• Check out the relaunch of our general collection, with classic designs and new ones by our very own Pissog!

Mythology Mafia - Day 3

StevenSnype said:
Also, the Ganesha claim, like any other PM, could easily be forged, which is why I am doubting to claim to you; any posting restriction could be faked.
Click to expand...

The odds of me faking this are highly unlikely, as my claim post was approximately 8 minutes after I received my role PM, meaning the window of time for creating a suitable fake was very low. As such, that is almost certainly my role and role name. However, there is no way of cleaning me other than an inspection, so I urge the village inspector to claim to me. I realise this is something a mafia would do, but it's the best option for cleaning me.
 
iiMKUltra said:
The odds of me faking this are highly unlikely, as my claim post was approximately 8 minutes after I received my role PM, meaning the window of time for creating a suitable fake was very low. As such, that is almost certainly my role and role name. However, there is no way of cleaning me other than an inspection, so I urge the village inspector to claim to me. I realise this is something a mafia would do, but it's the best option for cleaning me.
Click to expand...

Proof that it was approx. 8 minutes? I got my role approx 3-4 days ago (to lazy to check). That's plenty of time to fake a role and make an announcement, so unless i see it, i'm not believing it.

someone else needs to lead, this claim is troubling me.
 
Obviously I can't screenshot it, but I got my PM at 3:10 PM and posted (on page 1, starting with "Gentlemen, it is decided" at 3:18 PM. There was an edit at approx. 7:00 PM saying "I can't believe I forgot to lynch Spiffy."

So yeah, 8 minutes.
 
those 8 minutes don't really mean much, you could have just posted that and made the fake until afterward just to look more believable and use that to your favor, like you're doing right now.
 
I can't deny I'm being fairly forceful, but an unorganised village is mafia-bait.

In addition, I would like the one named Humbaba to contact me as soon as possible.
 
<iiMKUltra> bagman:
<iiMKUltra> the ganesha claim doesn't have a picture in it
<iiMKUltra> the picture is above the part saying "dear iiMKUltra"
<iiMKUltra> i put the picture there
 
Double posting shamelessly.

Lynch Hitmonchan

He claimed a role very unlikely to be on the village, his PM wasn't forwarded and contained a picture. He is our best bet for a lynch right now, but if he wants to contact me on irc, I urge him to do so.
 
I do not buy the fact that iiMKUltra put the picture in the claim by accident. Most likely he put the picture there just in case other people's role pm have pictures. This means that he is part of a minority that does not know what the role pm of the majority(the villagers) look like. That is the only reason i can think of as to why he decided to put a picture in his announcer message.

At the same time, iiMUltra did not forward us his role pm as well, but is accusing Hitmonchan of not forwarding his own, using that as a reason to lynch Hitmonchan.

For all the lack of reason that he has exhibited, lynch iiMKUltra.

I would retract my accusations as long as iiMKUltra gives valid reasons for his actions. If not, my stand does not falter. Of course if we decide that he is to be the villager leader(which i very much hope not), i would respect the decision and take down the lynch vote.

Edit: I do not condone the lynching of Hitmonchan now since iiMKUltra has decided to show us the PM.
 
icantseewhy said:
I do not buy the fact that iiMKUltra put the picture in the claim by accident. Most likely he put the picture there just in case other people's role pm have pictures. This means that he is part of a minority that does not know what the role pm of the majority(the villagers) look like. That is the only reason i can think of as to why he decided to put a picture in his announcer message.

At the same time, iiMUltra did not forward us his role pm as well, but is accusing Hitmonchan of not forwarding his own, using that as a reason to lynch Hitmonchan.

For all the lack of reason that he has exhibited, lynch iiMKUltra.

I would retract my accusations as long as iiMKUltra gives valid reasons for his actions. If not, my stand does not falter. Of course if we decide that he is to be the villager leader(which i very much hope not), i would respect the decision and take down the lynch vote.
Click to expand...

I have asked him to forward his role pm to me, but he refused, seemingly without reason. I'm actually quite suspicious.
 
Firstly, the picture isn't in the pm. It's above it. Secondly, why on earth would I need to forward my pm to anyone? It's in the thread for the whole world to see. I'll send it to anyone if you like, but I really don't see the point. Raikage has confirmed to me that no role pms were sent out with pictures. If the picute was in the pm, it would be between "dear iiMKUltra, you are Ganesha" and the next paragraph. It is above both that and the first elephant noise and is thus outside of the role pm.
 
I want to see an example of iiMKUltra making a decision: what role was it which Hitmonchan claimed? Can we see his PM? Also, if he were putting the picture in a fake PM, he would have put it where the examples are in the OP. He did not. It also clearly says that there are no pictures in the PMs.

EDIT: It is getting a bit ridiculous how many people are dropping out of this.
 
Because of a bit of doubt in our minds, here is exactly what Hitmonchan sent me, minus the night action.

Hitmonchan said:
Dear Hitmonchan,

You are Selene.


Sister of Helios, and of Eos, you are the goddess of the moon. You are said to travel the world at night, pulling the moon, and illuminating it with you crown. You were also believed to be incredibly fertile, according to some source which say you mothered up to 60 daughters.

<snip>

You win if Raikage's Minions win.
Click to expand...

Notice: the picture, the multitude of grammatical errors (while these don't prove anything, they certainly don't help) and the fact is was posted by Hitmonchan, not by Raikage. It was also not forwarded to me, and with the title of "Role PM" rather than "Mythology" as mine was. If it even matters, there were around nine and a half hours between the update and Hitmonchan's claim.

I have removed the night action as if he is village, having the whole mafia know exactly what he is ruins any chance of him coming back and explaining himself.
 
[09:50] <rare> so are we ok to vote?
[09:50] <Life> The things people believe...
[09:51] <iiMKUltra> yeah, i'd say

vote hitmonchan

i'm not saying i trust iiMKUltra yet, its just that the guys pm is a painfully obvious fake, and he hasn't defended himself in any way yet.
 
5 bucks says that Hitmonchan won't come back to play another game of Mafia.

Hitmonchan, if you do read this, know this. Everyone makes stupid mistakes all the time and all you have to do is make sure that you don't make the same ones again next game.

Vote Hitmonchan.
 
Vote Hitmonchan

Would've voted earlier but I thought the day got skipped or something from the thread title.

Hitmonchan's not a bad villager, he pretty much won the first game of mafia I played on n0 or n1.
 
You must log in or register to reply here.
Back
Top