Man I get a bonus today - Joycap AND Toshiro46 posted!
JoycapJoshST said:ALL OF MY YES
In that meme nom we shall not name one of my earlier (unfortunately deleted) posts - I mentioned how the top 4 can easily beat it in a 1v1, and can pressure it out in multiple ways. Quote:
Cool. You know who also loses to these Pokemon?
- Mega Sableye
- Clefable
- Technically Toxapex too (Extrasensory from either Greninja or Dark Pulse flinch).
And these are Pokemon commonly placed on stall builds as well. I fail to see how Skarmory losing to these, and some of them it
actually beats with Counter is a death sentence to Skarmory. You have to realize that these Pokemon have multiple ways of beating some of their checks and counters in stall. Well, with the exception of Chansey which you wanted in B about a month or two ago.
Now - I'm aware that previous post was blown out of proportion in a lot of areas, to wit I apologize. However - we need to realize how Skarmory is often the weakest link on the teams it is suitable on. Let me explain:
Stall:
Since the post quoted above - I have been informed that Skarmory's role is as a staple spiker on Stall and it's Deffoger (whether it be standard SPL stall or the dual Defog 'Ciele' stall). I have come to understand this, and IMO it's fine. HOWEVER: knowing this, multiple problems start to surface.
1. There is the matter of conflicts between it setting hazards and Defogging. I mentioned this last time: Defogging is contradictory to it's own role; breaks sturdy; and because of all this, leaves too much of a burden to keep hazards off come the time. Note the offensive hazard setters that beat it - Lando-T and Greninja - are also known to heavily dent MSab, giving it no incentive to stay in. This has been fact since the start of the Generation with the advent of Z-moves, which I will come back to later.
Why do you need to be "informed" on something that would be bloody obvious from A) Observation and B) from
playing the damned game?
Multiple teams run Defog and entry hazards regardless if it is stall, balance, and even Hyper Offense to some extent. Defog is a crucial element to stall because:
- It prevents other walls from being put into specific KO ranges or being worn down faster
- Or, the real issue, keeps Dugtrio's Focus Sash intact
I don't get how Defogging "breaks" Sturdy when a Skarmory can easily Defog from full health and still have Sturdy afterwards (force the opponent to switch out?). That's why you have either Mega Sableye or another Defogger on the team - to prevent the above scenarios from happening to stall frequently. If Stealth Rock remains on the field it puts Clefable at high risk of being 2HKOed by Thundurus-I's Thunderbolt for example while Stealth Rock and Spikes can chip Toxapex into 2HKO or OHKO ranges much easier.
Personally, I don't think Spikes is a
must for the stall team, but it is highly recommended. Spikes is probably the most replaceable move next to Counter here, as I've seen variants use Whirlwind / Counter as well as Taunt / Counter or using Brave Bird / Whirlwind too. Spikes are really hard to turn down, though, for what it's worth.
2. It's heavily constrained by it's item choice - it being in most cases Shed Shell to stop it being trapped by Magnezone.
It's really funny you say that, because Toxapex has also run into the conundrum that it needs to use Shed Shell in order to stay safe against Dugtrio, but it also means that Toxapex is easier to wear down. For example, the "standard" Toxapex takes about ~40% damage from Solar Beam from Zard Y. That's
really bad when Chansey could potentially be down for the count by Dugtrio, which is the most likely scenario since Chansey is a guaranteed trap with it being forced to hold Eviolite. Skarmory being "constrained" by Shed Shell is almost a non-factor - it makes trapping Skarmory that much harder to do, which makes it more difficult for a Pokemon that Skarmory reliably checks and no other stall team members can - which is Mega Pinsir.
To that, I bring up this quote once again from reyscarface regarding Dugtrio stall, from the suspect test:
Knock Off Landorus + Magnezone teams completely dumpster Stall, as the first mon youll bring into Landorus is always going to be Skarmory.
I'm not saying that reyscarface is incorrect for this statement, but Landorus-T also has a slew of issues such as the amount of moves it wants to run before Knock Off. Let's look from usage stats all the way up to 1825 from last month alone just for "ladders" sake:
Hide
| Moves | | Earthquake 99.566% | | Stealth Rock 75.915% | | U-turn 58.305% | | Hidden Power Ice 45.022% | | Stone Edge 29.044% | | Swords Dance 24.810% | | Fly 15.835% | | Explosion 13.730% | | Knock Off 11.636% | | Smack Down 8.528% | | Other 17.610%
And that was before Smack Down (and Gravity) really caught on for Landorus-Therian. Consider that other moves are also missing from here: Toxic and Protect. There's also that Magnezone is #3 for Landorus-Therian's partners - not even raking 5%:
Hide
| Teammates | | Magearna +7.460% | | Medicham-Mega +5.682% | | Magnezone +4.776% |
Landorus-Therian also has to be quite offensive to pull off the successful role of this, and it can't reliably KO things properly until things have been chipped a bit (either by Stealth Rock or just stall mons taking passive damage). For example: Impish Landorus-Therian does jack shit to Chansey (0 Atk Landorus-Therian Earthquake vs. 248 HP / 252+ Def Eviolite Chansey: 196-232 (27.8 - 33%) -- guaranteed 4HKO) and isn't that great against Mega Sableye (0 Atk Landorus-Therian Earthquake vs. 248 HP / 116 Def Sableye-Mega: 111-132 (36.6 - 43.5%) -- guaranteed 3HKO). I also want to point out that in scenarios such as Magnezone + Landorus-Therian vs stall, stall may opt to switch to Mega Sableye before Skarmory to predict the Knock Off. Even then, stall is not guaranteed to lose Skarmory right away to Magnezone. There are potential scenarios where the stall player could predict Magnezone switching into Skarmory and going straight for Dugtrio - banking that it has Focus Sash to at least risk the play.
While it's true what reyscarface states is
correct, there is a lot more to the story here. Using Knock Off Landorus-Therian definitely helps, but chances are you're probably using it more for Mega Pinsir - not for Landorus-Therian itself. This is because the offensive sets usually incorporate Stealth Rock, Swords Dance, or both into their sets. Defensive sets also have a lot of moves to choose from as well.
I also don't understand your argument, furthermore, about Skarmory being the weakest link to stall. Let's review a few posts:
Old VR Post, but note the teams
If you look at the composition between these teams, they all have one thing in common (theoretically there should be
2, but some people have this stupid opinion that Chansey is a replaceable stall teammate ???) - all of them carry Skarmory. Another stall team that was run within WCoP also incorporated another stall team where Landorus-Therian wouldn't do much - that being Tangrowth / Quagsire. Though arguably also defunct like many of the stall teams listed here, the biggest outlier is this -
Skarmory is used on almost all of them.
Obviously, there are exceptions - Eo Ut Mortus is an oddball and doesn't like using the standard norm for stall, like, ever but we still love him. Overall though - what is considered the strongest of stall still uses Skarmory 100% of the time - making it difficult to be a replaced Pokemon. If you replace it with Zapdos you have a rougher time because then you rely heavily on Mega Sableye to block back Stealth Rock and you have Zapdos taking a lot of damage when you do switch into Stealth Rock.
SM OU Sample Teams
And would you look at that - both of those teams have Skarmory in them. Man for being the "weakest link" it sure shows when Toxapex was replaced for Alomomola in one of them.
There is a reason... no... multiple reasons why I quote this once again.
Firstly, I understand Rey' to be a top OUPL/SPL player - and I am mentioning this as, in my honest opinion, one of the best posts regarding G7 stall in this forum's history. I don't watch a lot of top-level Smogon play, I must confess - but in the video regarding Dugtrio by aim and njnp - he is bought up multiple times:
I'm not bothering with this video honestly - too long and a few people have told me a summary of it.
Basically from what I can guess - it mentions how players like rey have had a very high success rate with stall in SPL, though stall has coincidentally had a rather up and down ratio in WCoP - that is, if you paid any attention to it.
I'll give you this link so you can be caught "up-to-date".
Secondly - Skarmory is the only Pokemon protecting SPL Stall from being trampled on by strong Grass and Ground type spam (two types Dugtrio isn't known to trap in this metagame, mind you). But when it is removed from play this easily by a core this splashable, I begin to wonder how certain players even have a problem with the standard SabStall.
Man it's like this Pokemon doesn't exist anymore:
But I get it - you really want to lose to this Pokemon too. Throttling Tapu Bulu isn't enough for Skarmory I guess. Pack up boys and girls.
Before anyone jumps on me for this, I do understand that Magnezone did drop not too long ago due to the influx of Fire types in the metagame (Zard Y; Tran; Awak etc.). Now answer me this: how does the influx of Fire types help Skarmory in the slightest if it forces Zone to drop?
Skarmory is an interesting case where, while it draws in these threats, stall does have some appropriate answers to these too. Mega Sableye can attempt to stall out quite a bit of Heatran provided that Mega Sableye doesn't power it up. Zard Y still has to answer to Toxapex and Chansey in the standard spl stall, though it only answers to Chansey against Ciele's which makes Ciele's kind of iffy sometimes. Finally, there's Alolan Marowak which, I agree that it can do some damage, but it also can be worn down by Toxic and Stealth Rock while being forced out 100% of the time by Dugtrio if Alolan Marowak KOes something. Even Alolan Marowak is not enough sometimes to break stall alone, but that's because stall is more like a game of chess than it is a standard game.
Balance:
The main thing that I think warrants a Skarmory drop regarding Balance is it's weakness to Z-Move lures. Balance is already the worst playstyle in the current metagame solely due to Z-moves and their offensive / coverage applications (see Grassium Heatran; Waterium Scolipede and others like Electrium Tapu Lele and the 3 forms of Z-Move Garchomp (namely Firium)), and Skamory's weakness to all of the above only makes this worse. Throw in it's passive nature and weakness to Taunt (which Balance has very few means of consistently stopping) and soon enough this bird becomes extremely dead weight.
You literally could not be further from the truth. I can't even believe you would make such an absurd statement. If you even
watched or
played ANY recent SM OU you would know that balance has become a lot better in the current setup.
Just look at some of the fucking replays from later weeks if you don't believe me.
Possibly lower when Duggy eventually leaves - but that's for the there and then.
:cwl:
Joycap, I say this in the nicest way possible, but I think it would be worthwhile to either play the game or do extensive research before making such absurd claims in the future. Yes, I understand that Marrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrr made the nomination prior to, and yes I realize that I am personally looking at your response before his; however, the failure to realize that Skarmory is more of a team player that is supposed to check physically inclined threats (which it still can fairly well, but it is a bit pressured by some I admit) and rattling off Pokemon that it should never face (Magearna?) obviously shows the failure to comprehend Skarmory's role in defensive teams. Furthermore, it still has roles in Hyper Offensive teams as a suicide lead that can lay down Spikes and Stealth Rock while scaring off Mega Sableye with Supersonic Skystrike and Skarmory with Taunt. This, however, does not excuse you from your constant poor posting that has shown and continued to show within the OU VR as well as within the forums.
Oh, and if it isn't obvious by my tl;dr -
Skarmory to remain in A-. Skarmory is a pivotal team player in stall and, while it draws in Fire-types, stall teammates and balance does have some responses to these threats. In fairness, Clefable (and even Mega Sableye) also draw in Heatran and are ranked about the same or even higher.
===
Now for the dessert:
Toshiro46 said:In theory, these calcs are pretty impressive, but the issue is that Camerupt is so slow that it's going to have to take a hit before it can deal damage back, which means, unfortunately, that it can't switch into much and in a scenario against these mons (Bar Magearna, which it does do very well against) is only going to get one attack off before being revenged.
Sure, you could put it on Trick Room, but Ash Greninja would fuck you for days, and Ash Gren is already one of the biggest threats to TR teams as is.
Robopoke and a few others have explain this better, but the goal of Mega Camerupt is to be a balance disruption. Celesteela, Toxapex, Clefable, and Tangrowth do not enjoy seeing this Pokemon and the potential doubling into Mega Camerupt makes it deadly. Very few Pokemon can reliably switch into Sheer Force Fire Blast and Earth Power. To compare - Latios still takes a significant chunk (40%) from Fire Blast and Mega Charizard Y has to always be careful of Rock Slide (nevermind that Fire Blast in sun does a good 55%+).
I think Mega Camerupt being a fairly good balance breaker in the current metagame with access to tools that a lot of balance teams love (Magearna, Koko, and Zapdos resistance) really help its case to rise. I agree that it's a pretty underrated Pokemon and, used properly, is difficult for a lot of balance teams to answer outside of being faster than it (and faster threats hate switching into it). I think C+ is more fitting for it personally since it's still a niche mon, but it's much better than Pokemon like Gliscor that have very little-to-no relevant niches left in the SM OU Metagame that a lot of teams desire.