even mean by brainless vs. skill-testing or whatever? I hear Melee players say that Melee is the most skill-intensive fighter because it has the highest actions per minute and the smallest frame windows for certain inputs. But Smash inputs are mostly memorized routines like wavedashing, shuffling, drill-shining, etc.; the improvisational portions of Melee have very large windows due the floaty physics and extremely long hitstun. So some "modern fighting game" enthusiasts say that BlazBlue is more skill-intensive because it requires more complex improvisation instead of just rehearsed, rapid inputs.
Isn't the test really whether the better player can consistently win? Like, two people who score the same on general reflex and hand-eye coordination tests, both of whom have played Street Fighter IV for 100 hours and BlazBlue for 100 hours, sit down to try out MvC3, sight-unseen. One guy plays for 50 hours, and the other plays for 100 hours. Will the 100 hours guy have a clear advantage? Will he win every single time, or nearly every single time? If he does win consistently, then by definition the game is not brainless, right?
Or maybe you're saying that MvC3 is like Soul Calibur 3, where you can teach your girlfriend Xiang-Hua's 5 best moves an hour before the tournament and she can win a round or two?