Tried to reply to all the defensive suspect themed posts that had content worth debating in them. Ignored a few posts by people with sub-100 posts who clearly think I posted that because I can't beat Milotic or something, might wanna "lurk more," friends.
I'd sooner nominate Registeel. That thing just sits there and paralyzes everything.
Registeel had been my first thought too, since it's such a bandaid counter for most teams both offensive and defensive. Both it and Milotic just get thrown onto teams willy nilly since they both counter about half the metagame without any sort of intelligent team support at all. I don't really care about how the work on offensively incline teams, but it irritates me much they boost stall. With that playstyle so much of the game is team matchups (or I guess more precisely, the opponent not having the right Pokemon to break the stall), and it's that much easier - I think, too much easier - to make sure that occurs when both of those Pokemon blanket counter half the game.
While banning Milotic would definitely weaken stall, it would also deliver a crushing blow to balance and some bulky offense since Milo is such a multi purpose wall. And while it certainly walls a ton of pokemon, Im not sure how broken it is since it has tons and tons of checks and counters, and it would be difficult to convince voters, Jabba & Reachzero (we still havent gotten Froslass banned, which should be tons easier than Milotic). Although Milotic has been nominated a couple of times before, nothing ever came of it.
All about who's nominating it, I think.
Though the fact it would hurt every style is kind of a sign itself, I think. It kinda sends up red flags with me when any Pokemon is fitting well on every style of play - at that point it's less because it's the right Pokemon, and more because it's the best Pokemon.
Man, you should have seen some of the semifinals tour matches. Everyone packed a bunch of Ghosts to make sure their Spikes stayed up and proceeded to just annoy the shit out of your team. I got a taste of that last week, but the influx of UU newbies is diminishing my frustration.
There was plenty of stall, for sure, though they weren't all that ghost heavy. IPL won with hail stall, AM won with his stall team (which I believe is only one ghost, does feature Milotic, and has comedy Foresight rapid spin) which about four other people were also using, one of whom got to the semis Saturday. Loki's team is pretty slowly based too, though I'm not sure I'd consider it stall...
Trying to think back to what people were using in the semis. Obviously all the above users were there... Meowth was one of the few who were using legit offense teams, HR.'s team is pretty fast, and two of the three round robin finalists Friday were using rain (though I would have used my current team if I'd had it then).
Stalking some friends the Sunday/late Saturday and through my own path Friday and Saturday stall was the only thing that really stood out to me, so I agree on that end - it's just everywhere. It didn't bother me to the point I couldn't beat it (I made a couple really stupid mistakes in the finals Friday vs. AM in addition to being outpredicted a few times, and Rain vs. Loki Saturday just wasn't going to work), but it was enough that I think weakening a couple of the pivots would be good for th egame.
Its been brought up in the past, but unlike Cresselia - who was voted of for its defensive prowess, Milotic is prone to Spikes, making it easy to handle somewhat. Though if it was somehow immune to Spikes, it would definitely be a different story. A RestTalk Milotic is probably one of the hardest things to budge.
I'm not sure what the entry hazards thing matters. I guess I should reword that before I get jumped, but I mean, as much as grounded hazard immunity makes anything a better Pokemon, it's not too relevant to its walling ability unless the hazards are consistently turning 3HKOs to 2HKOs or 2HKOs to 1HKOs, which isn't the case for almost anything with Milotic other than Moltres (who I suspect will also be getting banned anyway). Even with full hazards (which are not nearly as hard to keep off the field as people seem to be thinking these days), Milotic walls what I would consider a majority of the metagame, since there aren't too many Pokemon who can do > 50% to it and avoid getting Recover + status stalled unless they're using a boosted attack or a super effective attack of at least 85 base power.
This has been brought up before (IIRC Yanmega's stage or the one before it) and outside of 1 or 2 nominations died out. Yes, Milotic is an annoying bitch that deserves to burn in hell, but being vulnerable to all entry hazards, having quite a few safe switch-ins (talking about the tank set here) and having a 4 moveslot syndrome (no Rest/SleepTalk/Recover/Surf/HP Grass/Haze/Ice Beam) I don't see it any close to BL. As mentioned before, I think the metagame would benefit more from her staying than the contrary.
Edit: ninja'd by Demi Lovato and that 10 year old kid by her side ._.
On the edit: Yeah I'm pretty OVER all these creepy young girl pictures so it's time for some revenge (and especially scantily clad womenz avatars like Scofield's)...
Reliable switch-ins? It's a
tank. If you switch out, it already won. ++Hazard damage, force out that the team can try to punch later, it did what it's there to do.
You don't need to use Froslass / Raikou / Venusaur / Dugtrio to be successful in this tier. Seriously I don't understand why you all constantly complain all the time. This is one of the most stable UU metagames we have the chance to play in, and yet all I see is more bickering. IMO nothing is broken this round except possibly Froslass, yet there continues to be talk about something like Milotic being broken? Are you all out of your fucking minds?
Seriously it's like you guys want to ban something, then once that gets banned you find new stuff to ban regardless of the fact that it is not broken at all. Why are you all so ban-happy? Just enjoy the metagame with an objective attitude, not this subjective bullshit of "I can't kill Milotic therefore its broken." Maybe you just don't know how to beat it, reassess your team and strategy. And to whoever said Registeel is broken, I'm sorry that is just stupid and I'll leave it at that.
On another note, if you can't use non-standard shit to win, no one is telling you to avoid using the said 'broken Pokemon'. You have a choice what to use; if you don't wanna use the more powerful Pokemon then you have no right to complain about losing because the mental block in your head is preventing you from using a winning formula aka using the best available Pokemon possible. Why do you think Ubers are almost always used in the Ubers metagame? Jesus some of the things in this thread are ridiculous. Go adapt to the metagame and figure out why you might be losing, or just quit the game.
I don't really have anything to add to this but I appreciate that you write walls of text that share my opinion so I don't have to. As much.
(EDIT: Though obviously I agree with the course of action in the Registeel/Milotic section since he is vehemently defending stall, I like the logic there since not being able to kill them is not at all my issue.)