confirming as NFEmankoslayer
:linoone-galar::haunter::gastly::machoke::piloswine::brionne: please don't use this team
proof of reqs
as anyone who's spoken to me in the last few days knows, i will be voting
ban in the machoke suspect. here's why.
PumpedAaron said:I don't have the reqs, but between Hatterene, Vullaby, Brionne, and many others, Machoke actually has a lot of checks and counters. Sure Flame Orb choke can be a little difficult to Switch into, but if you invest in a little extra bulk, its easily doable.
PumpedAaron can you go into some more detail on this? i've listed a bunch of calcs below and i really can't see which mons can "invest in a little extra bulk" to "easily" take on flame orb machoke. as far as i can see knock off allows machoke to break through every single one of its defensive answers with ease.
defensive pokemon that cannot switch into machoke
252+ Atk Guts :Machoke: Knock Off (97.5 BP) vs. 252 HP / 252+ Def Eviolite :Hattrem:: 182-216 (57.2 - 67.9%)
machoke outspeeds and 2HKOs defensive hattrem
252+ Atk Guts :Machoke: Knock Off (97.5 BP) vs. 252 HP / 252+ Def Eviolite :Corsola-Galar:: 140-166 (43.2 - 51.2%) -- 5.9% chance to 2HKO, 98.8% chance to 2HKO after Stealth Rock
cannot switch into knock off reliably, pretty much only checks it if it gets cursed body off or is paired with a knock off absorber like koffing or gloom that can bait it into clicking CC or facade
252+ Atk Guts :Machoke: Knock Off (97.5 BP) vs. 252 HP / 252+ Def Eviolite :Clefairy:: 53-63 (15.4 - 18.3%)
252+ Atk Guts :Machoke: Heavy Slam (120 BP) vs. 252 HP / 252+ Def Eviolite :Clefairy:: 264-312 (76.7 - 90.6%)
dies to heavy slam most of the time, forced into a 50/50 between clicking moonblast (giving up all momentum if wrong) and clicking literally anything else (losing clefairy if wrong)
defensive pokemon that can switch into machoke once, but not after that
252+ Atk Guts :Machoke: Knock Off (97.5 BP) vs. 252 HP / 252+ Def Eviolite :Gloom:: 88-104 (27.1 - 32%)
252+ Atk Guts :Machoke: Facade (140 BP) vs. 252 HP / 252+ Def :Gloom:: 188-222 (58 - 68.5%)
has a chance to die, near guaranteed if rocks are up. cc into facade is also a roll to kill heavily in machoke's favour.
252+ Atk Guts :Machoke: Knock Off (97.5 BP) vs. 252 HP / 252+ Def Eviolite :Charjabug:: 73-86 (22.9 - 27%)
252+ Atk Guts :Machoke: Facade (140 BP) vs. 252 HP / 252+ Def :Charjabug:: 156-184 (49 - 57.8%)
does 25% with volt switch, thus is reliant on an offensive check to machoke to actually deal with this. only switches in once, or 0 times if rocks are up.
also, is forced into a 50/50 between actually clicking volt switch (giving up all momentum if wrong) and clicking literally anything else (not only losing charjabug but also losing sticky web)
252+ Atk Guts :Machoke: Knock Off (97.5 BP) vs. 252 HP / 252+ Def Eviolite :Machoke:: 44-52 (12 - 14.2%)
252+ Atk Guts :Machoke: Close Combat vs. 252 HP / 252+ Def Eviolite :Machoke:: 162-192 (44.5 - 52.7%)
is forced to pick between clicking dynamic punch (giving up all momentum if wrong) and clicking literally anything else (losing machoke if wrong)
252+ Atk Guts :Machoke: Knock Off (97.5 BP) vs. 252 HP / 252 Def Eviolite :Dartrix:: 92-109 (25.5 - 30.2%)
252+ Atk Guts :Machoke: Facade (140 BP) vs. 252 HP / 252 Def :Dartrix:: 198-234 (55 - 65%)
same deal as above, also can't switch in if rocks are up
252+ Atk Guts :Machoke: Knock Off (97.5 BP) vs. 248 HP / 252+ Def Eviolite :Vullaby:: 42-50 (12.2 - 14.5%)
252+ Atk Guts :Machoke: Close Combat vs. 248 HP / 252+ Def :Vullaby:: 232-274 (67.6 - 79.8%)
252+ Atk Guts :Machoke: Facade (140 BP) vs. 248 HP / 252+ Def :Vullaby:: 181-213 (52.7 - 62%)
read dartrix, but also machoke is arguably the only reason this thing wants to run brave bird over utility moves like knock off or foul play atm
252+ Atk Guts :Machoke: Knock Off (97.5 BP) vs. 248 HP / 252+ Def Eviolite :Mudbray:: 88-104 (25.6 - 30.3%)
252+ Atk Guts :Machoke: Close Combat vs. +1 248 HP / 252+ Def :Mudbray:: 162-192 (47.2 - 55.9%)
do i need to say it again tho
252+ Atk burned :Machoke: Knock Off (97.5 BP) vs. 252 HP / 252+ Def Eviolite :Koffing:: 24-29 (8.4 - 10.2%)
252+ Atk :Machoke: Facade (140 BP) vs. 252 HP / 252+ Def :Koffing:: 104-123 (36.6 - 43.3%)
by far the best defensive answer, can't switch into two facades but it at least takes multiple CCs unlike everything else on this list
defensive pokemon that can switch into machoke more than once
there's a few pokemon i missed off this list like palpitoad and hippopotas but you get the idea; i've been pretty repetitive thus far.
BP said:The argument that Machoke keeps several Pokemon that have the potential to be busted in check may not be a strong argument but it's one that I believe holds way more weight than it does currently. Machoke may be unhealthy but its keeping a plethora of Pokemon in check that otherwise would be busted such as Klang, Piloswine, Linoone-Galar, etc. My philosophy here is would you rather suffer from the Stomach Flu (Machoke) or Stomach Cancer (the plethora of mons that become busted). I would like to reiterate that this argument is definitely flawed and is not my only reason for wanting to keep Machoke in the meta.
this is an understandable position to take, but this is not considered to be and never has been considered to be a legitimate argument to hold. i fully expect some pokemon (though it's hard to say which yet) to be broken with the absence of machoke, but at the same time, physdef mons like mudbray and clef that are currently being pissed on by machoke will also be more viable in response to these threats; it's not as simple as "klang will be broken" when theoretical klang answers are currently being held back by machoke's presence. it's impossible to say.
also, if a pokemon is broken after machoke is gone, council will put forward a suspect or quickban for said pokemon. there's absolutely no reason to keep a broken mon in the tier just to avoid the hassle of banning something else later.
BP said:As previously stated, the most busted Machoke set is undoubtedly Flame Orb. This set certainly has its flaws, the most prevalent being that it has a very lackluster speed tier and is terribly frail. This leads to it being taken advantage of by faster Choiced attackers that are looking to revenge kill. Addtionally, Machoke's Flame Orb set isn't really its preferred set to begin with because of the support it requires. Its defensive set is much more preferable due to what it provides the team.
i'm not sure where this myth came from but machoke does not have a lackluster speed tier and is not "terribly frail". machoke is easily pressured by many offensive pokemon like brionne and haunter, yes, but its speed tier puts it ahead of every single defensive pokemon in the tier (i.e. its main targets), effectively guaranteeing at least one kill, typically far more, in every game. its also fast enough to reach the equivalent a positive natured base 80 pokemon when under webs, with only a handful of offensive pokemon like raboot and linoone actually creeping it
as far as bulk goes, lets go back to some of the defensive answers i mentioned up above
0 SpA
:Gloom: Sludge Bomb vs. 0 HP / 4 SpD
:Machoke:: 127-151 (42.1 - 50.1%)
8 Atk
:Mudbray: Earthquake vs. 0 HP / 0 Def
:Machoke:: 145-172 (48.1 - 57.1%)
0 SpA
:Clefairy: Moonblast vs. 0 HP / 4 SpD
:Machoke:: 204-242 (67.7 - 80.3%)
0 SpA
:Koffing: Sludge Bomb vs. 0 HP / 4 SpD
:Machoke:: 97-115 (32.2 - 38.2%)
and even some offensive answers
252 Atk
:Linoone-Galar: Double-Edge vs. 0 HP / 0 Def Machoke: 175-207 (58.1 - 68.7%)
252+ SpA
:Wartortle: Hydro Pump vs. 0 HP / 4 SpD Machoke: 189-223 (62.7 - 74%)
252+ Atk
:Piloswine: Earthquake vs. 0 HP / 0 Def Machoke: 201-237 (66.7 - 78.7%)
is flame orb machoke tanky? not especially. but killing a flame orb machoke is far more difficult than "pressure it with a faster pokemon" because you're often sacking something to get the initial damage to actually allow that to happen in the first place. the reason these one time switchins aren't enough for machoke to be a healthy presence is that if the machoke user chooses they can very easily stay in on the supposed "counter" as gloom clicks synthesis or charjabug clicks sticky web knowing they're still trading for a guaranteed kill even if the opponent picks the offensive option. alternatively, if they want to preserve machoke for later, they can do that too. there's often very little risk involved on the part of the machoke user and a lot of risk involved on the other side, although this'll change on a game to game basis.
on that note, how exactly are people bringing in these offensive checks? the lack of any pivot that can actually switch into machoke (barring charjabug once) means that these pokemon (e.g. haunter, specs brionne) can't actually come in until machoke's already claimed one; this often leads to situations reminiscent of shadow tag/arena trap, in that the defensive user has to avoid ever having certain defensive pokemon weakened (hattrem) or on the field at all (slow piloswine, ferroseed) because machoke can either pivot in via something like clef or sometimes just hard switch in, and claim a kill every time. the best machoke answer, koffing, still has to trade its life to actually take out machoke (and by take out machoke i mean chip it down to 10-20%)
to sum up, as soon as something on the field is in range of machoke's knock off, it's practically guaranteed a kill, and if something is in range of machoke's CC it becomes a guessing game that is very much in favour of the machoke user
also, while heavy slam is useful for taking on clefairy, it can easily be dropped for bullet speed which really puts a lot of stress on the opponent to keep their offensive checks healthy, with bullet punch doing up to 57.5% to non-eviolite haunter, up to 55.1% on specs roselia, 65.6% to offensive morgrem, etc. etc.
BP said:Physically defensive Machoke is by far the most used set do to the sheer amount of defensive support it provides for its teammates. This set can easily be taken advantage of by Knock Off users such as Vullaby, phys def Clefairy, Dartrix, and Mareanie. After becoming subject to a Knock Off, Machoke is much less of a defensive wall. A majority of Special attackers can KO it with a super effective move. Additionally, Corsola-Galar's trapping set completely demolishes defenisve Machoke, with or without Eviolite.
physically defensive machoke is definitely not the most used set. bulky offensive utility eviolite sets are by far the most common, especially if you include all the variants of the standard set (e.g. encore, bulk up/sub, ice punch) that slot over machoke's coverage moves from time to time.
that aside, i personally don't feel that eviolite should be considered at all in this suspect; while some sets do abuse machoke's switchins harder (sub bulk up abusing charjabug, for example), flame orb genuinely has no answers regardless and machoke's set is typically revealed pretty early on - flame orb specifically is the banworthy set, not eviolite. adding that to the mix just confuses things because yes eviolite has a variety of reasonably safe defensive answers.
BP said:I've left this out of my argument regarding banning Machoke because it should not be taken into account. Thus I have not taken it into account regarding my opinion. That being said, If I'm going to weigh in on this I'll be honest. I personally would not ban Machoke with how close DLC is. We'll be getting a bunch of new Pokemon and we'll be retesting it and other Pokemon anyway. If worst comes to worst we can just Quick Ban it once the DLC meta finally settles. If we do ban it however we'll have to reintroduce it and wait for the council to make a decision on whether or not its busted which will most likely be awhile considering it took forever for this suspect test to come to fruition (this is not a jab at council).
like you said, this should not be taken into account for the same reasons as the "
what if X mon is broken without machoke around?" theory. pokemon like scyther and tangela can check machoke in theory, but may be banned, or considered unviable for other reasons (unlikely but the whole point of this is everything is hypothetical). if pokemon like tangela are healthy, machoke can see a resuspect later on easily. this is not a valid argument.
TL;DR:
arguments against do not ban
- "Machoke has switchins"
no it doesn't
- "Machoke is slow"
not really
- "Machoke is frail"
nah
arguments for ban:
Monsareeasy said:
- Flame Orb Machoke promotes unhealthy predictions. It is generally more of a guessing game than thinking long term. These predictions most of the time
do not reward the better player. reward the machoke user.
- Flame Orb Machoke has no counters.
- Flame Orb Machoke almost completely invalidates balances and fatter play styles (This also enables Haunter due to haunter preying on offensive teams).
final addendum: haunter should have been banned months ago due to the huge limitations it forces on team building and i hope to see it go at some stage after the dlc battlefield clears a bit. shoutout to
tlenit1 for being a good friend also.