Stunt said:Ok. Roobushin is definitely bulky enough to take a hit from a +2 sp attack surf octillery and can break octillerys sub with drain punch (even when its +2 defense). Bulk up on the protect
then mach punch would OHKO octillery (assuming iron fist) . This is on my octillery which has 160 defense evs bold.
Now you guys continue to talk about surf flamethrower octillery, then I can talk about burungeru with psych up. Taunt can prevent further protect and subbing. Boil Over and Shadow Ball for Dual stabs.
You guys talk like bullet seed breloom is going to miss.
Again, even if they get a speed boost, that means they did not get an sp attack boost on the switch or maybe they lost some defense. Then breloom can mach punch them.
And smeargle as a lead with sub and not focus sash is risky because it will lose to any strong and fast lead.
Here is a brief typed out example of how roobushin works:
Lets say I have bullet punch band scizor out and I revenge a pokemon.
They send out octillery.
On the switch to roobushin, they sub.
lets say a +2 evasion / sp attack happens here and they have to lose speed/sp def/ accuracy/defense/attack.
if octillery gets minus speed, then roobushin will be faster. if it gets minus accuracy it has a chance to miss. if it gets minus defense roobushin can drain punch mach punch kill it . Octillery will protect if it gets bad boosts and attack if it gets good boosts.
Assuming sp attack, they will attack, but surf wont OHKO even with +2 252 sp atk (timid nature) . since sp attack is up, evasion cant be up at the time, so drain punch will hit, sub gone. Mach punch to get a hit (there is a 2/7 chance that there defenses are down now). Even if their defenses are up, most octillery sets like the one shown on the first page of this thread, do not invest in defense. Roobushin can mach punch to deal direct damage to octillery, and they will not be able to make another Substitute.
First of all, I hope you all have ACTUALLY used any of the counters forementioned before arguing against them.
The pokemon I mentioned can counter with standard sets they use and are on the top of the tier usage charts, meaning they are used in teams not trying to counter this ability
I can't argue with all this , "what if it misses" stuff because the odds are with you instead of against. I think +2 evasion is easier to hit then snow veil with bright powder... why dont you people ban that?
Octillery is faster than Roopushin still even without +2 speed. +2 Surf is an ohko on Max hp/min SDef. With +2 Def, Mach Punch (without Guts/Bulk Up) does less than 20% min/min and you don't want to be taking +2 SAtk. Vrs +2 Def, there is no way a Mach Punch ohkoes Octillery with Iron Fist even with Bulk Up. Bulk Up Guts, maybe if it doesn't have the Def+2, but not with +2. They could outsmart Bulk Up on the Protect (because it does get predictable) and attack you and it 2 potentially 2 hit koes (will with burn max/min) and it does a hell of a lot of damage to even special defensive (after +2 it does 2 hit ko).
Oh no, with Inconsistent, the odds are always favorably in the Inconsistent user, even with the -Drops (unless they come at the wrong time). Short of getting the wrong boosts (and or drops) at the wrong time, Inconsistent will always be in their favor. The whole luck happiness of it is why it's getting banned. While it isn't banned yet, the likelyhood is probably 99.9999999999999999999999999999999999999999% (I exaggerate but it probably is) in favor of it going away. When counters rely on luck and are destroyed if it gets the right boost, then it is going to go, simple as that. You could have all the counters and it could still win with luck. That's how terrible it is.
And your example is relying on them getting a bad minus (special attack, etc). If they don't (minus attack for example or minus accuracy but they still hit) what are you going to do? Relying on luck to win is not countering the thing itself.
Why would it run Timid? I'm calculating 252 SAtk MODEST. Burungeru is never going to use Psych Up (well it could but it is a waste of a move and will die to Toxic Spikes). Also, I think you're calculating the probability of a bad stat drop going down wrong (1/7+1/7 I don't think is the right formula). If it's +2 SAtk, it'll lose sub and ko Roopushin (or just kill it without losing sub which deserves a laugh).