vote M2H
i'm pretty much caught up. kicking up some dust for now, since this isn't a version of M2H i've seen before & passivity is at a high. i thought i remembered them saying they could be busy at some point so it's possible that's factoring in, i couldn't find the post looking back. even with that, something feels off here compared to typical M2H D1s and i wouldn't be surprised to see the "let's massclaim" through the megaphone be an attempt to come across looking like a villager attempting to force progress or something, seems like an approach they'd take as mafia
here's where i'm at roughly for my early village build:
townread: lechen, angrypidgeon
townlean: ehmcee
light townlean: dead by daylight, pulsar(?)
lechen is a read i feel pretty confident in, partially secret reasons but feel free to ask questions if you have any doubts here
angrypidgeon has trended up throughout the course of the day to the point where they'd have to be powerwolfing out of their mind and i'm not gonna entertain that at the moment considering they're the closest thing to a townleader we have, so i'm penciling in their slot as town for now. nothing feels in bad faith enough to have concerns that they're attempting to steer the ship in the wrong direction and even though i don't see level with some of their reads & think some of those townreads are hasty, it doesn't reflect poorly on their alignment
ehmcee i continue to feel good about bar that 1 strange recent post that may have just been me misunderstanding, still not at a place where he compares to the above two for me when i lay my cards out on the table so i'm keeping him a tier down for now
dead by daylight i have more subdued reasons for including where i did, but basically i think that the way he's posting feels "alone" and not like he's being coached. for example, i think the post about the neon policy is something that doesn't get hurled into the night sky in the way he did there if he's mafia without being discussed in a mafia chat first, but this is also rooted in my understanding that he's relatively new to the game
Dead by Daylight how many games have you played prior to this if you don't mind sharing? sorry if i'm incorrect about the above & you do have more experience, i just don't think we've been in a game together or that i've spectated one you've been in
pulsar i've been back and forth on more than anyone else here and i struggle to read her consistently for some reason, but there's been more positive than negative so far and i liked this stretch of posts. there's a level of comfortability here that mafia generally struggle to emulate when laying down reads in thread. it's only bad if she was partnered with ehmcee, but i'm leaning ehmcee town anyways, so i'm stowing away that tinfoil
also, not aligned on the alice townread as of now AngryPidgeon, so would appreciate if you can shed some light on that when possible
i'm pretty much caught up. kicking up some dust for now, since this isn't a version of M2H i've seen before & passivity is at a high. i thought i remembered them saying they could be busy at some point so it's possible that's factoring in, i couldn't find the post looking back. even with that, something feels off here compared to typical M2H D1s and i wouldn't be surprised to see the "let's massclaim" through the megaphone be an attempt to come across looking like a villager attempting to force progress or something, seems like an approach they'd take as mafia
here's where i'm at roughly for my early village build:
townread: lechen, angrypidgeon
townlean: ehmcee
light townlean: dead by daylight, pulsar(?)
lechen is a read i feel pretty confident in, partially secret reasons but feel free to ask questions if you have any doubts here
angrypidgeon has trended up throughout the course of the day to the point where they'd have to be powerwolfing out of their mind and i'm not gonna entertain that at the moment considering they're the closest thing to a townleader we have, so i'm penciling in their slot as town for now. nothing feels in bad faith enough to have concerns that they're attempting to steer the ship in the wrong direction and even though i don't see level with some of their reads & think some of those townreads are hasty, it doesn't reflect poorly on their alignment
ehmcee i continue to feel good about bar that 1 strange recent post that may have just been me misunderstanding, still not at a place where he compares to the above two for me when i lay my cards out on the table so i'm keeping him a tier down for now
dead by daylight i have more subdued reasons for including where i did, but basically i think that the way he's posting feels "alone" and not like he's being coached. for example, i think the post about the neon policy is something that doesn't get hurled into the night sky in the way he did there if he's mafia without being discussed in a mafia chat first, but this is also rooted in my understanding that he's relatively new to the game
Dead by Daylight how many games have you played prior to this if you don't mind sharing? sorry if i'm incorrect about the above & you do have more experience, i just don't think we've been in a game together or that i've spectated one you've been in
pulsar i've been back and forth on more than anyone else here and i struggle to read her consistently for some reason, but there's been more positive than negative so far and i liked this stretch of posts. there's a level of comfortability here that mafia generally struggle to emulate when laying down reads in thread. it's only bad if she was partnered with ehmcee, but i'm leaning ehmcee town anyways, so i'm stowing away that tinfoil
also, not aligned on the alice townread as of now AngryPidgeon, so would appreciate if you can shed some light on that when possible
