Heya, I've been experimenting with something for a PS Server I work on. It's almost all coded, but there's a lot of questions and such. I was told this would qualify as an OM rather than Pet Mod, so here I am!
Metagame Premise
:tauros: RBY Doubles :tauros:
Double Battles were first introduced in Pokemon Ruby and Sapphire, and alongside the mechanical changes, many moves already in previous generations were tweaked to work with this. I thought it would be interesting to see how RBY would work in a Doubles setting, given the massive differences in mechanics.
RBY makes for a fairly interesting game with a Doubles setting added. As such, there wouldn't be any slates or anything. In this OM, all moves that become spread moves in Gen 3 would regain those effects (Earthquake targets everyone, Blizzard targets both foes, etc). While many conventional strategies (Screens, Weather, etc) are removed, there's still quite a bit to look at. You have Super Fang Raticate who suddenly becomes amazing support, there are Thunder Wave and String Shot for speed control, hell Haze can become an interesting niche pick. Plus, Growl and Tail Whip can be used to exploit stat reapplication with Burns and Paralysis! This also helps make Mist a somewhat relevant choice to prevent statdrops from happening.
To remain faithful to the progression of Doubles as a battle format, I believe Gen 3 Doubles Mechanics are best.
- Pokemon switch out immediately after fainting.
- Spread move damage is reduced by 50% rather than 25%.
- Surf targets both opponents; allied Pokemon is unharmed.
These mechanics are also excellent for balancing out the terrifying spread moves of Gen 1 - Blizzard in particular - as well as encouraging smart, proactive switching. One interesting factor is that when a Pokemon faints, let's say after an unintended crit, you can strategically send a Pokemon in to absorb a Hyper Beam and force a recharge. These kinds of things are really cool.
In terms of ruleset, I'm thinking a standard Doubles OU ruleset applied to RBY is best.
- Sleep Clause: Limit one foe put to sleep.
- Freeze Clause: Limit one foe frozen.
- Species Clause: Limit one of each Pokémon.
- OHKO Clause: OHKO moves are banned.
- Evasion Moves Clause: Evasion moves are banned.
- Endless Battle Clause: Forcing endless battles is banned.
- This also comes with a Mewtwo and Mew ban, as well as RBY Desync Patches (Psywave, etc).
Potential bans and threats:
I'm 90% sure that partial trapping (Wrap, etc) would be banned for them disabling a Pokemon for many turns, allowing for some fairly obnoxious strategies. It feels like it would be very centralising, and from my testing, it has been. Sleep also seems a bit dumb, but Sleep Clause seems as if it would balance it out enough.
So some potential new threats...
:articuno: Articuno has the strongest Blizzard in the game, and it only gets better when it can hit both opponents with a chance to Freeze. Avoiding Earthquake and being incapable of becoming Frozen is a nice benefit too. I can see Articuno cleaning up games very well. It should look out for Rock Slide, though. It also gets Mist and is the fastest user of it.
:golduck: :slowbro: Golduck and Slowbro can become pretty interesting picks, as coupled with a Thunder Wave user, you can get a stat reapplication right off the bat, making for good speed control. The addition of a multi-targeting Surf also makes them threatening sweepers. I think either could be used in Doubles, as Golduck's Speed is enough to warrant consideration over Slowbro unlike in typical RBY OU.
:venusaur: Given Razor Leaf becomes a spread move in later generations, Venusaur and Victreebel would become pretty interesting. A spread move that almost always crits already sounds pretty great. I think Venusaur may edge it out for having higher speed, allowing for a faster Sleep option.
:raticate: Being the only Super Fang user in a pretty bulky format, Raticate sounds as though it would be a pretty good support pick. It's got fairly decent Speed to benefit this, though it's frail as hell and would likely crumble to something like Starmie.
:vaporeon: Multi-targeting Haze sounds interesting enough to consider Vaporeon. It's not as strong as something like Lapras or Starmie though, so I'm not sure if it would be a staple or anything. It's also one of the few Pokemon to get Mist, along with Articuno and Lapras, so that's a potential niche there too.
:butterfree: Butterfree and Beedrill are the only fully evolved Pokemon to get String Shot, which would lower both opponent's Speed by 1 stage given the rules I'm putting forward (use Gen 1 effects, but multi-targeting from later gens). This gives them a minor niche in the Speed control department. Bubble could see minor use from Blastoise, Seadra, Poliwrath or Kingler, but I don't think it'd be justifiable over something like Thunder Wave.
I think some regular OU staples would become worse, though.
:rhydon: While it gains multi-targeting STABs and has the best Earthquake in the game, I don't think Rhydon would hold up too well given Surf and Blizzard are likely going to be everywhere. Gang attacking also seems like a pressing issue. I can see it being used to stop Thunder Wave though, which I think will be quite common.
:gengar: Earthquake is likely to see a lot of play as it does in later generations, and since Gengar can't float, I think it'll face some pretty tough competition. It's not exactly frail on the special side in RBY though, so it may be able to stand up and fight.
Questions for the community:
- Well, would you play it? I'm of the understanding that RBY is generally seen in a poor light by a lot of newer fans of the game, and that's fine, I'm open to all criticism on all fronts.
- Do you think partial trapping should be banned in something like this? From what I've seen it's pretty damn powerful. It's effectively the same as freezing or sleeping a Pokemon in this format, given what you can do with the partner thereafter. Not to mention the pivoting potential.
- What do you think of Sleep? Taking a turn to wake up, as well as the potential to go like 6 turns without a move seems as if it would be a problem. However, Sleep Clause significantly tones down its potential for devastation.
- Explosion seems really broken since an ally's Substitute can be used to make them live. This makes Electrode+Snorlax a pretty scary threat to many teams.
Here are some test replays from when I was tinkering with the format on RBY 2k20's PS Server earlier. Feel free to tell me what you think, but note that they are a bit buggy with spread moves.
Test Replays (Warning, quite buggy!)