Vote Energy
-
Welcome to Smogon! Take a moment to read the Introduction to Smogon for a run-down on everything Smogon, and make sure you take some time to read the global rules.
-
Congrats to the winners of the 2023 Smog Awards!
NOC Rand+++ Mafia [GAME OVER | Zombies/Jester/Lyncher/Survivor Win]
- Thread starter Panic Station
- Start date
we can lynch Nuxl here too, the only different is that lynch energy first lets us fulfill CBs condition if we want and guards against energy being a cultist/werewolf
...
fuck
I might have figured it out
fuck
I might have figured it out
let me find KoC's post rq
it occurs to me that we also need to lynch energy even if he is the Town Cop in order to validate his results on asek and hal
Ugh nm
I had a theory that we were actually in MMMMYYY and KoC misread Traitor and thought it was Goon but I'm not entirely sold on that.
I had a theory that we were actually in MMMMYYY and KoC misread Traitor and thought it was Goon but I'm not entirely sold on that.
also occurred to me, statistically implausible
Even if Energy's role-cop thing is a mistake, we'd still have one part of the town/mafia setup unaccounted for and nobody claimed to fill that up
It's way more plausible than IIIIYYY
MMIIYYY satisfies the requirements, assuming KoCs mistake was 1M setup instead of 2M
That would mean Energy is the role-cop gone wrong and we shouldn't lynch him
it means we lynch him anyway
also this is actively against your win con, if we dont lynch energy and energy is the cop the next lynch is nuxl
i only allow whydon to die if energy's death confirms we can safely let you win
this set up speculation doesn't actually benefit us at this point anyway
in the most likely scenario lynching nuxl ends the game
in the next most likely scenario lynching energy gives us the information we require to further understand the game
the rest is guesswork
in the most likely scenario lynching nuxl ends the game
in the next most likely scenario lynching energy gives us the information we require to further understand the game
the rest is guesswork
Right now if Energy isn't Role-Cop, he must be Jester. I cannot think of any other way he makes this play.
and after this I don't feel like giving Energy a Jester win.
Hal is confirmed roleblocker anyway
seeing as you're asking us to give you a win you aren't exactly in a position to be having an opinion on the matter
I just don't see how lynching Energy makes sense.
Fuck I'm probably going to regret this but Vote: Energy
lynching energy theoretically confirms the remaining unknown variables in the gamestate including but not limited to: his own role and asek's alignment
if his flip confirms the game state exists such that Nuxl is the only remaining enemy to town, you will be allowed to fulfill the Lyncher win con
if his flip does not do this, we need to know this sooner rather than later
if his flip confirms the game state exists such that Nuxl is the only remaining enemy to town, you will be allowed to fulfill the Lyncher win con
if his flip does not do this, we need to know this sooner rather than later
more to the point, whydon never dies before nuxl except in the circumstance where energy's flip confirms the gamestate
Okay, salt over, I'm going to have a lie down.
therefore, if the standing expectation is that the nuxl flip will end the game...
