NOC New World NOC - GAME OVER

[HeaLnDeaL]

Glad to come back to this game and still see that it hasn't developed any further.

Can someone please tell me logically why Hannah would be a better lynch that Former? What are the arguments for not lynching Former? He's made questionable reads this whole game in between a ton of fluff, zero-content posts.

Also, on a sidenote, do we think it's 4 mafia 7 town? Because it's killing me to even guess 6 of my fellow townies.

I would tag JALMONT again but he's consistently shown he has zero interest in actually posting, so how about Whydon?

 

[HeaLnDeaL]

MoodyCloud

 

[Former]

actually forget that this post screams town

/unvote

I'd disagree, an activity post is a really cheap way to generate content and seem active, without actually doing things. Having played a few scum games with M2H recently, I think it's something he would do as either alignment.

 

[Former]

It could be 4p, but 3p is probably as likely. It all depends on the distribution of power roles imo.

Also heal, a word of advice. You are the kind of townie mafia are going to drag to the end of the game because they feel like you'll give them a mislynch. Be more adaptable on your reads and reevaluate them.

 

[Former]

That said, deadline is soon. At this point I still maintain that inferno is the best lynch, but given the lack of town cohesion, it may be best to just no lynch and let any cop role do their thing

 

[InfernoDragon]

I'm good for a lynch on either Former or Hannah at this point. Both Heal and M2H are at least leaning town for me, and Energy just confuses me at the moment. I think Former is a pretty solid scum read mainly based upon how weird many of his reads are. I don't see how Lily could be read much at all at this point given that they have said virtually nothing out of RVS, and Energy's tunnel on someone who seems pretty definitively towny makes it weird to think he is a locked town read. I don't see these reads coming out of an actual drive to scumhunt -they seem much more like a distraction made by a scum member protecting himslef

 

[Samoyed]

Votecount 1

HeaLnDeaL- 2 (Energy, Waterlily)
No Lynch - 1 (Former)
Hannahh - 1 (M2H)
Former - 1 (HeaLnDeal)
Inferno - 1 (The_Caporegime)

 

[JALMONT]

Anyone have any good video game recommendations? Preferably playable on ps4 but pc works too

 

[Samoyed]

Anyone have any good video game recommendations? Preferably playable on ps4 but pc works too

Nier Automata, I hear it’s 33% off on Steam right now

 

[Former]

unvote, vote inferno

yeah, that's a scum post

 

[JALMONT]

Nier Automata, I hear it’s 33% off on Steam right now

-__-

 

[M2H]

meh it definitely is worse than his earlier posts.

 

[M2H]

lemme go check EiMM for town!inferno meta

 

[Former]

1. He over explains, but doesnt try to persuade. In other words he's preemptively trying to justify his reason for scum reading someone he knows is town

2. He does all that. Without placing a vote. Something that comes from a scum mindset

3. His actual reasons are just awful and relies on ridiculous logic like "only scum tunnel" or "you cant deduce someone's alignment from a few posts " neither of which is true

 

[InfernoDragon]

lemme go check EiMM for town!inferno meta

Actually I haven't played a game on EiMM

 

[Former]

Energy WaterLily3 I need yall to join me on inferno

 

[InfernoDragon]

1. He over explains, but doesnt try to persuade. In other words he's preemptively trying to justify his reason for scum reading someone he knows is town

2. He does all that. Without placing a vote. Something that comes from a scum mindset

3. His actual reasons are just awful and relies on ridiculous logic like "only scum tunnel" or "you cant deduce someone's alignment from a few posts " neither of which is true

former if you read over any of my previous games you will see that what you outlined in points 1 and 2 is just pretty standard for me in any game I play - I don't vote until late when I am certain about a read, and I explain a lot. Take a look at Lover's Dance if you want to see what I am talking about

 

[M2H]

Actually I haven't played a game on EiMM

no mayor mafia its the last noc you played iirc

 

[InfernoDragon]

mayor mafia was the last one I played yep. Also I just realized how close to deadline it is and I’m not going to be on for the next hour so vote former

 

[Former]

InfernoDragon you're going to be lynched today, so if you're leaving, please claim now

 

[Former]

or at least claim PR/Vanilla

 

[JALMONT]

unvote, vote inferno

yeah, that's a scum post

Unvote right now this ain’t it

 

[Former]

Read through lovers dance https://www.smogon.com/forums/threa...ame-over-scum-win.3643212/page-6#post-7952275

Inferno's tone is very different that game from this one. So I'm happy with my push.

 

[Former]

View attachment 187948

Unvote right now this ain’t it

I'm pretty confidant it is. I also prefer it next to voting M2H/no lynch. But I could be persuaded to no lynch.

 

[M2H]

InfernoDragon you're going to be lynched today, so if you're leaving, please claim now

this is the type of stuff that I can't tr you for.

across our oc games I realized that I can't read you at all on what you say or how you say it but on what you are doing
and honestly trying to strongarm inferno into claiming when he isnt even the lead wagon rn is bad imo. You refused to explain your scum read on me which honestly just came across as omgus to me and a way to intimidate me away from pushing you. You honestly come across like you're power-scumming right now.

Pushing a no lynch is also just objectively a bad idea imo, and I kinda have to think town!former knows better than that. When there are an excess of null/inactive slots idt its ever a good idea to just not lynch.