The lack of Deoxys-D in top 20 is confusing me.....also its ok to ban Poli but not TTar?
Gen 4 mentality FTL....
Tyranitar is just one of those Pokemon that is hard to place. Those stats and that ability on any other Pokemon, yeah, that would be ban material. But Tyranitar's typing is what keeps it at bay. Rock/Dark is not exactly a 5-star typing. Weakness to some of the most common types; Fighting, Ground, Bug, Steel, Water, & Grass, only made up for by resisting some of the least common types in the game; Normal, Flying, Poison, Ghost, & Dark, with an immunity to Psychic.
Banning Tyranitar wouldn't exactly solve much anyway as Hippowdon is still around to put up Sand Storm. Hell, as long as Excadrill exists, people would even use Hippopotas if Hippowdon somehow got the shaft. Tyranitar is scarcely the problem, hell Sand Stream isn't even the problem.
The problem with Sand is that a 405 Attack power Steel/Ground-type Pokemon with Swords Dance and perfect Type coverage becomes faster than Deoxys-S when Sand Stream is active.
Aside from Garchomp, that's about the biggest change to Sand in 2 Gens.
Even if Excadrill isn't #1 on the statistics, you have to admit that on & even off paper, Excadrill defines broken.
But back on topic, Politoed makes the #1 Pokemon damn near impossible to OHKO & makes an already strong type of Pokemon even stronger. So yes, Politoed is kind of ban-able but, in reality, he's more of just a scapegoat for Ferrothorn is what I've come to realize. It's basically this:
"We don't don't want to ban Ferrothorn because we like using him, even if he has completely centered the metagame around himself making a lot of Pokemon completely nonviable."
That right there is why Ferrothorn will never be banned even though he fits the ban criteria even more than Excadrill and why people will always bitch about Rain. This is all coming from someone that uses Sun Teams. I'm giving Rain a pass and coming after the real issues to the rest of the metagame.