MewtwoHidden why is whydon godfather?
-
Check out the relaunch of our general collection, with classic designs and new ones by our very own Pissog!
-
Welcome to Smogon! Take a moment to read the Introduction to Smogon for a run-down on everything Smogon, and make sure you take some time to read the global rules.
NOC Rand+++ Mafia [GAME OVER | Zombies/Jester/Lyncher/Survivor Win]
- Thread starter Panic Station
- Start date
Cult and Undead have been completely ignored...
As they should be until there's a reason to believe they exist
Both have to conform to a minimum JJ K world
You said that your JK on csyager accounts for missing mafia kill
CB - un CC'd 1 shot cop with inno on Whydon, implies rolecop existence IIII
M2H - 1S JK with guilty, implies roleblocker existence - YYY
1M set up by mistake
Energy - un CC'd rolecop
Hal - un CC'd roleblocker
All the above are mechanically clear barring future counterclaims
Whydon - cleared from SK, town or godfather
Texas - town on play, not mechanically cleared
The above are town or godfather
Claims
Acidphoenix - hated survivor (created plan to hunt hated SK)
Waterlily - survivor (early claim)
Asek - (vt)
Unclaimed - Nuxl
M2H - 1S JK with guilty, implies roleblocker existence - YYY
1M set up by mistake
Energy - un CC'd rolecop
Hal - un CC'd roleblocker
All the above are mechanically clear barring future counterclaims
Whydon - cleared from SK, town or godfather
Texas - town on play, not mechanically cleared
The above are town or godfather
Claims
Acidphoenix - hated survivor (created plan to hunt hated SK)
Waterlily - survivor (early claim)
Asek - (vt)
Unclaimed - Nuxl
Asek vt claim looks better in this lens, there should be only two vanilla towns in this setup, I'm one and he's the only other one claimed
I thought about it more and I was wrong abt that bc I jailkept csyager since the start of the night so mafia would've known that I jailkept him.
Given that nuxl and asek cannot be hated serial killer and whydon was roleblocked the only logical assumption is that there is no hated serial killer
Acid claimed hated survivor which is compatible with format two, so my conclusion is that waterlily is the SK and one of whydon/nuxl/asek is godfather
Acid claimed hated survivor which is compatible with format two, so my conclusion is that waterlily is the SK and one of whydon/nuxl/asek is godfather
What other conclusions are possible?
The Cults & Undeads from before
How do we know I'm sane?
Cut it out with the cults and undead nonsense
If they exist they must have originated among lily/acid and especially if it's cult I really don't care about them until after the Killing roles are dead
If they exist they must have originated among lily/acid and especially if it's cult I really don't care about them until after the Killing roles are dead
You're sane because no other town roles have claimed, KoC is confirmed to have mussed the setup from 0M to 1M and so you must be IIII
At bare minimum we're in JJKKSS so yes it's possible for a cult or zombie but if that's town's lose condition than so be it
Optimal play is to solve the situation at hand
Optimal play is to solve the situation at hand
What's guaranteed? JJK????
JJ is minimum, we've checked all the realistic options for hated SK except me meaning KK, and one of acid or lily is almost always telling the truth about being S, acid claiming hated survivor specifically meaning SS
The most likely outcome is simply KKK. If either is a cultist or zombie than that's revealed if/when we kill lily anyway
Which cannot be accomplished until Knights returns
Anything else on the agenda in the interim?
Anything else on the agenda in the interim?