New bans cool. Banning Fur Coat and keeping Fluffy seems fine, there might as well be some sort of draw back for better Defense stats across the board and Alolan Persian as a Pokemon was extremely useful anyways. I want to see how things develop today but still heavily in favor in getting Regenerator out of here. Guess I can finally make some wild Darmanitan team now since it can break through Fluffy mons. Want to comment on some others' posts as well.
Not sure how the banning of Fur Coat now enables this "potent" combination of Marvel Scale + Fluffy when it already existed in a
better form. I don't think this combo is that great to be completely honest. Assuming you're running Flame Orb on things to get burn and not Rest, you have to casually avoid Knock Off which is probably the most widely used attacking move in the meta and still need to be able to outlast Pressure + Prankster stall which probably just isn't going to happen. I don't want to see responses that you can just switch either because that doesn't mean that Marvel Scale + Fluffy is potent, Regenerator is just saving you. Anyways since your mons now all carry a weakness to Fire moves thanks to Fluffy you should definitely have a weak point regardless of your possibly large Defense stat. I also don't know what Hydra stall is. Hydreigon? Hydration? Not sure what else this could mean and neither of those are things, at least when considering relevant builds. Lastly I don't think Prankster was impacted too greatly. It does lose a part of its strength now that you don't need Haze for Contrary, but Prankster Haze is going to be good regardless in a meta where set-up mons are still widely spread and Unaware is unavailable.
Going to lump your two posts together because I have quarrels with both.
I would post more of my replays if I could but most of my builds illustrate Stall vs Stall and reaplys unfortunately don't go past what is it, 200 turns? So there's really no point in me saving 400 turn replays of me PP stalling and trapping my opponent until I win or of 1000 turn replays of us ending in a draw because my opponent refused to tie (this actually happened more often than I expected). Just going to throw this out there ahead of time before breaking down your post but please don't talk about your experience in OU when discussing an OM. It carries no relevance to this discussion and makes me think less of what you're trying to discuss because you aren't actually discussing this OM at times. Anywho the way you want to bans to occur is, plainly put, absurd. Complex banning any moves that could potentially provide useful stats through Contrary is so ridiculous, why would you not just ban Contrary at that point? If someone showed me this comment alone without context I would think that the person posting it is trying to be satirical by saying let's just ban every special move and keep the physical ones that utilize Contrary instead of banning the ability. This is an example of how
not to tier a meta.
Your stance on Regenerator I agree with, it needs to go. I do like seeing Fur Coat gone and Fluffy staying and this could have an interesting impact on the meta now that Fire-types are a hot commodity. A combination ban on Fluffy + Ice Scales could still be interesting to see pan out but we'll need to see how the meta changes over the next 24 hours. Also Stamina is great when paired with these abilities but you're still weak to special moves and I personally have had no trouble dealing with Stamina stall.
I think I've played maybe 1 Serene Grace team and it wasn't that great so idk how to approach this. This type of team obviously loses to Pressure Prankster stall, which also kind of invalidates Serene Grace offense. There's just no way this type of offense is going to find much success in the current meta outside of trying to compete with Quick Feet offense and subpar offensive builds. Sand Rush being the main issue with Sand Spit is banned so this problem is solved, don't really want to discuss your other points on the Sand Spit debate because I honestly think you just don't know what you're talking about when assuming Contrary + Sand Spit was the main issue or when you listed the wrong weather rock.
Item clauses aren't necessary. Knock Off is the most used attacking option in the meta and items really aren't an issue in general.
I don't see an issue with the meta changing every day at this stage, we're heavily focused on working out the kinks and removing blatant issues within the OM and honestly I enjoy building new teams for this every day. I haven't used the same team past a day and it's fun to test new ideas and try to find different ways to beat the meta. Your request for complex bans I already touched on a bit but that's just not a good way to manage a metagame and we should mainly focus on blanket bans. Otherwise this OM will become way too confusing and convoluted to the point that nobody is going to want to play it.
Another example: What about allowing the holder of the banned ability be playable with its ability but the ability is not spread to other pokemons? Might not apply to all banned abilities
Posting your part above so my response makes more sense. I assume this can potentially be coded (no idea if it can or not) but this is a bad idea. Hardcoding only say Quagsire on a team to have Unaware defeats the whole point of this meta as it's no longer a team of Shared Power, it's X amount of mons sharing and Y amount of mons not sharing. That's also not considering how confusing of a ban this would be for new players let alone whether this type of complex ban would even be necessary. I don't really see the merit in this kind of ban since you're basically crippling your own team by having however many mons not sharing abilities and it doesn't follow the OM's concept.
These observations are from someone who has sat in Top 10 for the ladder through 100+ matches for the past uhh, 5 days? I think I started playing this OM 5 days ago so whatever day I started is how long I've been there. That also isn't including the amount of private test games I've done or battles I've watched so take that was you may. Anyways that's just to reinforce my understanding of the meta because I feel like I have a strong grasp on it.