Resource RU Tiering & Forum Rules

Status
Not open for further replies.

phantom

is a member of the Site Staffis a Community Leaderis a Community Contributoris a Top Contributoris a Tiering Contributor Alumnus
RU Leader
RU Tiering Philosophy

2 Week Voting block


Under normal circumstances, voting on initial quickbans or new drops will only occur after they’ve been in the tier for a minimum 2 weeks. We have no intention to vote on banning something just to retest it immediately after. This process has proven to be disruptive in the past and leads to hasty tiering decisions. By having time before a voting block occurs, this allows the council to make educated decisions for the tier while efficiently dealing with anything deemed broken or uncompetitive.

The case for a 1 week voting block

Only under extreme situations will we cast votes as early as one week. One of these situations is if a Pokemon is grossly overpowered to the extent that it makes the tier unplayable. Simply being “broken” will not be sufficient to take such measures, but if said Pokemon warps the tier so heavily around itself that it impedes the development of the metagame. Another case to cast votes early is if there is a significant RU tournament going on and the tier leadership chooses to hold a vote so as to not compromise the competitiveness of a large-scale tour.

Retests

We will only consider retests 6 months after a vote has occurred in a normal period (i.e. after a suspect test or voting block post-beta) or 3 months during a beta period or a 1 week voting block. Retests are moot if the metagame hasn’t been given enough time to change. If the community is dissatisfied with a vote, we want to give the tier adequate time to settle to be sure that doing a retest is the right decision rather than acting on knee-jerk reactions. We believe 6 months not only gives plenty of time, but also allows two full tier shift cycles, furthering bolstering the case for a potential retest. As with immediate voting blocks, retesting anything banned during that phase will occur sooner. This will give us a buffer in case any votes cast during beta or a week one period is deemed questionable.

The role of the RU council

The RU council is tasked with casting votes on potential suspects and nominations for voting blocks during the beta period. The tiering council serves as an advisory role to the tier leadership on any and all decisions pertaining to RU tiering. Council members are selected based on two criteria: playing ability demonstrated in tournament success and/or significant forum contributions. All council members, regardless of reasons they are selected, are expected to be consistently active and involved in the tier and to be able to articulate their tiering opinions that shows a clear understanding of the metagame. Council members are added on an as-need basis. Council members will typically include 7 members but will seldom exceed more than 9 members at any given time. Any non-Pokemon bans will exclusively be dealt with by the council. The RU Council will be formed at the start of beta and announced in this thread.

Suspect Tests

Once the tier has moved out of the beta period and has stabilized, suspects tests will occur. The tier leadership will start by holding a vote among the council. If a majority of the council agrees to a suspect (50% + 1), then a suspect test will occur. While the final call rests on the tier leadership, we will only take initiative if there is a clear split among the council with multiple options proposed and with a single decision needing to be made. We especially value community input during this phase and will ask for the public’s opinion (if it’s not already obvious) before moving forward with any decisions. Suspects tests typically last two weeks and with a focus on one Pokemon at a time. This is the chance the public has to take part in the tiering process. A simple 50% + 1 majority is required for a suspect to be sent to RUBL.

The RU council
RU Forum Rules
  • All threads must be approved by one of the forum moderators
  • Any tournaments must go through the tier leaders for approval
  • No one liners, double posts, or posts lacking content
  • All simple questions are designated to the SQSA thread
  • No posting of excessively large images
  • All other Smogon site-wide rules apply here
The forum moderators
 

EviGaro

is a Community Leaderis a Community Contributoris a Tiering Contributoris a Battle Simulator Driver
RU Leader
Hello everyone, phantom and I are proud to announce the new RU Council that will start the gen with us! We're all excited to get into beta very soon and try to help shape the tier into an enjoyable experience for you all:

atomicllamas - Former RUTL, made an early comeback to the eight gen and has been what anyone could expect. A very good overall player and leader in discussions both in public chats and the new VR Council.

Averardo - One of our most important RU contributors from late SM to currently, hosts tours, threads, has been a quality poster for a while and had his competitive debut on official team tours in the last Snake Draft. Highly respected on the PS side as well being one of our main auths in the room.

Feliburn - A member of the last RU Council, Feliburn has stayed extremely active and on top of the metagame, being one of the biggest ladder tryhards you can find while posting insightful ideas on forums like he typically did in SM and before. His continued involvement is definitely appreciated and he is without question a leading head in this tier

MrAldo - Similarly to Feli, Aldo has been around for a while now as a mod for both the forums and the room, and has been involved into helping people ease into the new RU tier through discussions around the community. His dedication to RU is impressive and we look forward to seeing it continue this gen.

Odd Della Robbia - One of RU's new star players, but ODR is more than just that. While his clutch ability definitely makes him an example for new players in the tier to look up to, ODR's approachable demeanour and willingness to commit to the tier's development is what we personally think makes him an outstanding candidate for the RU Council, as he has been nothing short of great in whatever role he took so far.
 

phantom

is a member of the Site Staffis a Community Leaderis a Community Contributoris a Top Contributoris a Tiering Contributor Alumnus
RU Leader
We got two new council members!

Ajna has been one of the top tournament players in the tier for a long time now. Ajna has consistently dominated in tournaments while also being one of the most active council members during his previous tenure. Ajna has demonstrated both a great understanding and commitment to the tier that will make him a valuable asset to the council.

Bebo is a new face to the council. Bebo is one of the tier’s most active players, consistently topping the ladder and having a good run in RU’s circuit tournaments. He’s a positive presence on discord, where he’s regularly contributing to the chat and demonstrating good meta knowledge in doing so.

Congrats to both!
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

Users Who Are Viewing This Thread (Users: 1, Guests: 0)

Top