Alright my analysis on Hoopa-Unbound:
Reasons it should be banned:
Reasons
1. It gets so much coverage! That's covered later.
2. The item it hold impacts the dynamic of countering Hoopa-U, sometimes needing to sac a mon to see if it is scarf or band (for example).
3. As I said in reason 2, this thing is just plain out versatile, being able to be a wallbreaker or a cleanup mon.
4. It gives Psychic a Dark/Ghost switchin and it gives Dark a Fighting switchin (even though it cant really live 2 CCs from anything).
Reasons it should
not be banned:
Reasons
1. It has terrible defense and most priority is defensive.
2. It dies to almost every U-turn, which is one of the most common moves in the game (and also one of the best).
3. Without a Choice Scarf, it is slow af and once again dies to any physical STAB move from a decent wallbreaker.
My Opinion: Well Hoopa-U does have subpar defense, however that can easily be mitigated via other pokemon. U-turn is a huge threat to the type anyway so I think that is a decent reason (even though yes it can be somewhat mitigated). However overall I think its Pros outweigh its Cons by a longshot. With Band/LO it can sweep lots of Balance/Stall teams with ease. Choice Scarf can put an end to alot of megas and HO teams.
While I understand this cannot be like Aegislash and we havve to globally ban it or not ban it at all, I'd just like to say that Hoopa-U is helps out Psychic alot more than it helps Dark. It can take Dark pulses/Shadow balls with ease, while only really being able to take Focus Blast for Dark. Also, for Psychic Dark coverage is alot more useful (to beat types like Ghost and mirror matches) then for Dark when Psychic can only really be used to beat fighting (but its not really a switchin its just a check).
Also, It can be used a
special or physical attacker or even mixed which is very dangerous.
Physical Coverage Moves
Drain Punch - beats Dark and Steel types that may beat Hoopa (example: Tyranitar)
Fire Punch - Once again it can beat Steel types (example: Ferrothorn)
Gunk Shot - It can beat fairies (example: Azumarill)
Hyperspace Fury - STAB
Ice Punch - It can beat Dragons (example: Garchomp)
Knock Off - Mitigates threats like Chansey/P2
Thunder Punch - Nice way to beat water types (example: Gyarados)
Zen Headbutt - STAB
Special Coverage Moves
Charge Beam/Thunderbolt - beats water types (example: Gyarados)
Dark Pulse - STAB
Energy Ball - beats water/ground types (example: Swampert)
Focus Blast - beats dark types (example: Tyranitar)
Grass Knot is quite subpar to Energy Ball
Hyperspace Hole - STAB
Shadow Ball - Sort of pointless but its still cool.
Signal Beam - A really cool way to beat other Hoopa-U
Hidden Powers [Fire, Ice]
Status Moves
Calm Mind - Good counter to Electric (I guess)
Destiny Bond
Guard Split - gimmicks?
Magic Coat
Nasty Plot - Nice way to wall break
Reflect/Light Screen - Time to setup Dual Screens
Thunder Wave
Toxic
Trick
Trick Room
Substitute
How to beat It
Just a heads up, these are examples. I have Gyarados here because it can take a thunderbolt nicely after mega evolving and can ddance/ohko. I don't have Skarmory though because this is assuming you don't know if hes physical or special or even mixed.
Flying - Scarf Landorus-Therian, Scarf Togekiss, Mega-Charizard-Y, Gyarados-Mega
Psychic - Scarf Jirachi, Gardevoir-Mega, Scarf Victini, Other Hoopas?
Fighting - Gallade-Mega, Medicham-Mega, Sash Breloom, Scarf Heracross, Cobalion
Water - Gyarados-Mega, Azumarill, Cloyster (Sash), Mega-Swampert in Rain
Steel - Skarmory, Klefki, Scarf Excadrill - Hoopa is really scary for Steel...
Dragon - Scarf Kyurem-Black, Garchomp, Mega-Latias/Hydreigon core to scout moveset
Dark - Mandibuzz, Sableye-Mega, Weavile, Hoopa...? (If you know he isn't running Drain Punch/Fmiss almost everything walls Hoopa)
Bug - Scarf Heracross, Yanmega, Scolipede, Bulky Volcarona, Pinsir-Mega
Poison - Skuntank/Drapion - or hope hes not running Psychic coverage
Fire - Mega-Charizard-Y, Scarf Victini, Torkoal, Bulky Arcanine, Bulky Volcarona
Ground - Hippowdon, Sand Rush Excadrill, Scarf Landorus-Therian, Mamoswine, Garchomp (mega)
Normal - Staraptor, Chansey, P2, Ditto?, Lopunny-Mega - hope hes not running knock off and for Lopunny hope hes not running naive/hasty etc.
Ghost - Um...Mega-Sableye, uh...Scarf Gengar, Aegislash...really hope hes not special nasty plot sub.
Fairy - Azumarill, Mega-Diancie, Scarf Togekiss, Clefable, Scarf Gardevoir
Electric - Thundurus, Rotom-W, Zapdos
Rock - Shuckle, Mega-Diancie, Mega-Aggron, Scarf Terrakion
Grass - Whimsicott, Sash Breloom, Cradily, Ferrothorn...?
Ice - Scarf Kyurem-Black, Avalugg (hope not special), Weavile, Mamoswine, Cloyster, Piloswine
Of course there are more...but those are just a few. However when you look at all them, most of them hope on Hoopa not having some coverage move or not being physical/special.
On a Scale of 1-10 how much do I want to ban this: 8
EienSeiryuu said:I've always believed that Hoopa-U is an incredibly powerful Pokemon, but I'm very wary of giving it a global ban. I won't argue its presence on Psychic. The versatility it brings to the team is unparalleled. It ruins many matchups, primarily the Psychic mirror and the Ghost matchups. It has unpredictability on its side, to make matters worse.
That being said, I feel removing it from Dark is a mistake. Let's consider what roles Hoopa-U can play on a Dark team. Unlike Psychic, Dark fails to have a good selection for speed control. Sucker Punch, while immensely powerful and a form of speed control of its own, is woefully unreliable. Further, it's resisted by Dark's weak matchups, matchups Hoopa-U comes in to save the day, such as Fighting and Fairy.
As an alternative Choice Scarf user, Dark has... Krookodile, Hydreigon, Honchkrow, and Tyranitar. All of these simply lack the coverage that Hoopa-U can provide. Where Honchkrow can pretty much always get a safe kill versus Fighting, it fails to have similar effectiveness against Fairy, a type that Dark struggles against and that Hoopa-U previously checked. Honchkrow also very much enjoys being able to switch between moves and has access to Sucker Punch, resulting in Choice Scarf being a rather undesirable set to run (Not even mentioning its absolutely atrocious speed tier, only being able to speed tie while holding a Choice Scarf against Speed 115 Pokemon).
Hydreigon might be useful versus Fairy, as it can carry Flash Cannon, importantly outspeeds Choice Scarf Gardevoir, and has a resistance against Azumarill's Aqua Jet. The unfortunate reality for Hydreigon is that it's simply too weak. Even against the aforementioned Gardevoir, outspeeding it has little benefits when Gardevoir simply lives any attack and kills it outright in return. In general, even, Hydreigon fails to provide the firepower that Honchkrow or Hoopa-U can. Hydreigon relies heavily on its impressive coverage and heavily on items like Life Orb or Expert Belt to bolster its poor offenses.
Krookodile is a third option, that has access to Moxie to potentially threaten unprepared teams. But unfortunately, Krookodile's coverage is severely limited. Its one saving grace is the ability to threaten out Fairy team that lost Togekiss after a +1 Moxie boost. Other than that, it fails to do anything meaningful versus Fighting, and drops to priority of pretty much any form.
The final Choice Scarf user I mentioned was Tyranitar. It's just not possible on Dark to run Choice Scarf Tyranitar. Its role as a reliable Stealth Rock setter, Special Defense wall, and general utility provider (with moves like Fire Blast, Pursuit, Thunder Wave) just cannot be replaced without severe costs. And if one truly wanted to run Choice Scarf Tyranitar, its speed still has so much to ask for and it doesn't provide the coverage or power Hoopa-U did.
This is all just talking about the hole Dark would have to fill because it loses its premier Choice Scarf user. Consider the matchups Dark suddenly becomes very pressed to defeat. Fighting becomes even more oppressive, as Hoopa-U is the key to taking out threats against the Dark team. With the support of Mandibuzz and Sableye, Hoopa-U was the backbone of the offense in Dark. No Pokemon can replace it, as Honchkrow suffers from crippling speed (It's slower than every common Fighting Pokemon except for Conkeldurr, as Breloom outspeeds the Adamant Honchkrow) and its Sucker Punch simply doesn't do the damage necessary due to the type disadvantage. Hydreigon has the mild benefit of having a Dragon typing, making it able to check Keldeo... except that Hydreigon can't actually kill Keldeo without a Life Orb, which is going back to the Choice Scarf issue and the role compression Hoopa-U provides. Without recovery, Hydreigon can only come in against Keldeo so many times before it eventually dies. Fighting really won't be threatened by any Pokemon that replaces Hoopa-U. Speaking of Keldeo, without the support of Hoopa-U's Choice Scarf Hyperspace Hole, a Substitute-Calm Mind Keldeo will walk right through any Dark team (This can be extrapolated to all other Sub users, as the Hyperspace moves are critical to defeating them).
Also consider Fairy, which Hoopa-U could combat with an incredibly powerful Gunk Shot. Fairy already is a cripplingly bad matchup, and to lose its only real way of winning is absolutely devastating. What Pokemon can possibly replace that Gunk Shot? Pangoro, which dies to any Fairy move provided by even a completely uninvested Whimsicott (Moonblast) or Klefki (Play Rough)? Bisharp is the other key to Dark's victory, but fails to be able to reliably take out either of Fairy's Mega-evolution options (Diancie must be caught on the switch, which will never happen, and Gardevoir can be difficult to defeat vs. Will-o-Wisp or Substitute variants) or anything faster than it without 2 or 3 Swords Dances to boost the resisted Sucker Punch.
Consider its position as a revenge killer. What exactly will replace it? It's a 284 Choice Scarf boosted Speed Pokemon that has immense coverage coming from base 160 Attack and base 170 Special Attack. Will Dark use a Life Orb Weavile, which is weaker, slower, and has no coverage at all? The aforementioned Choice Scarf users all have their pitfalls as revenge killers who rely heavily on Life Orb to eke out those crucial kills and thus will be prohibitively slow.
I haven't even discussed the other type matchups, where Hoopa-U is a premium wallbreaker in. This would be for example Electric's Zapdos/Rotom-W core, Grass/Poison's Mega-Venusaur that simply won't die anymore, Flying's already difficult to break Skarmory/Zapdos core, and Stall Water's core in general. Dark absolutely needs Hoopa-U because as it stands, it won't stand a chance without it.
So I'll conclude by asking you: is banning Hoopa-U from Psychic so absolutely important to us, that we are willing to cripple Dark completely?
Well to an extent it might crush Dark but people will find out a way eventually. Also, how come we don't have per say Talonflame on Fire, Skymin on Grass, Kyurem-White on Ice?
Talonflame was banned because of its existence on Flying and making it more overpowered than it was. Same with Skymin. Kyurem-White would destroy everything on Dragon. So what the difference? If we don't ban, Hoopa-U will keep destroying everything on Psychic...
this is very opinion based and I hate psychic