To start discussion I'd like to address the elephant in the room when it comes to offence teams. This was something that had been pointed out to me by
Blaine500 and I am happy to hear discussion on this topic.
Just because we have slowly shifted to a more offensive and "optimized" meta does not mean that, at least initially, some of our performances do not show a blindspot. As far as teambuilding is concerned, there is a trend that we are all aware of and it's that many
offence teams seem relatively ill-equipped for 2 particular threats.
Me getting harassed by a grammar bot that automatically promotes BKC 's spelling propaganda.
The first one, players seem to have caught wind of in recent years and either,
A) decided that building in a way that specifically counters it is too costly, or
B) decided that we can just play around. The second pokemon isn't something you can't be "prepared" against, but rather is able to take advantage of 2-4 members of a team by virtue of its typing and attacks. (I am speaking on behalf of high level play since most inexperienced players try to change their teams to face anything and everything that makes them feel uncomfortable).
:gs/Jynx: :gs/starmie:
Jynx is a powerhouse of a pokemon and perhaps deservedly one of the most threatening special attackers in the tier of GSC OU. It may not be as effective in certain scenarios as Gengar or Zapdos, but you may find yourself wondering if it's worth not putting on a team when you find that you've made space for a sweeper-like mon. The moveset I have in mind is one that has become synonymous with the pokemon itself and it really says a lot on how the metagame is affected by this off beat meta pick.
Jynx offensive set
item
Leftovers
Move 1: Lovely Kiss
Move 2: Ice Beam
Move 3: Psychic
Move 4: Substitute
You could have argued once that this poke was an anti-meta pick in 2018 or something since it seemed to counter many staple pokemon that aren't seeing as much usage, like Exeggutor or Marowak. But to say that Jynx's insurgence triggered the downfall of these two threats may be a bit of a stretch, especially if we consider how many more pokemon out there that are weak to it are still being used. Let's look at some calcs:
Damage no spdef drop
Jynx Ice Beam vs. Zapdos: 245-288 (63.9 - 75.1%) -- guaranteed 2HKO after Leftovers recovery
Ice Beam
Jynx Ice Beam vs. Nidoking: 272-320 (74.5 - 87.6%) -- guaranteed 2HKO after Leftovers recovery
Jynx Ice Beam vs. Golem: 296-348 (81.5 - 95.8%) -- 56.4% chance to OHKO after Spikes
Jynx Ice Beam vs. Steelix: 148-174 (41.9 - 49.2%) -- 20.8% chance to 2HKO after Spikes and Leftovers recovery
Pscychic
Jynx Psychic vs. Gengar: 256-302 (79.2 - 93.4%) -- guaranteed 2HKO after Leftovers recovery
Jynx Psychic vs. Machamp: 239-282 (62.4 - 73.6%) -- guaranteed 2HKO after Leftovers recovery
Jynx Psychic vs. Cloyster: 169-199 (55.7 - 65.6%) -- guaranteed 2HKO after Leftovers recovery
Jynx Psychic vs. Heracross: 224-264 (61.7 - 72.7%) -- guaranteed 2HKO after Leftovers recovery
With spdef drop
Jynx Ice Beam vs. -1 Raikou: 171-202 (44.6 - 52.7%) -- 85.6% chance to 2HKO after Spikes and Leftovers recovery
Jynx Ice Beam vs. -1 Zapdos: 374-440 (97.6 - 114.8%) -- 87.2% chance to OHKO
Jynx Ice Beam vs. -1 Snorlax: 161-190 (30.7 - 36.3%) -- guaranteed 4HKO after Leftovers recovery
Jynx Psychic vs. -1 Vaporeon: 169-199 (36.5 - 42.9%) -- 98.7% chance to 3HKO after Leftovers recovery
...
The offensive metagame's general weakness to Jynx's Psychic and Ice typing enables it more than other special attackers to fish for RNG based effects (Freeze or Spdef drop) or setup a substitute, even causing in certain cases a shift of the momentum in a teams favor when they otherwise might have been losing. Whether or not this is considered a competitive matchup, offence teams have to account for it, hence why I think it's interesting to point out. Unlike other special attackers, Jynx has a tendency to work well even in matchups where it shouldn't (it can reliably setup substitute and bombard a sleep talk lax or Raikou with the right sleep rolls, fish for freezes against it and other checks like Starmie or even put heal bell stall teams out of commision by using Lovely Kiss on Blissey). One of the other aspects that helps Jynx is that Dark types that should naturally counter Jynx, either can't find a place on a team due to competition or just don't work. Tyranitar being the obvious check to Jynx, fits on many teams, but I do not forsee the entire playerbase deciding to renounce Steelix or Golem or Rhydon there just to counter Jynx without first assessing the risk of Zapdos they are exposing themselves to. Tyranitar isn't immune to being put to sleep or being frozen either and, often times due to the slow pace of many normal resisting mons, can be whittled down to a point where a 3HKO is likely. Houndoom on the other hand has the problem of being less splashable and Umbreon can't do enough damage.
Jynx is so centralizing in today's meta, not only for the fact that
it's currently included in 4 of the recently updated sample teams, but its moveset is simply outstanding. There are other combinations of moves that work, including using Thief over Substitute, which 9/10 steals leftovers from two of the most powerful pokemon in the tier (Snorlax or Raikou or even Zapdos).
Now onto Starmie.
This one you might not have expected (If you did, congratulations! You are cool) because you conceived this pokemon as a
"strictly stall" pick, with a few minor exceptions. Starmie is arguably one of the best spinners in the meta and has a really good matchup against
spikers and spinners of all shapes and sizes. I think when someone looks at GSC OU Starmie, they forget how much of a threat it was in RBY and how
it's still among the higher echelon of special attacking powerhouses (just not quite the highest). Like Jynx it is surprisingly strong against Boom offence teams, but it's more for its ability to disrupt and the speed control than for hax (it's also probably superior to Jynx from a purely defensive standpoint).
I noticed that out of the 12 offence sample teams, 9 have more than 2 pokemon that are either weak to its STAB or are walled by it. Starmie also has access to some of the best coverage this metagame has to offer, if not the absolute best in all of old gens. It can learn Blizzard, Thunder, Ice Beam, Thunderbolt, Psychic, Surf and Hydro Pump, a movepool not many other pokemon can compete with. By comparison Gengar doesn't learn Ice Beam and Jynx doesn't learn Thunder and neither of these learn Hydro Pump.
Furthermore, Starmie's Water and Psychic typing play a much more defensive role against certain staples, like Machamp, Vaporeon, and, yes..., even Jynx. There is no doubt about how good it is on defensive teams but I believe it being written off as "stall teams only choice" is a great misuse of this wonderful toy!
With STAB water moves this Starmie acts as a check to Nidoking, Tyranitar, Golem, Steelix, Rhydon, Houndoom and Jynx and it just hits so many things neutrally. I found some moderate success with a team that was built on the GSC discord which included this particular set:
Death Star
Item: leftovers
Move 1: Hydro Pump
Move 2: Thunder Wave
Move 3: Psychic/ Blizzard
Move 4: Recover
Hydro Pump is a key move in that it can deal significant amounts of damage by virtue of the elevated base power, when compared to Surf. It has a 99.1% chance to actually 3HKO Zapdos if that says anything and with it you will never be afraid of being targetted by a Steelix trying to explode on it to clear the way for Machamp, because Steelix will be OHKO'd. A special shoutout to
Fear who innovatively inspired us with Nightmare substitute Starmie in SPL XI week 6. Personally I remembered Sulcata bringing it in GSC cup VI in 2020,
which he won, but that wasn't until the milkman had been pestered by our Greek hero in that famous SPL game. I guess the best path to victory is learning from a loss.
Here are a few replays which showcase its latent and unexplored power. (I will update this with some SPL replays).
https://replay.pokemonshowdown.com/gen2ou-1382817869-sou50cf5dhyi86dqwjja3ig8k442r94pw Psychic Starmie
https://replay.pokemonshowdown.com/gen2ou-1383164112-mgrv9k1hjabgef76mgq46n40lgems0mpw Blizzard Starmie
https://replay.pokemonshowdown.com/smogtours-gen2ou-474850 Fear vs Kratosmana SPL 11 week5 - tfw lastmon Zap is your Starmie
https://replay.pokemonshowdown.com/smogtours-gen2ou-475829 Fear vs Sulcata SPL 11 week 6 - Sub Nightmare Starmie
https://replay.pokemonshowdown.com/smogtours-gen2ou-545281 Fear vs Gorgie SPL 12 week 8 - TWO STARMIES
https://replay.pokemonshowdown.com/smogtours-gen2ou-505883 2 gsc cup games of Sulcata vs Tony Flygon with Nightmare Starmie, Golem and Forry.
https://replay.pokemonshowdown.com/smogtours-gen2ou-505903