I am in favor of dragalge being suspected. Here's why:
-
It has no good switch ins/counters. Of course it has pokemon immune to dragon and poison, but because of its great offensive typing and excellent coverage move pool with focus blast it can usually just finish the switch ins of with sludge wave, draco, focus blast, etc. Keep in mind that most of said switch ins (slurpuff, klinklang, etc.) cannot kill dragalge in one hit without a boost, meaning they will ultimately die to one of dragalge's coverage moves. The only reliable and decent counter, metang, simply doesn't work too well against the rest of the meta, and so far no one has found any other reliable counter and switch in that can actually deal with dragalge. Don't confuse this with it's checks, I know it has a lot because of its speed, but they're called checks for a reason; They can't take a hit so they have to always come in on a safe turn.
-
Great bulk and typing. If dragalge was ice rock, then it wouldn't be so bad, but no, it has an excellent typing both defensively and offensively which grants it near perfect coverage (especially in NU) and makes it take neutral from fairies, meaning slurpuff won't be able to switch in on a draco meteor and kill it. It's bulk is also very decent, it has the special bulk to take many hits and then immediately kill what's trying to hit it afterwards and its bulk allows it to beat mega sceptile 1v1. It also serves as a fire spam check, which doesn't make it ban worthy, but means it checks one of the best offensive pokemon in the tier, typhlosion.
-
What is going to happen if slurpuff and altaria are banned? If these two were to be banned, it wont have anything keeping it from running specs, meaning it can freely wallbreak even better than the dragon fang set because there are not offensively threatening limitations to it's armada. The only reason the fang set is run is because of these two (and mega audino, which is not hard to stop compared to puff and altaria), and once they are gone, this thing can freely bomb the whole of NU without nothing to check or at least limit its offensive capabilities. Of course the specs set requires more predictions and is not as safe, but the trade off for extra damage is well worth it when you OHKO and 2HKO almost the entire meta.
-
Hardly needs support. Dragalge has excellent synergy with most of the pokemon in NU, and requires no support to run effectively. It doesn't care too much about hazards and doesn't really require any of it's counters to be taken care of because there are almost none anyway. Thus, once this thing is out freely on the field to drop a nuke, there's not much that can come in and stop it without dying. It is extremely independent and can switch in on many hits because of its bulk and typing without the need for support from its teammates. It also forms really solid cores with a lot of threats in the tier on both balance and hyper offense, and even stall.
Those are just my thoughts on why Dragalge needs a ban eventually. Right now, I think it's bearable, but still slightly overpowered. Later on in the meta, especially if the fairies leave, It will be even more insane and thus I think it is worthy of a ban. I tried to do this without comparing it to any pokemon, so bear with me if some of my points are lacking a little. Here are some calcs to support my above arguments:
calcs
252+ SpA Dragalge Focus Blast vs. 4 HP / 0 SpD Klinklang: 270-318 (103 - 121.3%) -- guaranteed OHKO
-2 252+ SpA Adaptability Dragalge Sludge Wave vs. 0 HP / 0 SpD Slurpuff: 240-284 (78.6 - 93.1%) -- guaranteed 2HKO
252+ SpA Adaptability Dragalge Sludge Wave vs. 0 HP / 0 SpD Altaria: 360-424 (123.7 - 145.7%) -- guaranteed OHKO
252+ Atk Pixilate Altaria Return vs. 0 HP / 4 Def Dragalge: 231-273 (85.2 - 100.7%) -- 6.3% chance to OHKO
All in all, once the other megas' fate has been decided, I think this this is definitely
worthy of a ban. Great typing defensively and offensively, great bulk meaning it desn't necessarily need speed, the ability to OHKO and 2HKO almost the entire tier and the fact that it has no decent counters right now is why I think it deserves to be tested. Also, in the long run I think this thing will become even more of a threat when other pokemon leave NU.
I understand that against offense it isn't very good, but it's mons like this that make stall virtually unplayable which is really unbalanced.