trax said:If a small town business providing a non-essential service would actually continue to be supported by the local community despite knocking back the business of a demographic, what makes you think that town isn't already pretty much segregated?
Small town businesses basically live and die on local support and if the business is not essential and not supported it won't be around for long, if the entire community would be willing to support a business they don't need that doesn't serve a given group of people, then that's going to be a very inhospitable place for them to live regardless; finding work and socialising are both going to be very problematic and you can't really enforce those without coming up with thought crimes (which I'd fucking hope nobody supports).
A few businesses* have had a stack of money donated after they got sued, but do you legitimately think it's viable as an actual business strategy**, and do you think it could continue on a vastly larger scale? No fucking chance.
Indubitably, a place that decided, en masse, to stop serving blacks, or gays, or muslims, or any other societal group would be a hostile place to live for members of that group regardless if that segregation was legal at the time or not. However, you miss a critical point: I was citing a hypothetical, a situation where
absolutely no regulations existed. In that case, even essential services could be withheld; visitors to that town who were gay could entirely be denied any order of food, lodging, or anything else. In essence, I was trying to prove the need for regulations - even you seem to agree there is a distinction between "essential" and "nonessential" and that line is the one to be used in determining where segregation is acceptable. Thus, that town wouldn't only be a hostile place to live, it would be an impossible place to go for any offending minority. That's undesirable in a society.
az said:yeah, this was my main concern with the op ?_?
i thought it was just a case of you choosing a poor example, but looking at it it rly makes me wonder why anyone thought this law was necessary??
the premise of the law is: there is a federal law preventing discrimination. This Indiana law affords businesses the right to discriminate (and not serve) people based on the business's religious beliefs, nullifying the federal law, the Civil Rights Act. What people are disputing is the concept of mandatory non discrimination - I haven't seen an argument claiming the Indiana law is justified in undercutting the federal one given the Federal one is valid.